USA-ALG

No need to renew EAD, GC gives you authorization to work plus much more, You can keep it somewhere and let it expire.

I do concur with you. It seems as if she is "playing" you both to see which one will get her the "American Visa" first. I suggest that you go further into this matter and dig up for more information.
I wish you luck.

There is something not right here or she is not disclosing everything. If they see 2nd petition in the system this means it is active. If (as your fiancee claims) her ex-fiance brought another person on K1, than he supposed to cancel it. Likewise, as they denied her, they would deny her ex-fiance to petition for another person as long as old petition is active. Do you see it does not make sense? Given that petition expires within 4 months AND Based on factual evidence of reasoning for denial (but not taking to consideration your or your fiancee words it looks like either:
1) 2 individuals (including yourself) petitioned for her at the same time (or nearly the same)
2) Someone petitioned for her with approved I129F with less than 4 month..

It goes in cycles. In a few months California may be the fast one again.

I was just being a bit of a smart alecky with your phrasing. It's all good

WOW! Amazing story

don't get yourself distracted reading numerous stories, every case varies and depends how much evidences you have aggregated to show the CO, take my advice get yourself busy doing other things, rather than reading more stories of Denial, you will be like what if this happens to me don't ever assume this might occur to you as well, when i had my Past petition, i used to be like you always used to think negative, just believe in Allah think positive and if your relationship is strong enough to convince the CO, inshallah you will get it, don't stress yourself out just let your hair down,i wish you best of luck for your successful interview.

Yes you can. However, it is often cheaper and quicker just to file again.

LOL

GET MARRIED AS SOON AS SPOUSE ARRIVES IN USA!!!! I DO NOT UNDERSTAND WHY THIS IS SO HARD FOR PEOPLE TO COMPREHEND!
DO NOT PLAN WEDDING CERAMONEY UNTIL SPOUSE ARRIVES IN USA! AGAIN, I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY PEOPLE PLAN WEDDING CARAMONY BEFORE SPOUSE ARRIVES OR BEFORE SPOUSE HAS ARRIVAL DATE AND THEN COMPLAIN THAT THE PAPERWORK IS TAKING TOO LONG!
IF YOUR SPOUSE HAS TO LEAVE THE COUNTRY BECAUSE YOU DIDN'T GET MARRIED WITHEN THE 90 DAYS, IT IS YOUR OWN FAULT. 90 DAYS IS MOR THAN ENOUGH TIME TO GET MARRIED!
IF YOU PLANNED A HUGE CERAMONY AND ARE UPSET THAT YOUR SPOUSE WON’T BE HERE WHEN YOU HAD PLANNED, AGAIN..YOUR OWN FAULT! DON'T MAKE PLANS UNTIL THINGS ARE SET IN STONE!
JUST TRYING TO HELP PEOPLE BEFORE THEY REGRET THEIR DESCIONS.

Dear Missy and Vj'ers!!
Please pardon me if I sound brash! But this needs to be said.
#1: IF the alphabet men, i.e. USCIS, ICE, FBI, CIA, etc, find out you willingly filed out of false pretenses, then it will be ON YOU. You will be charged with heavy fines, penalty, and a record for the rest of your life.
#2: Are you lower than dirt? NO! Then don't let him treat you like that.
#3: Are you a dog? Then why is he ordering you around like one and yet leaves you like a master leaves his dog at home....
#4: You are a human with a brain and a heart of gold.
#5: Forget the appeal, he is manipulating you... Leave him in his country to ROT.
Finally: Do the right thing, SAVE HUMANITY (i.e. yourself and your sanity and not to burden the GOVERNMENT with bad men like him in USA).
E

Dear Missy and Vj'ers!!
Please pardon me if I sound brash! But this needs to be said.
#1: IF the alphabet men, i.e. USCIS, ICE, FBI, CIA, etc, find out you willingly filed out of false pretenses, then it will be ON YOU. You will be charged with heavy fines, penalty, and a record for the rest of your life.
#2: Are you lower than dirt? NO! Then don't let him treat you like that.
#3: Are you a dog? Then why is he ordering you around like one and yet leaves you like a master leaves his dog at home....
#4: You are a human with a brain and a heart of gold.
#5: Forget the appeal, he is manipulating you... Leave him in his country to ROT.
Finally: Do the right thing, SAVE HUMANITY (i.e. yourself and your sanity and not to burden the GOVERNMENT with bad men like him in USA).
E

