Jump to content
RichardShane

Wierd RFE from USCIS - Bona Fide Father/Daughter Relationship

By RichardShane in Bringing Family Members of US Citizens to America

 Share

11 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

RichardShane Explorer

RichardShane   2

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Philippines
 Timeline
Posted

This is for a friend of ours that just recently filed a petition for her parents. They received an RFE and it stated that they need proof of a Bona Fide Father/Child Relationship because there is a discrepancy on the marriage date listed on the Marriage Contract and my friends Birth Certificate. The date on the marriage contract was their civil wedding, and the date on my friend's birth certificate was the church wedding. Both letters are from the year 1980, and she was born in 1984. We find this very weird.. What is USCIS implying? Any thoughts?

Naturalization:

09/11/2010 - Sent N400 Application (with fee waiver request) to Phoenix, AZ

02/16/2011 - I'm a US Citizen!!

K1 Visa for Fiancee:

03/11/2011 - Sent I-129 Application

03/15/2011 - NOA1 via Email

03/17/2011 - NOA1 Hard Copy

05/26/2011 - RFE

06/10/2011 - RFE Response

06/15/2011 - NOA 2 via Email

06/18/2011 - NOA 2 Hard Copy

07/13/2011 - NVC Received Case

07/15/2011 - NVC forwards to US Embassy Singapore

07/17/2011 - Consulate Received Case

07/21/2011 - Packet 3 Received

07/22/2011 - Packet 3 returned

07/29/2011 - Packet 4 Received, Interview Scheduled

08/19/2011 - Interview APPROVED!!

08/26/2011 - Visa on Hand

08/30/2011 - POE, Honolulu, HI

AOS

10/08/2011 - Married in Las Vegas

11/02/2011 - Sent I-485, I-131, I765 to Chicago Lockbox

11/04/2011 - Received and was signed for

11/17/2011 - Acceptance Text Message from USCIS dated Nov 4

11/24/2011 - NOA Hard Copy

11/28/2011 - Biometrics Appointment 12/14/2011

12/07/2011 - Walk in Biometrics

01/05/2012 - I-765 approved + Ordered production of Card

01/13/2012 - Combo Card received , I-1765 and I-131

01/19/2012 - Interview notice! Set for 02/24/2012

02/24/2012 - Interview done! One more background check!

02/24/2012 - USCIS Card Production Notification

02/26/2012 - USCIS Decision Notification (Approval)

03/05/2012 - GC on hand!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lenchick Community Regular

Lenchick   133

Posted
Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa (DCF) Timeline
Posted

This is for a friend of ours that just recently filed a petition for her parents. They received an RFE and it stated that they need proof of a Bona Fide Father/Child Relationship because there is a discrepancy on the marriage date listed on the Marriage Contract and my friends Birth Certificate. The date on the marriage contract was their civil wedding, and the date on my friend's birth certificate was the church wedding. Both letters are from the year 1980, and she was born in 1984. We find this very weird.. What is USCIS implying? Any thoughts?

They probably want a DNA test or earlier records, that he is your friend's father.

She also should've made sure the translation was proper for USCIS to understand that those were dates for different types of wedding ceremonies if I got you correctly. Incomplete translations could really cause problems.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
RichardShane Explorer

RichardShane   2

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Philippines
 Timeline
  • Author
Posted

I think that only matters if you were born after your parent's marriage? no? She was born 4 years after the wedding.. that's why we were wondering..

Naturalization:

09/11/2010 - Sent N400 Application (with fee waiver request) to Phoenix, AZ

02/16/2011 - I'm a US Citizen!!

K1 Visa for Fiancee:

03/11/2011 - Sent I-129 Application

03/15/2011 - NOA1 via Email

03/17/2011 - NOA1 Hard Copy

05/26/2011 - RFE

06/10/2011 - RFE Response

06/15/2011 - NOA 2 via Email

06/18/2011 - NOA 2 Hard Copy

07/13/2011 - NVC Received Case

07/15/2011 - NVC forwards to US Embassy Singapore

07/17/2011 - Consulate Received Case

07/21/2011 - Packet 3 Received

07/22/2011 - Packet 3 returned

07/29/2011 - Packet 4 Received, Interview Scheduled

08/19/2011 - Interview APPROVED!!

