denial 212 a6c1

[melcom1122 4]

I am new to this forum. my story is quite complicated but please bare with me. i am only twenty three years old, but i have been in love with mu husband since i was 12. we met in 2001. since our relationship has been long distance it has always been on and off. and considering the fact that we were both kids, we never took it seriously.

In 2006 we broke up,and i had just turned 18,i did something extremely stupid, i was so heartbroken, i rebelled and i married his brother who has always has a crush on me. it was a pointless marriage the next day we both regretted it, and never told anyone about it. my husband didnt even know. i tried to get divorce but it was too expensive, so i finally got divorced about two summers later, and the person who had married and divorced us, told us that the marriage wasnt in the marriage books, that it was as if it never existed.

my husband and i became serious around this time and in November 2010 we finally got married. i went back to the person who had married his brother and i and he again repeated to me to not mention my previous marriage that no one would believe it was harmless and it would cause me trouble. and that it was as if it never existed. when i got back to the u.s a couple months later i filed the i 130 petition and the lady who helped me file my papers i told her the story and she recommended also for me to mention my previous marriage.

Our interview was January 23'rd and unfortunately we were denied on this mishap, we were given a white slip, and denied under 212 a 6 c 1

saying we showed false material/not enough evidence. i am extremely heartbroken, and have not stopped crying since. please dont judge me i made a stupid mistake but my marrige is genuine and i need help. we didn't have much pictures which i noticed the officer who interviewed me didnt appreciate, but after that he refused to look at other evidence such as all the times i have gone to our country to be with him, and all the western union receipts, i have been sending my husband money weekly since 2009, since i got my first job. what do i do? i got bad legal advice, has anyone been through this situation what happens to our case. a lawyer told me to collect as much evidence as possible and i am going to start getting a list of all the calls we make to each other throughout the day, and also more photos with his family.

the officer at the consulate never asked me if i had been previous married, because i had the divorce certificate with me just in case, and he asked us a few questions which i know we answered correctly too. he refused to looks at my evidence. he was vey unfair. my husband and i need to be together and my last options is move to the Dominican republic, but my future is here. this is like a nightmare. please no judging or mean comments.

[az110965 252]

I am new to this forum. my story is quite complicated but please bare with me. i am only twenty three years old, but i have been in love with mu husband since i was 12. we met in 2001. since our relationship has been long distance it has always been on and off. and considering the fact that we were both kids, we never took it seriously.

In 2006 we broke up,and i had just turned 18,i did something extremely stupid, i was so heartbroken, i rebelled and i married his brother who has always has a crush on me. it was a pointless marriage the next day we both regretted it, and never told anyone about it. my husband didnt even know. i tried to get divorce but it was too expensive, so i finally got divorced about two summers later, and the person who had married and divorced us, told us that the marriage wasnt in the marriage books, that it was as if it never existed.

my husband and i became serious around this time and in November 2010 we finally got married. i went back to the person who had married his brother and i and he again repeated to me to not mention my previous marriage that no one would believe it was harmless and it would cause me trouble. and that it was as if it never existed. when i got back to the u.s a couple months later i filed the i 130 petition and the lady who helped me file my papers i told her the story and she recommended also for me to mention my previous marriage.

Our interview was January 23'rd and unfortunately we were denied on this mishap, we were given a white slip, and denied under 212 a 6 c 1

saying we showed false material/not enough evidence. i am extremely heartbroken, and have not stopped crying since. please dont judge me i made a stupid mistake but my marrige is genuine and i need help. we didn't have much pictures which i noticed the officer who interviewed me didnt appreciate, but after that he refused to look at other evidence such as all the times i have gone to our country to be with him, and all the western union receipts, i have been sending my husband money weekly since 2009, since i got my first job. what do i do? i got bad legal advice, has anyone been through this situation what happens to our case. a lawyer told me to collect as much evidence as possible and i am going to start getting a list of all the calls we make to each other throughout the day, and also more photos with his family.

the officer at the consulate never asked me if i had been previous married, because i had the divorce certificate with me just in case, and he asked us a few questions which i know we answered correctly too. he refused to looks at my evidence. he was vey unfair. my husband and i need to be together and my last options is move to the Dominican republic, but my future is here. this is like a nightmare. please no judging or mean comments.

Your post is a little unclear. On your I-129F, how did you answer regarding a previous marriage?

If the Consulate denied you for a material misrepresentation, then a lifetime ban results with very little chance of appeal and reversal at USCIS. If the Consulate denied and issued an 221(g) for additional evidence of bonafied relationship then there is a chance to submit additional evidence.

