IRS Transcript or W-2/1099?

[Kuchiki 165]

If one has submitted IRS transcripts to NVC, is it pertinent to also submit W-2/1099? In other words, will NVC send an RFE if only IRS transcripts have been submitted and not W-2/1099?

[SteveInBostonI130 3,319]

Per the I-864 instructions, tax return transcripts are acceptable as-is.  W2's and 1099's are not required.

 

However, some members have reported getting RFE's for W2/1099 when they submitted the transcripts.  It's relatively rare but does seem to happen.

[Kuchiki 165]

1 hour ago, SteveInBostonI130 said:

Per the I-864 instructions, tax return transcripts are acceptable as-is.  W2's and 1099's are not required.

 

However, some members have reported getting RFE's for W2/1099 when they submitted the transcripts.  It's relatively rare but does seem to happen.

What's the rationale for requesting W2/1099 when in the AOS form instructions it is explicitly mentioned that if you submit IRS transcripts, W2s are not required. I really don't get how NVC operates. 

[Verrou 1,899]

3 minutes ago, Kuchiki said:

What's the rationale for requesting W2/1099 when in the AOS form instructions it is explicitly mentioned that if you submit IRS transcripts, W2s are not required. I really don't get how NVC operates. 

i dont want to take the chance especially when we filed Marriage Jointly and both of us got income, so we submitted Tax Transcript, 1040 and W2. i know many people in this forum said otherwise and just provided tax transcript, but i just want to avoid RFE

[Kuchiki 165]

Just now, Misscloud said:

i dont want to take the chance especially when we filed Marriage Jointly and both of us got income, so we submitted Tax Transcript, 1040 and W2. i know many people in this forum said otherwise and just provided tax transcript, but i just want to avoid RFE

In our case, the taxes have been filed as married filing separately and we only submitted IRS transcripts. No W2/1099. I'm paranoid about getting an RFE after 3 months just for them to request a W2/1099.

[Verrou 1,899]

2 minutes ago, Kuchiki said:

In our case, the taxes have been filed as married filing separately and we only submitted IRS transcripts. No W2/1099. I'm paranoid about getting an RFE after 3 months just for them to request a W2/1099.

fingers crossed. nothing u can do now, hope for the best

PS. i totally understand because sometimes i woke up at night and thinking about RFE paranoia as well 

[Mrs.Williams 34]

In reading other threads people were denied b/c they did not submit W2's. I would say, submit everything under the kitchen sink b/c they will deny you for simple things. 

[more00 17]

Submit the 1099 too because my wife did and before we did get DQ

[Kuchiki 165]

Just now, Mrs.Williams said:

In reading other threads people were denied b/c they did not submit W2's. I would say, submit everything under the kitchen sink b/c they will deny you for simple things. 

This is where I get confused. I've read some threads here on VJ about few people getting RFEs against missing W2s. But the instructions on AOS form say otherwise about IRS transcripts and W2s. Either one required. Not both. Then why on earth does NVC send people RFEs!?

[Mrs.Williams 34]

Just now, Kuchiki said:

This is where I get confused. I've read some threads here on VJ about few people getting RFEs against missing W2s. But the instructions on AOS form say otherwise about IRS transcripts and W2s. Either one required. Not both. Then why on earth does NVC send people RFEs!?

I totally agree with you but we will never know the true answer of what NVC wants.. Thankfully, we have this forum.

[Kuchiki 165]

4 minutes ago, more00 said:

Submit the 1099 too because my wife did and before we did get DQ

So you submitted that later than your other documents? And did it push back your review time? or were you DQd on time?

[Kuchiki 165]

2 minutes ago, Mrs.Williams said:

I totally agree with you but we will never know the true answer of what NVC wants.. Thankfully, we have this forum.

This is kinda frustrating at this point since we already submitted everything. I guess if most members are recommending to submit W2 then we have no choice. Will have to do it then, just to avoid any potential RFEs. 

[Dashinka 23,245]

11 minutes ago, Kuchiki said:

This is where I get confused. I've read some threads here on VJ about few people getting RFEs against missing W2s. But the instructions on AOS form say otherwise about IRS transcripts and W2s. Either one required. Not both. Then why on earth does NVC send people RFEs!?

The RFE's I have seen were for those that sent transcripts as well as copies of the 1040(s) without the W2s/1099s.  

[Kuchiki 165]

1 minute ago, Dashinka said:

The RFE's I have seen were for those that sent transcripts as well as copies of the 1040(s) without the W2s/1099s.  

But are copies of 1040 required? Can IRS Transcripts suffice alone?

[Loren Y 2,732]

21 minutes ago, Dashinka said:

The RFE's I have seen were for those that sent transcripts as well as copies of the 1040(s) without the W2s/1099s.  

This is what I have seen also. If you send transcripts, that is all you need to send, it covers all the bases, and that is all I have ever sent for the many petitions I have filed. IF you send tax returns themselves ( 1040,1040ez, etc) then they are expecting all documentation with them ( W-2's, Schedule Cs, Etc.) because that is what makes the return complete.