Jump to content

42 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Filed: AOS (apr) Country: Sweden
Timeline
4 minutes ago, ultrasoul said:

@Dispie @mbssss Having filed many I-130's (paper and electronic) and concurrent I-485's and I-130's for various family members, I can categorically tell you that it is better to file a concurrent I-130 and I-485 package versus breaking them apart into 2 separate filings.


Yes- the online I-130 filing is most certainly a breeze compared to the paper version and has a tremendous benefit of time saving for those who are planning on consular processing with the electronic transmission of the approved I-130 to the NVC, eliminating 30 - 55 days of waiting time after  I-130 approval (no need for USCIS to send paper package from approving service center to NVC, no need for NVC manual data entry from USCIS forms to create NVC case)

 

However, you aren't doing consular processing but rather an adjustment of status. Based on my experience handling several AOS cases (concurrent paper I-130/ I-485 filings and separate I-130/ I-485 filings), my recommendation is always to go with the concurrent albeit paper filing. Why? 

 

For concurrent filings, both I-130 and I-485 is adjudicated in the same local USCIS FO. If you separate them, they are adjudicated separately. Pre-COVID, I have seen I-485 interviews being scheduled by local FO within 60 days of I-485 filing and have seen I-130's taking 6 months to adjudicate by a USCIS service center. 

 

Therefore, my perspective is that saving an hour with an electronic I-130 is NEVER preferable to concurrent paper filings. Just my 2 cents.

 

Makes a lot of sense. I actually ended up filing them concurrently on paper after speaking with other people who expressed similar opinions as you.

 

Very useful post and I'm sure that it will be useful for other people who consider doing it.

AOS

08/25/2020 - Sent I-130, I-485, I-131 and I-765 to Chicago Lockbox using USPS                                         11/06/2020 - Received physical receipt notice for I-765 in the mail

08/28/2020 - Package was received by USCIS                                                                                                   12/15/2020 - Online account updated and indicated the I-944 RFIE was sent

09/25/2020 - Debit Card was charged by USCIS                                                                                                 12/28/2020 - Recieved the I-944 RFIE via e-mail after speaking with a tier 2 officer

09/29/2020 - Recieved text notifications from USCIS with reciept numbers                                                  1/11/2021 - Responded to the RFIE and sent the I-944 to USCIS 

10/01/2020 - Recieved rejected I-765 back                                                                                                           3/3/2021 - Biometrics scheduled for 03/29

10/05/2020 - Recieved physical reciept notices in the mail

10/06/2020 - Sent I-765 to Chicago Lockbox using UPS

10/09/2020 - Package was recieved by USCIS

10/30/2020 - Recieved text notication from USCIS with reciept number for I-765

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Malaysia
Timeline

@mbssss Just to clarify again, for separate I-130 and I-485 paper filings, both from my experience are adjudicated separately by 2 different officers with 2 different timelines.

 

@Dispie As mentioned before, I'm not sure if a local FO adjudicator is able to pull down an electronic I-130 to make a decision on the I-130 as well at your I-485 local FO interview so please do share back.

I-130 JOURNEY FOR 2020 Minor Child of LPR (F2A Online Application, MNL Consular Processing)

07/29/20 Online Filing for I-130, Same day Priority date 
07/31/20 Paper NOA1 mailed by USCIS, received on 08/03/20

07/31/20, 08/15/20, 09/01,20 Expedite Requests denied three times (self-submission and congressman outreach)

09/28/20: I-130 Approved by USCIS, received mailed NOA2 on 10/01/20

10/01/20: NVC electronically receives I-130 petition from USCIS, generates NVC case & invoice number, paid all NVC fees same day

10/05/19: CEAC ready for document uploads

TBD: Waiting for NBI Police Clearance to complete all upload of NVC docs

 

I-130 JOURNEY FOR 2019 Parent of USC (IR-5 Paper Application, MNL Consular Processing)

01/18/19 NOA1 I-130 (Priority Date)

08/02/19 Called USCIS to expedite I-130 after 196 days pending,  emailed expedite evidence 08/06/1,  expedite approved 08/09/19

08/13/19: I-130 Approved by USCIS, USCIS sent petition file to NVC 08/29/19 

09/09/19: NVC receives I-130 petition from USCISgenerates case & invoice number on 10/03/19 (paid all NVC fees same day)

10/07/19: CEAC ready for document uploads (AOS and IV documents uploaded to CEAC same day)

11/25/19: NVC Case Complete, NVC emails interview schedules interview on 12/18/19 for 01/06/20

01/06/20: IR-5 Interview in Manila Philippines embassy (MNL); forgot original signed I-864 resulted in 221GUSEM receives original signed I-864 via 2GO courier on 02/04/20
3/4/20: Immigrant Visa Issued by USEM, 2GO carrier picked up passport from USEM 3/6/20 and delivers to residence on 3/10/20

6/10/20: US POE

6/13/20: SSN card mailed date by SSA, delivered to residence on 6/18/20

7/3/20: LPR Green Card ordered, Production on 7/24/20, Mailed by USCIS on 7/27/20, delivered to residence on 7/29/20

 

I-130/ I-485 JOURNEY FOR 2019 Parent of USC (IR-5 Paper Application)

01/18/19: NOA1 Received I-130 (priority date, was not concurrently filed with I-485 as we were not sure if we were going to CP or AOS)

06/19/19: USPS receives I-485 package to lockbox (priority date); 06/24/19: Credit card charged ,  USCIS mails out NOA1 06/25/19 with receipt numbers (assigned to MSC National Benefits center),  Received NOA1 from USPS (07/02/19:)

