Cr1 Visa Denial letter. what to do next ??

[Imran99 11]

3 minutes ago, Duke & Marie said:

The refusal has nothing to do with requested info..

 

its financial / public charge

O really I didn't know that 

Thanks for telling me great information 

[SalishSea 16,772]

1 minute ago, Imran99 said:

O really I didn't know that 

Thanks for telling me great information 

Maybe read the letter appended to OP’s post if you need clarification?

[Imran99 11]

2 minutes ago, Imran99 said:

O really I didn't know that 

Thanks for telling me great information 

Denials come along with other factors that you are not fulfilling either.It has to do something with relationships history and bonafide 

[SalishSea 16,772]

Just now, Imran99 said:

Denials come along with other factors that you are not fulfilling either.It has to do something with relationships history and bonafide 

Well yes, but this denial is specifically due to the public charge, as stated in the letter.

[Downloader 197]

9 minutes ago, Imran99 said:

Denials come along with other factors that you are not fulfilling either.It has to do something with relationships history and bonafide 

A week ago he was asking very basic questions about a i-130.....Today he is a Visa Zen Master already.

Good for you buddy!

[Imran99 11]

6 minutes ago, Downloader said:

A week ago he was asking very basic questions about a i-130.....Today he is a Visa Zen Master already.

Good for you 

I didn't know you are the founder of this website.

[Downloader 197]

58 minutes ago, Imran99 said:

I didn't know you are the founder of this website.

Nor did I. 

[Pinkrlion 2,607]

1 hour ago, Jorgedig said:

Well yes, but this denial is specifically due to the public charge, as stated in the letter.

The letter was specific that the denial was due to public charge.  There was no reason to question anything else they submitted to prove bonafides.  Google - Denial for public charge and it will give you more information.

[kris&me 572]

7 hours ago, Sunny_Skies said:

Do they seriously deny you if the immigrant doesn't have a good job? My fiancé has had a stable work but only in grocery stores. He was at one for a couple of years, went to a warehouse, got laid off after two months, and went to another grocery store. I would hate to see us denied over that.

 

I really hope that everything works out you and your wife!

no,  immigrant's job is not the basis for the income

but,  the CO in many embassies will ask "what plans do you have for life in the US?"

they want to know if the person plans to work or study or have any idea what is expected 

[SalishSea 16,772]

24 minutes ago, Pinkrlion said:

The letter was specific that the denial was due to public charge.  There was no reason to question anything else they submitted to prove bonafides.  Google - Denial for public charge and it will give you more information.

Think you quoted me instead of the OP 😉

[Nitas_man 3,100]

4 hours ago, Imran99 said:

You don't have to worry.It can be overcome by writing an affidavit on both sides that you will not become a public charge. 

When did you start your process??

Cr1 or Ir1 ???

This is the post of the month

[SusieQQQ 11,584]

3 hours ago, Imran99 said:

Some people have nothing to do except making fun of people.if you can't help in this situation at least you can give them courage 

That’s different than giving bad advice - and false hope - about doing meaningless affidavits. 

[Villanelle 4,121]

Im interested in what the answers were on the sworn statement he was asked to provide were (posted in another thread). It was asking him to list the  number of people the USC supports and other members that live in the house and their income sources. It seems the USC works a minimum or low paying job and based on what he says there are also 4 other adult (children?) in the house. I suspect they are either unemployed or under employed and perhaps may even be using social service programs.  So it would seem even though her household size can technically be 2 on the 864 (if she doesnt claim the adult children on taxes) but she should actually have a higher household size if she accounted for them on the 864 as her dependents. So it seems they are considering her to have a higher household size based on the fact she does support the children. 

 

The only solution here is a change in circumstances. He can further his education and obtain degrees to secure a well paying job after completion or if school is not his thing there are plenty of trades or jobs that provide on the job training that after 1-2 yrs with them he could be certified in some field. Another scenario would be for her to reduce the size of her household. It may be time for her adult children to leave the nest. 

 

[Sunny_Skies 22]

21 hours ago, dentsflogged said:

My guess would be it's the sum of the circumstances. 

Job hopping isn't uncommon and wouldn't be an issue so long as employment is consistent (rather than the job) and income exceeds the minimum requirement. 

Job hopping + a huge age gap + other factors that don't match up (ie: beneficiary claims to not be working as they "must" look after an ill parent despite applying for an immigrant visa would would take them away from said parent that needs so much nursing that beneficiary can't work?) + Petitioner being almost at retirement age = a group of circumstances that would make most CO's do a major double-take. 

I make above the income requirements (43 k) a year and he has had stable employment. So I'm hoping that's enough!

[Ontarkie 13,917]

~~Hijack post removed, Do not post questions for your own case in other members threads. Related reply also removed~~