Denial at uscis

[analyncortez32 3]

I wonder who among you here got denied at uscis after RFE? What did you do? Are USCIS tiers 2 reliable telling you over the phone that your petition is denied? 

[debbiedoo 2,339]

most RFE's do not result in denials. Most of them are simple information that wasn't included or not enough info given.

 

I'm not sure if they would tell you over the phone that you were denied. But to be denied at the petition stage I (think) is pretty uncommon. its more likely to happen at the consulate stage.

 

Did you receive an RFE/what was it for?

[BJ & Christine 1,392]

Denial at uscis stage after petition receives a rfe are do to petitioner not fully reading what was stated on rfe and not sending in what uscis requested. 

Does it happen. YES. Will it happen again? Ubetcha it will. 

Not sure if teir 2 can tell u if u been denied or not. Most the time the information u recieve from uscis over the phone is sketchy at best. Many been told one thing and next person they speak to says something completely different. 

Until u have hard copy in hand take what uscis says with a grain of salt.

[debbiedoo 2,339]

27 minutes ago, BJ & Christine said:

Denial at uscis stage after petition receives a rfe are do to petitioner not fully reading what was stated on rfe and not sending in what uscis requested. 

Does it happen. YES. Will it happen again? Ubetcha it will. 

 

This is true, they are tightening down on people who can't complete basic instructions and opting many times for a flat out denial instead of an RFE(as well they should). BUT if an RFE was issued, that doesn't seem to be what happened here (assuming RFE is responded to appropriately and accurately) .

 

 

Edited October 13, 2018 by debbiedoo

[Carpe Vinum 2,308]

If it is not sensitive....What was your RFE for?

[usmsbow 795]

I know this much: tier 2 and reliable don't go together unless the word NOT appears right before reliable. 

 

 

[geowrian 22,335]

Most (the overwhelming majority actually) I-129Fs are approved. There are not a lot of requirements for the I-129F and they are mostly pretty black and white on if you meet them or not. Just the evidence of meeting within 2 years is the biggest unknown on what evidence is enough.

Many people get an RFE. Most have an approval afterwards. Some will get a denial because they either didn't respond or responded incompletely or they simply did not meet the requirements (and therefore cannot provide a satisfactory response).

An RFE is not a sign of an impending denial. Most are for pretty minor things that just need to be checked off to meet the requirements of the law or policy.

[Illiria 980]

I found this site https://www.uscis.gov/laws/admin-decisions?topic_id=1&newdir=D6+-+Fiancees+and+Fiances+of+U.S.+Citizen+%28K-1%29/ an interesting read, it’s the decisions on appeals of denials of fiancé/fiancée petitions. Quite often a failure to respond adequately to an rfe is listed as part of the description of the case. 

Edited October 14, 2018 by Illiria

[Visitor User 222]

RFE for what?

[Boiler 43,363]

Why did you get a denial?

[analyncortez32 3]

We Got RFE for the divorce decree and clarity of our meeting online while he was married. So he explained in the letter he was separated for years and then we met online and went through his divorce for 2 years because his ex wouldnt want to settle. Tier 2 said our petition was denied and sent us denial on october 9th. The letter must have been in my fiances mailbox. But there was no letter. I hope they just gave us wrong info. We sent the right documents to them. We are devastated now. 

[analyncortez32 3]

15 hours ago, debbiedoo said:

most RFE's do not result in denials. Most of them are simple information that wasn't included or not enough info given.

 

I'm not sure if they would tell you over the phone that you were denied. But to be denied at the petition stage I (think) is pretty uncommon. its more likely to happen at the consulate stage.

 

Did you receive an RFE/what was it for?

Thats why we are confused my fiance talked to a tier 1 and asked for callbacl. A tier 2 called back and said our petition was denied and being reviewed by the supervisor and we would get response in 15 days. He called to confirm again but the tier 1 said they sent a denial letter to him on the 9th. This is weird because we sent them the divorce decree with stamps and signatures and a letter of explanation. I am so devastated now since we dont know whats really going on. No letter yet 

[analyncortez32 3]

8 hours ago, usmsbow said:

I know this much: tier 2 and reliable don't go together unless the word NOT appears right before reliable. 

 

 

I hope they gave us the wrong info. They just made our lives miserable

[Knome 245]

3 hours ago, analyncortez32 said:

We Got RFE for the divorce decree and clarity of our meeting online while he was married. So he explained in the letter he was separated for years and then we met online and went through his divorce for 2 years because his ex wouldnt want to settle. Tier 2 said our petition was denied and sent us denial on october 9th. The letter must have been in my fiances mailbox. But there was no letter. I hope they just gave us wrong info. We sent the right documents to them. We are devastated now. 

so did you applied for K1 while he was still married? what exactly the RFE says can you pls tell

[Ed Fingaz 1]

4 hours ago, analyncortez32 said:

We Got RFE for the divorce decree and clarity of our meeting online while he was married. So he explained in the letter he was separated for years and then we met online and went through his divorce for 2 years because his ex wouldnt want to settle. Tier 2 said our petition was denied and sent us denial on october 9th. The letter must have been in my fiances mailbox. But there was no letter. I hope they just gave us wrong info. We sent the right documents to them. We are devastated now. 

Did you guys applied for K1