[Laure&Colin 558]

Your post is a little unclear. On your I-129F, how did you answer regarding a previous marriage?

If the Consulate denied you for a material misrepresentation, then a lifetime ban results with very little chance of appeal and reversal at USCIS. If the Consulate denied and issued an 221(g) for additional evidence of bonafied relationship then there is a chance to submit additional evidence.

There's no I129F, it's a spousal visa. OP filled the I130.

Anyway, did the CO say anything about your previous marriage at all? Did you or did you not send your divorce certificate to the USCIS with the original petition?

[NY_BX 397]

I am new to this forum. my story is quite complicated but please bare with me. i am only twenty three years old, but i have been in love with mu husband since i was 12. we met in 2001. since our relationship has been long distance it has always been on and off. and considering the fact that we were both kids, we never took it seriously.

In 2006 we broke up,and i had just turned 18,i did something extremely stupid, i was so heartbroken, i rebelled and i married his brother who has always has a crush on me. it was a pointless marriage the next day we both regretted it, and never told anyone about it. my husband didnt even know. i tried to get divorce but it was too expensive, so i finally got divorced about two summers later, and the person who had married and divorced us, told us that the marriage wasnt in the marriage books, that it was as if it never existed.

my husband and i became serious around this time and in November 2010 we finally got married. i went back to the person who had married his brother and i and he again repeated to me to not mention my previous marriage that no one would believe it was harmless and it would cause me trouble. and that it was as if it never existed. when i got back to the u.s a couple months later i filed the i 130 petition and the lady who helped me file my papers i told her the story and she recommended also for me to mention my previous marriage.

Our interview was January 23'rd and unfortunately we were denied on this mishap, we were given a white slip, and denied under 212 a 6 c 1

saying we showed false material/not enough evidence. i am extremely heartbroken, and have not stopped crying since. please dont judge me i made a stupid mistake but my marrige is genuine and i need help. we didn't have much pictures which i noticed the officer who interviewed me didnt appreciate, but after that he refused to look at other evidence such as all the times i have gone to our country to be with him, and all the western union receipts, i have been sending my husband money weekly since 2009, since i got my first job. what do i do? i got bad legal advice, has anyone been through this situation what happens to our case. a lawyer told me to collect as much evidence as possible and i am going to start getting a list of all the calls we make to each other throughout the day, and also more photos with his family.

the officer at the consulate never asked me if i had been previous married, because i had the divorce certificate with me just in case, and he asked us a few questions which i know we answered correctly too. he refused to looks at my evidence. he was vey unfair. my husband and i need to be together and my last options is move to the Dominican republic, but my future is here. this is like a nightmare. please no judging or mean comments.

So, you didn't disclose your marriage in the application even though you were advised to do so? Then, you admit you have an issue with a past mistake and you don't submit enough evidence to proof beyond unreasonable doubt your relationship is genuine, even after all these years? To make matters worse, you show western union receipts that you've been sending him, which looks like its a business transaction? On top of that, has your child been petitioned for in this claim?

I'm not judging you, frankly is not like you committed a crime. What I'm questioning you on is your critical thinking. This is a serious process and lying won't get you anywhere; in fact, it'll make you stay away from the US.

Yes, apparently you got bad advise. Hopefully someone that's gone thru the DR embassy can give you better advise on how to overcome this. Who's the USC? Are you in the US right now?

[himher 634]

wow

You are saying you disclosed it at the interview but your husband didnt know and failed to disclose it on the I130?

I am new to this forum. my story is quite complicated but please bare with me. i am only twenty three years old, but i have been in love with mu husband since i was 12. we met in 2001. since our relationship has been long distance it has always been on and off. and considering the fact that we were both kids, we never took it seriously.

In 2006 we broke up,and i had just turned 18,i did something extremely stupid, i was so heartbroken, i rebelled and i married his brother who has always has a crush on me. it was a pointless marriage the next day we both regretted it, and never told anyone about it. my husband didnt even know. i tried to get divorce but it was too expensive, so i finally got divorced about two summers later, and the person who had married and divorced us, told us that the marriage wasnt in the marriage books, that it was as if it never existed.

my husband and i became serious around this time and in November 2010 we finally got married. i went back to the person who had married his brother and i and he again repeated to me to not mention my previous marriage that no one would believe it was harmless and it would cause me trouble. and that it was as if it never existed. when i got back to the u.s a couple months later i filed the i 130 petition and the lady who helped me file my papers i told her the story and she recommended also for me to mention my previous marriage.

