Can I sue USCIS if my I-751 gets denied?

[A1987WA 11]

I already talked to four lawyers; three of them very prominent. I came on F1 visa 01/2015, married 10/2015 and now I am in CGC expiring 09/2018 but our marriage is unfortunately proceeding to divorce. Check my other threads where I discussed about my evidences. When I talked to lawyers all of them confused me: "50/50 chance but You have ways more enough evidences. People get approved with half of evidence as yours; but approval depends on Officer and Case to Case". To be honest and why my title is like that- Because it was real love, my 1st marriage with all best intentions but she stepped out from relation after 1.5 years. Not a single day or for a single moment I had any bad intentions; I have been always honest in my life and same to her, to my marriage and relation. I have evidences, I was honest and I am down to face any interview with millions officers if I need- And I am confident because of my honesty, authenticity and good intentions. Even I said all these to lawyers; they said: "You sound like real husband but even though 50/50 chances and depends from officer to officer". Its freaking weird that an IO will determine future of my education and career just on his/her mentality and intentions to approve or not. Plus the lawyers asked for $1800 for divorce waiver ROC. I was thinking to do own because my honesty, intention, ethics and morals are real and good. Lawyers said: " Don't take risk of self submission". My question: If i submit ROC with Divorce waiver for my real marriage, but if I get denied can I sue USICS? Or any further steps to go to higher authority? I did not like lawyers words: 50/50, Depends, Case to Case. This is a terrible feelings and situation for an immigrant. 

[Transborderwife 4,666]

Sue for what exactly?

[ch3john 308]

on what grounds would you be suing for? 

[A1987WA 11]

Just now, Transborderwife said:

Sue for what exactly?

Not sue exactly; like challenge and take it to higher authority in case my ROC with divorce waiver gets denied. I was proper husband; why I will compensate for fault of USC spouse? Its terrible and complete injustice.

[A1987WA 11]

7 minutes ago, A1987WA said:

I already talked to four lawyers; three of them very prominent. I came on F1 visa 01/2015, married 10/2015 and now I am in CGC expiring 09/2018 but our marriage is unfortunately proceeding to divorce. Check my other threads where I discussed about my evidences. When I talked to lawyers all of them confused me: "50/50 chance but You have ways more enough evidences. People get approved with half of evidence as yours; but approval depends on Officer and Case to Case". To be honest and why my title is like that- Because it was real love, my 1st marriage with all best intentions but she stepped out from relation after 1.5 years. Not a single day or for a single moment I had any bad intentions; I have been always honest in my life and same to her, to my marriage and relation. I have evidences, I was honest and I am down to face any interview with millions officers if I need- And I am confident because of my honesty, authenticity and good intentions. Even I said all these to lawyers; they said: "You sound like real husband but even though 50/50 chances and depends from officer to officer". Its freaking weird that an IO will determine future of my education and career just on his/her mentality and intentions to approve or not. Plus the lawyers asked for $1800 for divorce waiver ROC. I was thinking to do own because my honesty, intention, ethics and morals are real and good. Lawyers said: " Don't take risk of self submission". My question: If i submit ROC with Divorce waiver for my real marriage, but if I get denied can I sue USICS? Or any further steps to go to higher authority? I did not like lawyers words: 50/50, Depends, Case to Case. This is a terrible feelings and situation for an immigrant. 

Not sue exactly; like challenge and take denial decision to higher authority in case my ROC with divorce waiver gets denied. I was proper husband; why I will compensate for fault of USC spouse? Its terrible and complete injustice.

[Transborderwife 4,666]

I'm not following you.  Things can be appealed if uscis made a clerical mistake.

[Springrain22 427]

1 minute ago, Transborderwife said:

I'm not following you.  Things can be appealed if uscis made a clerical mistake.

Immigration is not your right, it's a privilege. I think the same applies for ROC. Although USCIS has to review everything clearly and do good things to immigrants, it's not always guaranteed. Try to think if you're really able to handle all this by yourself. If not then try to think what is the best option for you to handle all this. Unfortunately, CO has the right to determine your future status and is some way your life. The main point is to help the CO to make the right decision.

[Russ&Caro 1,549]

As Springrain22 infers, just do your best assembling evidence and submitting application/waiver, or have an attorney do their best, and then hope for the best. There are no guarantees and worrying about your chances beforehand is sort of a waste of time.

[Lemonslice 5,250]

34 minutes ago, A1987WA said:

I already talked to four lawyers; three of them very prominent. I came on F1 visa 01/2015, married 10/2015 and now I am in CGC expiring 09/2018 but our marriage is unfortunately proceeding to divorce. Check my other threads where I discussed about my evidences. When I talked to lawyers all of them confused me: "50/50 chance but You have ways more enough evidences. People get approved with half of evidence as yours; but approval depends on Officer and Case to Case". To be honest and why my title is like that- Because it was real love, my 1st marriage with all best intentions but she stepped out from relation after 1.5 years. Not a single day or for a single moment I had any bad intentions; I have been always honest in my life and same to her, to my marriage and relation. I have evidences, I was honest and I am down to face any interview with millions officers if I need- And I am confident because of my honesty, authenticity and good intentions. Even I said all these to lawyers; they said: "You sound like real husband but even though 50/50 chances and depends from officer to officer". Its freaking weird that an IO will determine future of my education and career just on his/her mentality and intentions to approve or not. Plus the lawyers asked for $1800 for divorce waiver ROC. I was thinking to do own because my honesty, intention, ethics and morals are real and good. Lawyers said: " Don't take risk of self submission". My question: If i submit ROC with Divorce waiver for my real marriage, but if I get denied can I sue USICS? Or any further steps to go to higher authority? I did not like lawyers words: 50/50, Depends, Case to Case. This is a terrible feelings and situation for an immigrant. 

I think you have created 12 topics on pretty much the same subject.   I suggest you go back and read the answers there .  

 

You could file again if it is denied.  Also, no lawyer can "guarantee 100%", so it is nice to hear they were honest with you.  

[vegasbound 83]

39 minutes ago, A1987WA said:

 Its freaking weird that an IO will determine future of my education and career just on his/her mentality and intentions to approve or not. 

If this is your mentality going into the application process, then you are setting yourself up for failure. 

[Ontarkie 14,948]

~~Thread locked in favour of a previous thread. Do not start any more threads for the same or similar topic. This is considered spamming and will put your account at risk.~~