Apply j1 and had asylum final denied, now still maintain f1 visa

[Kiroshi85 0]

Hello everyone

I came to United States in 2011 on f1 visa, I am still maintaining my status and will be expired dec 2016.in 2014 I got final denial for asylum. In the next couple of months, I will apply j1 for physician training job. I have been searching information that I will have a problem with my j1 visa because history of asylum. If I am back to my country indonesia, I can't get any non immigration visa except h1b. Can somebody tell me that I can fight or try to get j1?

[Alaska2012 462]

What were your grounds for asylum if I may ask?

[Boiler 43,619]

Was the application deemed frivolous?

[Jawaree 717]

If frivolous you have a prob If you are in a committed relationship & intend to stay

with the individual then think about getting marry....Its must be a bonafide relationship

with a ISC or GC holder, and speak with an atty or legal aid

[HFM181818 748]

so, why is it that you would return to Indonesia after the J1? It certainly does not sound like that's the plan.

My guess, as far as the basis for the asylum claim, (like so many others) is someone called him a name......and his attorney spun up a cover letter making that name calling into 'persecution.'

Really, how does a 20-something claim persecution? In a country like Indonesia, he would not even be on anyone's radar screen for anything.

Personally, I think asylum should be ended....it's really nothing more than a game, in which the best liar wins.

[Kiroshi85 0]

@hfm this post not to discuss about asylum. But j1.its final decision don't have enough price, only story. I did not report to cops, and I got assaulted in the street, he broke my car and asked never come to his area because I am inherited Chinese, and I Dont belong to Indonesia. Search about crisis may 1998. It is iceberg they need a reason like crisis economy, to rob and rape Chinese.

I am staying here. I am a foreign physician but my hospital only provide j1.

[Boiler 43,619]

Sounds frivolous.

[HFM181818 748]

_{Fairy tales....'oh gosh, I got a speeding ticket....I was persecuted...gimme asylum'....sheesh....asylum is just a story-telling contest, nothing more. End asylum, end COS, end waivers.}

[Alaska2012 462]

Ummm that doesn't sound like a reason for asylum. That can happen to you over here too....What you gonna do then? Seek asylum in Canada?

[Boiler 43,619]

TOS violation reported

[TBoneTX 43,287]

The post below has been edited to remove a Terms of Service violation and is returned to the thread as follows:

I di not get a ticket. Lol, somebody driver slip in front of my car, I got punches several times. Bruise in my face, he broke my car.

OP, this is your only verbal warning. We do not insult other members. When you joined this site, you agreed to adhere to the Terms of Service, which are found here: http://www.visajourney.com/content/terms . Modify your posting behavior, immediately and permanently.

TBoneTX

VJ Moderation

[Kiroshi85 0]

Please for other member, I do not need your comments about my asylum. I prefer somebody help me and not critics me because I have done with my asylum please be wise and smart. I have a question regarding j1 not about my asylum. People don't understand my post, this post in j1 or exchange visa. I have a history. And it means I did not get my asylum. My concern about my j1 cause I need it for work. Sometimes I need to be patient , we can't control what people want to say in this thread. Just comment if you have experience or information then if you do not have it and ignore it.

[HFM181818 748]

it is doubtful that anyone who visits this site will reach out to someone who has tried to game our laws and is now looking for another way to do the same.

[Boiler 43,619]

The frivolous Asylum claim is highly relevant when applying for another nonimmigrant visa/status.

[Ischnura 285]

Why is it so important that you stay in the US? If you're being persecuted so badly why not try another country if this one doesn't want you? Surely anywhere else would be better if you need out that badly.