Our interview was January 23'rd and unfortunately we were denied on this mishap, we were given a white slip, and denied under 212 a 6 c 1

saying we showed false material/not enough evidence. i am extremely heartbroken, and have not stopped crying since. please dont judge me i made a stupid mistake but my marrige is genuine and i need help. we didn't have much pictures which i noticed the officer who interviewed me didnt appreciate, but after that he refused to look at other evidence such as all the times i have gone to our country to be with him, and all the western union receipts, i have been sending my husband money weekly since 2009, since i got my first job. what do i do? i got bad legal advice, has anyone been through this situation what happens to our case. a lawyer told me to collect as much evidence as possible and i am going to start getting a list of all the calls we make to each other throughout the day, and also more photos with his family.

the officer at the consulate never asked me if i had been previous married, because i had the divorce certificate with me just in case, and he asked us a few questions which i know we answered correctly too. he refused to looks at my evidence. he was vey unfair. my husband and i need to be together and my last options is move to the Dominican republic, but my future is here. this is like a nightmare. please no judging or mean comments.

[Boiler 45,665]

Have you reported your Lawyer to the State Bar?

[Matt & Rocio 28]

I am new to this forum. my story is quite complicated but please bare with me. i am only twenty three years old, but i have been in love with mu husband since i was 12. we met in 2001. since our relationship has been long distance it has always been on and off. and considering the fact that we were both kids, we never took it seriously.

In 2006 we broke up,and i had just turned 18,i did something extremely stupid, i was so heartbroken, i rebelled and i married his brother who has always has a crush on me. it was a pointless marriage the next day we both regretted it, and never told anyone about it. my husband didnt even know. i tried to get divorce but it was too expensive, so i finally got divorced about two summers later, and the person who had married and divorced us, told us that the marriage wasnt in the marriage books, that it was as if it never existed.

my husband and i became serious around this time and in November 2010 we finally got married. i went back to the person who had married his brother and i and he again repeated to me to not mention my previous marriage that no one would believe it was harmless and it would cause me trouble. and that it was as if it never existed. when i got back to the u.s a couple months later i filed the i 130 petition and the lady who helped me file my papers i told her the story and she recommended also for me to mention my previous marriage.

Our interview was January 23'rd and unfortunately we were denied on this mishap, we were given a white slip, and denied under 212 a 6 c 1

saying we showed false material/not enough evidence. i am extremely heartbroken, and have not stopped crying since. please dont judge me i made a stupid mistake but my marrige is genuine and i need help. we didn't have much pictures which i noticed the officer who interviewed me didnt appreciate, but after that he refused to look at other evidence such as all the times i have gone to our country to be with him, and all the western union receipts, i have been sending my husband money weekly since 2009, since i got my first job. what do i do? i got bad legal advice, has anyone been through this situation what happens to our case. a lawyer told me to collect as much evidence as possible and i am going to start getting a list of all the calls we make to each other throughout the day, and also more photos with his family.

the officer at the consulate never asked me if i had been previous married, because i had the divorce certificate with me just in case, and he asked us a few questions which i know we answered correctly too. he refused to looks at my evidence. he was vey unfair. my husband and i need to be together and my last options is move to the Dominican republic, but my future is here. this is like a nightmare. please no judging or mean comments.

When you filled out the I-130 petition, did you list your previous husband for Section B, #11? If you did list him did you include a copy of the divorce certificate? You said the lady who helped you file the papers told you to mention your previous marriage, or did you intend to write that she said not to mention the previous marriage?

A quick Google search of 212(a)(6)©(i) returns a number of results. They all point to this denial being due to willful misrepresentation or fraud. I just did a quick read but it sounds like this is tough to beat and you would very likely need a good immigration attorney to even have a chance to get this removed so you can re-apply.

If you didn't list your previous husband on the I-130 petition, the visa was most likely denied for this reason.

If they denied you due to a lack of evidence of a bonafide marriage, they would have given you a 221(g) slip for lack of evidence.

Did this same person who helped you fill out the form sign section F of the I-130 petition? If so you could argue that you gave that person the information about they previous marriage, but that they chose to disclose it.

I'm very sorry for this situation you are in. I would be devastated if I were told that my wife could never be allowed to enter the US to live with me. This is a sober reminder to us that we must always be honest when we fill out these petitions and applications, even if something seems minor or irrelevant.

My advice? Get a good attorney who has a history of overturning these types of denials and be prepared for a long wait. If you can't live apart any longer you should consider moving to a country where you can live together.

