How to voluntarily return green card?

[Sa Pa 0]

Hi everyone!

Please guide me.

 

I was married to US citizen in March 2017 in my country. My husband came back to US and sponsored me. He was nice to me in start but his family never been. I got visa in May 2018. Later on, I came to know, they people are fraud. He uses girls and give divorce to them, he was two times married in my country. Whole family is cruel, they put girls like maid at home. My parents moved last year to US also, in Nevada. 

 

When I came to know about my insecurity, I came to my parents. I asked my husband to give me security first and take seperate apartment for you and me as I cannot live with your parents and siblings. He started harrassing me and told me he will do fraudulent case on me. 

 

Right now i gonna get two years green card. And after that he can put me in fraud case. If he proves fraud, I can never come to US to my parents. I am real, I didnt do any fraud. I am masters degree holder and I can go for Ph.D anywhere.

 

So, if I voluntarily return my green card and go back. Will it still be prove fraud??

I asked a lawyer about voluntarily returning my card to immigration, he doesnt know about it.

 

Please guide me... 

Thanks!

[arken 4,197]

You can file i-407 to abandon GC voluntarily, but that doesn’t mean you will be guaranteed an entry to US later on with a visitor or immigrant visa. 

 

As long as the marriage was done in a good faith, your husband can’t simply convince UCSIS that you are a fraud. 

I believe the best bet is to divorce you husband (if you two have reach to the point that being together is no longer an option) and file for ROC later on with the divorce waiver. My suggestion is assuming whatever you said is true. Your husband could have more to your story.

[Ontarkie 13,904]

~~Moved to Effects of Major Family Changes, from ROC - As similar threads are discussed here.~~

[nullaccount234 882]

If you do decide to surrender your GC and go back to your home country, potential fraud claims will likely not be the issue, however getting a tourist visa to the US any time soon having an ex husband there and your parents - might be tough.

 

I don't think you should have to surrender it in the first place though. He needs substantial evidence to prove fraud on your part. I'm not sure where he would get that from.

 

Edit: Just as @arken already posted.. Computer not keeping up with notifications today.

Edited June 23, 2018 by LizM

[Credo 12]

Why would you want to complicate your immigration status at this perilous times. Is your husband threatening you? His he maltreating you? Did he take money from you for the purpose of green card? What made the marriage fraud? Your masters degree will not save you if you direct the attention of ICE to yourself. 

 

Submit the GC and live the country 

[Sa Pa 0]

I fear that as I didnt go to his state and live even for a day. So he can say that I am a fraud. Isnt it?? Please give me suggestion.

 

I read on website that to surrender green card voluntarily doesnt create problem for later on coming to USA. Is it?

 

I am real. I dnt want someone prove me fraud and i go back with so dis respect. Please provide me good suggestion. 

If I go back now and later on my parents sponsor me, will it be ok for me? Or I shouldnt leave US and apply for waiver after 2 years. 

If I didnt get waiver then it will prove fraud a lawyer told me. 

 

Kindly suggest me. 

[Jojo92122 1,924]

Go find a competent immigration lawyer.

[Sa Pa 0]

Just now, Jojo92122 said:

Go find a competent immigration lawyer.

I went to 2 lawyers. Paid fee. One said that if you dnt get waiver it doesnt mean you fraud. 

Other lawyer said it will prove you were a fraud to get card only. 

I fear about my future. What I do? I want my future secure. Please give suggestion. 

[Boiler 43,397]

Best to file the I407 at your local Consulate when you return.

[Sa Pa 0]

2 minutes ago, Boiler said:

Best to file the I407 at your local Consulate when you return.

Boiler, I can file i407 but what can be the consequences in my case. Please read my post full and suggest me. 

I didnt go to my husnand state even once. 

[Jojo92122 1,924]

2 minutes ago, Sa Pa said:

Boiler, I can file i407 but what can be the consequences in my case. Please read my post full and suggest me. 

I didnt go to my husnand state even once. 

You need professional help.  This is not Do-It-Yourself.  Your situation is too complex for VJ.

 

You not even going to his state after entering on the immigration visa to get your green card does not look good for a legitimate marriage.  Looks like you used him to get a green card and now want to return it because he wants to report you for fraud.  That's what it looks like.  I am not saying you did this.  Just saying that it could look that way to many people.

[Sa Pa 0]

35 minutes ago, Credo said:

Why would you want to complicate your immigration status at this perilous times. Is your husband threatening you? His he maltreating you? Did he take money from you for the purpose of green card? What made the marriage fraud? Your masters degree will not save you if you direct the attention of ICE to yourself. 

 

Submit the GC and live the country 

I fear becz I didnt go to his state and came to my parents. I told him to take seperate apartment for u and me. He threatened. 

How will I prove that I am not fraud. I have few phone recordings of him only and few documents from his ex wife proving he was cruel. 

[Jojo92122 1,924]

2 minutes ago, Sa Pa said:

I fear becz I didnt go to his state and came to my parents. I told him to take seperate apartment for u and me. He threatened. 

How will I prove that I am not fraud. I have few phone recordings of him only and few documents from his ex wife proving he was cruel. 

Be careful.  It could be a crime to record phone calls in certain states.

 

Him being cruel to his ex-wife has nothing to do with you.  How does this prove you didn't commit fraud?  

Edited June 23, 2018 by Jojo92122

[Boiler 43,397]

How did your parents move to the US.

[Sa Pa 0]

3 minutes ago, Jojo92122 said:

Be careful.  It could be a crime to record phone calls in certain states.

 

Him being cruel to his ex-wife has nothing to do with you.  How does this prove you didn't commit fraud?  

I am real and doesnt want someone prove me fraud. My situation is complex. I dnt know what to do??

If I go to him, I am sure he will harm me. I fear of him now too much...