Dear Missy and Vj'ers!!
Please pardon me if I sound brash! But this needs to be said.
#1: IF the alphabet men, i.e. USCIS, ICE, FBI, CIA, etc, find out you willingly filed out of false pretenses, then it will be ON YOU. You will be charged with heavy fines, penalty, and a record for the rest of your life.
#2: Are you lower than dirt? NO! Then don't let him treat you like that.
#3: Are you a dog? Then why is he ordering you around like one and yet leaves you like a master leaves his dog at home....
#4: You are a human with a brain and a heart of gold.
#5: Forget the appeal, he is manipulating you... Leave him in his country to ROT.
Finally: Do the right thing, SAVE HUMANITY (i.e. yourself and your sanity and not to burden the GOVERNMENT with bad men like him in USA).
E

Dear Missy and Vj'ers!!
Please pardon me if I sound brash! But this needs to be said.
#1: IF the alphabet men, i.e. USCIS, ICE, FBI, CIA, etc, find out you willingly filed out of false pretenses, then it will be ON YOU. You will be charged with heavy fines, penalty, and a record for the rest of your life.
#2: Are you lower than dirt? NO! Then don't let him treat you like that.
#3: Are you a dog? Then why is he ordering you around like one and yet leaves you like a master leaves his dog at home....
#4: You are a human with a brain and a heart of gold.
#5: Forget the appeal, he is manipulating you... Leave him in his country to ROT.
Finally: Do the right thing, SAVE HUMANITY (i.e. yourself and your sanity and not to burden the GOVERNMENT with bad men like him in USA).
E

The ONLY thing that matters to this man is his green card. Period. And he is willing to commit fraud, have you commit fraud and possible go to jail to get it. GET RID OF HIM ALREADY !!

Don't listen to him! Stop this relationship now and don't file for him! He is clearly using you. Just like he needs proof before he 'works' on this with you--you yourself may need proof that once he receives is GC, he won't leave you again. If you have feelings for him still, don't do it because it is illegal. And it is not worth risking something like that for someone who doesn't love you... Good luck!

He is a total #######! Why do you feel guilty when even from the start of the process he left you without a word and just came back because he just wanted to come back? Like everyone else says, file a divorce. Make him suffer.

The longer you are allowing this clown to use and play you, the longer true love with a good man will not happen. You need healthy boundaries not co dependancy. You can not change him. Take your life back. He is comtrolling you.

If you remain married to a person solely for the purpose of obtaining an immigration benefit from the US Government, then YOU are breaking the laws of the United States. Only you can decide if that is how you wish to live your life.

OP, pull the plug now. DO NOT "HELP" THIS MAN ANOTHER SECOND. Besides all the self-esteem issues running through my head because of the mere thought of helping this man, do you really want to be on the financial hook for this scum for the next 10 years?!?!? He could financially damage you, and I PROMISE you, he's not going to give one flying piece of doo doo!

Three months flat? You've been conned or suckered.
I promise you it will take LONGER than 9 months, maybe 14 months for some.
Do not shell out more money to that conniving fella.
Do your homework FIRST before doing anything.
KNOW that the VISA process is really an EASY one, this I tell you. The most difficult part is learning how to argue with your spouse, living together, learning about spouse quirky habits, likes and dislikes, dealing with prejudice, and all that. RISING above it all is - LOVE along with hard work.
Good luck.

There is an old expression " Actions speak louder than words". Please think about this.

Why would you want to marry someone who shows no interest in coming, and total lack of effort on his part? Why are you asking our advice for questions you really know the answers to already? Is it worth being with him if everything is an argument and you don;t communicate? Honestly?

my suggestion for you is NEVER EVER stay alone with your wife, not even for 30 seconds, she just needs to be alone with you and call the cops and say you slapped her, or try to strangle her or you or hit her on the face hard and pushed her in the chest etc, when she realizes she doesn't have enough prove to ROC she can try to be alone with you just to call the cops and make her case strong to file I-751 waiver based in domestic violence. Report her to ICE.

sounds like she had a coach for her immigration fraud or a series of coaches.
2 weeks in country and she does this? All was planned, prior.
Cut yer losses, file for divorce on Monday. Change the locks, change yer telephone number, do not contact her further.
She's setting you up for a VAWA claim, but she's stupid - she not need to adjust to a 10 year card later down the road with VAWA - a divorce, instead, will be helpful for her in filing the ROC bit.
Seriously, change the locks today, change yer # on Monday, file the divorce on Monday.
You've been had. You can certainly file a report with ICE, if you want.
To any one of the faithful VJ readers who want to say, "Wait! There's always 2 sides to the story!" - uhm, sorry, I get to disregard you, this one time.