[Boiler 45,665]

She said:

i got bad legal advice,

[NY_BX 397]

She said:

I don't think she got bad legal advise. The lawyer did suggest for her to disclose her previous marriage. She listened to the wrong person: the one that apparently married them, who should be held accountable for lying to them in the first place. Why would you claim to legally marry someone and then claim it was "off the books"? I hate to say this, but this will be an uphill battle.

[Matt & Rocio 28]

She also said:

when i got back to the u.s a couple months later i filed the i 130 petition and the lady who helped me file my papers i told her the story and she recommended also for me to mention my previous marriage.

I'm guessing she meant to say she recommended her NOT to mention the previous marriage.

If the person who helped her file the petition signed under section F as the person who prepared the petition there may be a case to be made that the omission was made by the preparer and not the petitioner.

[san diego 407]

It is hard to understand the situation based on the information provided. Independently, considering complexity of the situation I would use a GOOD lawyer. Are you in US? If you are I can recommend you one if you write me privately. The lawyer that I would like to recommend is a very good one. I used her in my case even though I cannot judge how good she is as my case was simple. She is highly regarded and highly recommended.

[Boiler 45,665]

Then what is wrong posting her info?

[TedM 9]

It's my understanding that 212(a)(6)©(i) only applies to the alien (beneficiary). I believe that you are the petitioner, correct? Unless someone decided that your husband was perpetuating some fraud-like involvement in the original marriage (you to his brother), I'm not sure how that classification would apply to you.

However, I am entirely confused by your situation. I'm not sure if or when you notified about your previous marriage, though it sounds like you did not list on your I-130 (as your I-130 was presumably approved). And I'm not sure how your current marriage bona fides would affect a 212(a)(6)©(i) ruling, so don't know why you mention that part of the visa interview process. I'm also confused by how or why the divorce paperwork even came up in the interview, or how the CO knew about the previous marriage.

I can, unfortunately, see how people would become suspicious of your application if they found out you had previously married your husband's brother. I'll also assume you are a permanent resident, not a USC?

The best advice any of us can give you is to find a good lawyer before this gets any more out of hand.

Edited January 31, 2012 by TedM

[melcom1122 4]

So, you didn't disclose your marriage in the application even though you were advised to do so? Then, you admit you have an issue with a past mistake and you don't submit enough evidence to proof beyond unreasonable doubt your relationship is genuine, even after all these years? To make matters worse, you show western union receipts that you've been sending him, which looks like its a business transaction? On top of that, has your child been petitioned for in this claim?

I'm not judging you, frankly is not like you committed a crime. What I'm questioning you on is your critical thinking. This is a serious process and lying won't get you anywhere; in fact, it'll make you stay away from the US.

Yes, apparently you got bad advise. Hopefully someone that's gone thru the DR embassy can give you better advise on how to overcome this. Who's the USC? Are you in the US right now?

I WAS advised NOT to do so.....by the person who had divorced me and the person who filled my papers....i was advised NOT to.

It's my understanding that 212(a)(6)©(i) only applies to the alien (beneficiary). I believe that you are the petitioner, correct? Unless someone decided that your husband was perpetuating some fraud-like involvement in the original marriage (you to his brother), I'm not sure how that classification would apply to you.

However, I am entirely confused by your situation. I'm not sure if or when you notified about your previous marriage, though it sounds like you did not list on your I-130 (as your I-130 was presumably approved). And I'm not sure how your current marriage bona fides would affect a 212(a)(6)©(i) ruling, so don't know why you mention that part of the visa interview process. I'm also confused by how or why the divorce paperwork even came up in the interview, or how the CO knew about the previous marriage.

I can, unfortunately, see how people would become suspicious of your application if they found out you had previously married your husband's brother. I'll also assume you are a permanent resident, not a USC?

The best advice any of us can give you is to find a good lawyer before this gets any more out of hand.

i am a u.s born citizen. and the co never asked me about the previous marriage, but i assume that is why we were both denied, yes technically its my husband who is denied, but its both of us really, because i need him here with me.

and as for marrying his brother a stupid horrible mistake, that i will always live with, but i never petioned for himto come here the marrige was not even a real marrige it was a stupid mistake

It is hard to understand the situation based on the information provided. Independently, considering complexity of the situation I would use a GOOD lawyer. Are you in US? If you are I can recommend you one if you write me privately. The lawyer that I would like to recommend is a very good one. I used her in my case even though I cannot judge how good she is as my case was simple. She is highly regarded and highly recommended.

write me privately tell me plz i need help

[Barbie_Vazquez 10]

Awww! Girl the government can find out everything. I wish you would have told them on the I-130 form. But because you did not disclose this it may be too late. I feel bad