07/05/19:  USCIS mailsout biometrics appointment notice with appointment date for 07/24/19, Received biometrics notice letter from USPS 07/11/19
07/12/19: Walk-in biometrics completed

07/18/19: Called USCIS to expedite EADReceived mailed USCIS instructions on where to fax expedite evidence from USPS 07/26/19 Faxed requested evidence for EAD expedite  07/27/19
07/31/19: USCIS approves EAD I-765 and Advanced Parole I-131, USCIS mails out combo EAD/ AP card 08/02/19, Received combo EAD/ AP card via USPS Priority Mail 08/07/19

08/08/19: I-485 Case is Ready to Be Scheduled for An Interview
08/26/19: I-130 Approved (NOA2) by USCIS

12/10/19: FO sends out I-485 interview appointment details for 01/28/20 interview date 

02/06/20: I-485 case approved and NOA2 mailed
02/05/20: Green card ordered, Production and mailed 02/10/20, delivered to residence on 
02/12/20

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: AOS (apr) Country: Sweden
Timeline
55 minutes ago, ultrasoul said:

@mbssss Just to clarify again, for separate I-130 and I-485 paper filings, both from my experience are adjudicated separately by 2 different officers with 2 different timelines.

 

@Dispie As mentioned before, I'm not sure if a local FO adjudicator is able to pull down an electronic I-130 to make a decision on the I-130 as well at your I-485 local FO interview so please do share back.

Right, the I485 goes to the local office while the I130 is processed by one of the service centers if I remember correctly. Nonetheless, I filed them together to make it easier for myself so hopefully that will work out fine! 

AOS

08/25/2020 - Sent I-130, I-485, I-131 and I-765 to Chicago Lockbox using USPS                                         11/06/2020 - Received physical receipt notice for I-765 in the mail

08/28/2020 - Package was received by USCIS                                                                                                   12/15/2020 - Online account updated and indicated the I-944 RFIE was sent

09/25/2020 - Debit Card was charged by USCIS                                                                                                 12/28/2020 - Recieved the I-944 RFIE via e-mail after speaking with a tier 2 officer

09/29/2020 - Recieved text notifications from USCIS with reciept numbers                                                  1/11/2021 - Responded to the RFIE and sent the I-944 to USCIS 

10/01/2020 - Recieved rejected I-765 back                                                                                                           3/3/2021 - Biometrics scheduled for 03/29

10/05/2020 - Recieved physical reciept notices in the mail

10/06/2020 - Sent I-765 to Chicago Lockbox using UPS

10/09/2020 - Package was recieved by USCIS

10/30/2020 - Recieved text notication from USCIS with reciept number for I-765

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@ultrasoul thanks for sharing your experience.

 

When we spoke with a lawyer last December (we thought of filing through a lawyer), he said we would wait up to a year or even more before hearing back from the San Francisco office. He also said we would be lucky if they forward the documents to Sacramento, where it was supposed to be faster. We didn't even expect to be called for interviews within 6+ months. I would still assume that they can pull the electronic version at any time in any office, and thus it should not be a factor comparing to mailing separately. Well, it might be my wishful thinking :)


It's been 6 months since I filed I-130 and 2 months since I-485 filing. No updates on either case yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 1 month later...
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Thailand
Timeline

Hello all of VJ, 

 

This site helped me greatly with our K-1 6 years ago.  Now we would  like my wife's grown daughter to come to the U.S. I filed (and paid $ 535.00) the I-130 today. The daughter is in her home country of Thailand. 

 

I am trying to determine if there is anything else I should be doing at this point, or is just wait wait wait?  Thanks all very much - Tango

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Tango777 said:

Now we would  like my wife's grown daughter to come to the U.S. I filed (and paid $ 535.00) the I-130 today.

 

Are you listed as the petitioner?  Or do you mean that you helped your wife file the I-130 to petition her daughter?  If you are the petitioner, how old was the daughter when you and her mom got married?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Thailand
Timeline

My wife is the petitioner, I just filled out the online I-30. The daughter is 28 now, and her Mom and I have been married (K1) for over 6 years now. Thanks for commenting on this. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Tango777 said:

My wife is the petitioner, I just filled out the online I-30. The daughter is 28 now, and her Mom and I have been married (K1) for over 6 years now.

 

Thanks, just checking.  Also, is the daughter single?  If so, she should stay that way until she enters the US with her immigrant visa.  Other than that, nothing for any of you to do now but wait and wait until petition approval.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Thailand
Timeline

Yes, she is single and has a 9 year old whom we hope to get over here at some point. This is all mainly for a better future for the boy. Our daughter (my step daughter) will do fine over here also. It's difficult to get ahead in Thailand especially if you are not from a known family. So I was skeptical about applying because I've always heard it's quite difficult to get a green card. I am thinking if it ever happens it could be 5 - 10 years? 

Thanks again Chancy. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Tango777 said:

I was skeptical about applying because I've always heard it's quite difficult to get a green card. I am thinking if it ever happens it could be 5 - 10 years?

 

Not really difficult in terms of procedure, but the visas for your step-daughter's category are limited (unlike K1) so the line is very long.  Better set your expectations to 7 years minimum wait time.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Thailand
Timeline

Nothing thus far. I just look at it like an investment to get in line. $ 550.00. I'll spend some time looking into it later in this year. I spent so much time on our K-1 in 2012-2014 but that was when the CGI contractors were in the State Dept. Hopefully they're gone now but I don't know. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
31 minutes ago, Brand83 said:

Hi everyone :)

 

I am a little confused about the "Additional Information" section under the "Other Information" tab when filing online.

 

Is there were I need to attach the I-130A PDF

I don't remember where exactly I attached I-130A but I didn't have anything in the "Additional Information" section. Unless they have updated the process, it should be somewhere before that

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...