08/26/2011 - Visa on Hand

08/30/2011 - POE, Honolulu, HI

AOS

10/08/2011 - Married in Las Vegas

11/02/2011 - Sent I-485, I-131, I765 to Chicago Lockbox

11/04/2011 - Received and was signed for

11/17/2011 - Acceptance Text Message from USCIS dated Nov 4

11/24/2011 - NOA Hard Copy

11/28/2011 - Biometrics Appointment 12/14/2011

12/07/2011 - Walk in Biometrics

01/05/2012 - I-765 approved + Ordered production of Card

01/13/2012 - Combo Card received , I-1765 and I-131

01/19/2012 - Interview notice! Set for 02/24/2012

02/24/2012 - Interview done! One more background check!

02/24/2012 - USCIS Card Production Notification

02/26/2012 - USCIS Decision Notification (Approval)

03/05/2012 - GC on hand!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
RichardShane Explorer

RichardShane   2

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Philippines
 Timeline
  • Author
Posted

oooops! I wasn't very clear on my initial post. Both "Marriages" are on the year 1980, and she was born in 1984..

Naturalization:

09/11/2010 - Sent N400 Application (with fee waiver request) to Phoenix, AZ

02/16/2011 - I'm a US Citizen!!

K1 Visa for Fiancee:

03/11/2011 - Sent I-129 Application

03/15/2011 - NOA1 via Email

03/17/2011 - NOA1 Hard Copy

05/26/2011 - RFE

06/10/2011 - RFE Response

06/15/2011 - NOA 2 via Email

06/18/2011 - NOA 2 Hard Copy

07/13/2011 - NVC Received Case

07/15/2011 - NVC forwards to US Embassy Singapore

07/17/2011 - Consulate Received Case

07/21/2011 - Packet 3 Received

07/22/2011 - Packet 3 returned

07/29/2011 - Packet 4 Received, Interview Scheduled

08/19/2011 - Interview APPROVED!!

08/26/2011 - Visa on Hand

08/30/2011 - POE, Honolulu, HI

AOS

10/08/2011 - Married in Las Vegas

11/02/2011 - Sent I-485, I-131, I765 to Chicago Lockbox

11/04/2011 - Received and was signed for

11/17/2011 - Acceptance Text Message from USCIS dated Nov 4

11/24/2011 - NOA Hard Copy

11/28/2011 - Biometrics Appointment 12/14/2011

12/07/2011 - Walk in Biometrics

01/05/2012 - I-765 approved + Ordered production of Card

01/13/2012 - Combo Card received , I-1765 and I-131

01/19/2012 - Interview notice! Set for 02/24/2012

02/24/2012 - Interview done! One more background check!

02/24/2012 - USCIS Card Production Notification

02/26/2012 - USCIS Decision Notification (Approval)

03/05/2012 - GC on hand!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lenchick Community Regular

Lenchick   133

Posted
Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa (DCF) Timeline
Posted

oooops! I wasn't very clear on my initial post. Both "Marriages" are on the year 1980, and she was born in 1984..

what did you mean here then? -"The date on the marriage contract was their civil wedding, and the date on my friend's birth certificate was the church wedding."

You also mentioned that USCIS found discrepancy in dates.

In any case they need more proofs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Harpa Timsah Grand Master

Harpa Timsah   13,258

Posted
Filed: Lift. Cond. (apr) Country: Israel
 Timeline
Posted

Doesn't matter what the dates are (post-marriage birth, etc). The discrepancy is enough to make them think that this person is not her real father. It is fairly common that people try to petition for other people that are not really their relatives using falsified documents.

AOS for my husband
8/17/10: INTERVIEW DAY (day 123) APPROVED!!

ROC:
5/23/12: Sent out package
2/06/13: APPROVED!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
RichardShane Explorer

RichardShane   2

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Philippines
 Timeline
  • Author
Posted

what did you mean here then? -"The date on the marriage contract was their civil wedding, and the date on my friend's birth certificate was the church wedding."

You also mentioned that USCIS found discrepancy in dates.

In any case they need more proofs.

Oh man.. I was on a hurry when I was typing this.. sorry for the confusion. LOL. So, the marriage contract that was sent with the application was her parent's "civil wedding" which is basically the official marriage.. however, when she was born in 1984, the wedding date that they put on her birth certificate was their "church wedding". Both weddings occurred in 1980.. I believe it was two months apart..

Date on the Marriage Contract: February 1980 (official marriage certificate)

Marriage date on my friend's official birth certificate was: April 1980 (church wedding)

She was born in 1984

I hope I'm clear. lol

Naturalization:

09/11/2010 - Sent N400 Application (with fee waiver request) to Phoenix, AZ

02/16/2011 - I'm a US Citizen!!

