American Idol May 11

[Cristy 4]

Who should win?

[rejane 1]

I want elliott to win...

[*Robert* 2]

I want Kat. She's good looking and has a great voice. Elliot looks like an elf and Taylor looks like he's constapated! When he tries to dance on stage he looks likes he's a retard!

Maybe some of you women who love Taylor can explain why, and I'm curious what the age group is that likes him as well?

[giraffemd 0]

Taylor please.

[Anyta Holland 0]

Now that Chris is gone.... TAYLOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[sparkofcreation 0]

Kat.

I feel like Taylor's a big joke, people like him 'cause he's wacky, but be honest: how many would buy an album by him? When they couldn't watch his antics? He can sing, he proved that with "In the Ghetto," but that's not where his fan base is. His fan base wants to see him dance to "Jailhouse Rock." I admit I enjoyed that, but I wouldn't get that with a CD.

Elliott, frankly, is not good. He's trying to step into a niche that's already stuffed full of other singers, and he's not as good as them and he's not as good as the other contestants. He should've been gone before Paris.

I'd like it to come down to Taylor and Kat, because the #2 person will get a record deal anyway (Clay Aiken, Bo Bice) and I don't think Elliott deserves one. I don't think Taylor does either, but I want Kat in the top 2 at least and I think she's more likely to beat Taylor than Elliott if it comes down to that.

Have y'all heard that Chris supposedly didn't really have the lowest vote total, it's that he's signed a contract with a band and that's against AI's terms for its contestants?

Edited May 13, 2006 by sparkofcreation

[alexil74 0]

Taylor

[KarenCee 3]

I want Kat. She's good looking and has a great voice. Elliot looks like an elf and Taylor looks like he's constapated! When he tries to dance on stage he looks likes he's a retard!

Maybe some of you women who love Taylor can explain why, and I'm curious what the age group is that likes him as well?

I vote for Taylor...nothing to do with his looks or age...I'm probly older than he is. But, I like the way he sings.

Just a side note here...I wish people would be careful of using the word "retard" in the context that it was used...I teach Special Education students and its terms like this that are...shall I say...hurtful? Not trying to start a war here...I'm just particular to "my" kids and I've heard that term used way too many times in regards to the kids I've taught over the years.

[silvanski 1]

Chris

OK Taylor then

Edited May 13, 2006 by Silvanski

[MichelleandCraig 1]

Silvy, you stole the words right from my keys before I got the chance to type them.

CHRIS!!!! GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRrrrrrr.

But..I voted for Elliot. I like Kat's voice, but she's just on my nerves after she had a HORRIBLE week and Chris left anyway. Maybe not her fault, but I don't care.

Taylor, I like alright...I love his personality, his singing is, in Randy's words, "just ok for me, dawg" but I think Elliot has a really good voice. M.

[nayalamb 0]

SILVER ALL THE WAY!!!

go taylor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i like elliott but i think taylor is just so... unique...

[silvanski 1]

I mean Taylor is a great entertainer (has a CD out BTW "Under The Radar") and is -as the British say- an all-round good egg; I liked him a lot from the start, but Chris undoubtedly has more charisma... anyway what's happened has happened and Taylor can count on my vote from now on

[Jenn! 918]

Did you all hear that Fuel wants Chris as their new lead singer? He will have to wait until after the AI tour to accept though.

[Indo_mommy 0]

Did you all hear that Fuel wants Chris as their new lead singer? He will have to wait until after the AI tour to accept though.

Yep hear about that too and they said Chris' band just got signed.

[iceyspots 0]

elliot