K1 Visa for Fiancee:

03/11/2011 - Sent I-129 Application

03/15/2011 - NOA1 via Email

03/17/2011 - NOA1 Hard Copy

05/26/2011 - RFE

06/10/2011 - RFE Response

06/15/2011 - NOA 2 via Email

06/18/2011 - NOA 2 Hard Copy

07/13/2011 - NVC Received Case

07/15/2011 - NVC forwards to US Embassy Singapore

07/17/2011 - Consulate Received Case

07/21/2011 - Packet 3 Received

07/22/2011 - Packet 3 returned

07/29/2011 - Packet 4 Received, Interview Scheduled

08/19/2011 - Interview APPROVED!!

08/26/2011 - Visa on Hand

08/30/2011 - POE, Honolulu, HI

AOS

10/08/2011 - Married in Las Vegas

11/02/2011 - Sent I-485, I-131, I765 to Chicago Lockbox

11/04/2011 - Received and was signed for

11/17/2011 - Acceptance Text Message from USCIS dated Nov 4

11/24/2011 - NOA Hard Copy

11/28/2011 - Biometrics Appointment 12/14/2011

12/07/2011 - Walk in Biometrics

01/05/2012 - I-765 approved + Ordered production of Card

01/13/2012 - Combo Card received , I-1765 and I-131

01/19/2012 - Interview notice! Set for 02/24/2012

02/24/2012 - Interview done! One more background check!

02/24/2012 - USCIS Card Production Notification

02/26/2012 - USCIS Decision Notification (Approval)

03/05/2012 - GC on hand!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Lenchick Community Regular

Lenchick   133

Posted
Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa (DCF) Timeline
Posted

Doesn't matter what the dates are (post-marriage birth, etc). The discrepancy is enough to make them think that this person is not her real father. It is fairly common that people try to petition for other people that are not really their relatives using falsified documents.

I absolutely agree with your statement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
RichardShane Explorer

RichardShane   2

Posted
Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Philippines
 Timeline
  • Author
Posted

Doesn't matter what the dates are (post-marriage birth, etc). The discrepancy is enough to make them think that this person is not her real father. It is fairly common that people try to petition for other people that are not really their relatives using falsified documents.

Oh I see. So I think that's what they suspect then.. I thought the bona fide relationship requirement is only if you were born out of wedlock, because that's what they are requiring her to do..

Naturalization:

09/11/2010 - Sent N400 Application (with fee waiver request) to Phoenix, AZ

02/16/2011 - I'm a US Citizen!!

K1 Visa for Fiancee:

03/11/2011 - Sent I-129 Application

03/15/2011 - NOA1 via Email

03/17/2011 - NOA1 Hard Copy

05/26/2011 - RFE

06/10/2011 - RFE Response

06/15/2011 - NOA 2 via Email

06/18/2011 - NOA 2 Hard Copy

07/13/2011 - NVC Received Case

07/15/2011 - NVC forwards to US Embassy Singapore

07/17/2011 - Consulate Received Case

07/21/2011 - Packet 3 Received

07/22/2011 - Packet 3 returned

07/29/2011 - Packet 4 Received, Interview Scheduled

08/19/2011 - Interview APPROVED!!

08/26/2011 - Visa on Hand

08/30/2011 - POE, Honolulu, HI

AOS

10/08/2011 - Married in Las Vegas

11/02/2011 - Sent I-485, I-131, I765 to Chicago Lockbox

11/04/2011 - Received and was signed for

11/17/2011 - Acceptance Text Message from USCIS dated Nov 4

11/24/2011 - NOA Hard Copy

11/28/2011 - Biometrics Appointment 12/14/2011

12/07/2011 - Walk in Biometrics

01/05/2012 - I-765 approved + Ordered production of Card

01/13/2012 - Combo Card received , I-1765 and I-131

01/19/2012 - Interview notice! Set for 02/24/2012

02/24/2012 - Interview done! One more background check!

02/24/2012 - USCIS Card Production Notification

02/26/2012 - USCIS Decision Notification (Approval)

03/05/2012 - GC on hand!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Unlockable Mentor

Unlockable   7,306

Posted
Filed: Citizen (pnd) Country: Dominican Republic
 Timeline
Posted

No.

They can ask for proof of siblings in any situation. Married or not.

Advise your friend to be prepared to provide proof. DNA, birth cert., etc.

“When starting an immigration journey, the best advice is to understand that sacrifices have to be made... whether it is time, money, or separation; or a combination of all.” - Unlockable

Link to comment
Share on other sites
 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...