Mixel96

the 2 hole punch way was the way I was told when I submitted my I-129F, I was also was under the impression that leaving all the paper as it was with only a large black Clip to hold it all together was also acceptable.

Starting April 1st, EAD (I-765) and AP (I-131) will require additional fees when filed with I-485. I hope it helps
 
 

Will likely be denied. But, no harm in applying if money is not an issue. 

A lot of this depends on the Consulate, you mention ESTA so I doubt you have too much to worry about.
 
I think my letter was one sentence. None was interested in looking at more that a photo of both of us.

As long as there was no misrepresentation, I don’t see an issue with the previous denials. 

Starting April, you'd have to pay $3005 of adjusment of status fees when she enters the US on K-1 visa and you marry. That's in addition to whatever fees you're filing now for I-129F and embassy.
 
For spousal visa, you'd pay similar fees at the beginning and only $220 for green card when she enters the US.
 
The difference is give or take $2500, that's how more expensive K-1 is compared to spousal visa.
 
Plus with K-1 she'd be stuck in the US for 6-12 months not able to work or travel. Some EADs come fast, while others take 9 months or so.
 
Essentially, if she enters as a spouse, you'd pay fewer fees and she'd be able to start working within few weeks of entering. Even if it's a small part time job, it can make a big difference. Plus, when entering on spousal visa she can travel internationally next day if she desires, while with K-1 she may get stuck for 6-18 months until GC or advance parole shows up.

You can just cut it, that’s what we did 

At this point it doesn't matter. But it's just the beginning of the fiance route. It's the more expensive route compared to spousal visa. Are you sure you can handle it financially?

With two denials, you have an uphill battle in front of you. Good luck.

*For my matter

Hello guys,
 
I am still in the process of selecting the proper lawyer for my case. 
 
does anyone here have experience with the DHS TRIP here?

So.. I am telling you guys, I got close. 
 
It went way better than I expected it to go, but still not well enough. The lady was very nice and asked me lots of questions I could easily answer (university choice, career plan, financial support) before she referred to the refused admission with ESTA. She asked me to walk her through it and she showed understanding, which made me feel quite positive. I was prepared to present strong ties and even there her reaction seemed to be „good“. But to finish the interview of, she said: „Oh I see you didn’t mention you already had an appointment in May. I can’t overrule my managers decision, I am sorry“
 
I mean honestly, this is kind of unfair. I explained the misunderstanding with the refused admission and she showed her understanding for that. The previous denial was solely based on one question the embassy officer asked me: „what happened to Chicago?“
 
I don’t get it why she did not know from the beginning that this was my second attempt. I don’t blame myself this time because I answered everything well. I guess I’ve got to accept that I won’t get a student visa for wanting to be a student..

So.. I am telling you guys, I got close. 
 
It went way better than I expected it to go, but still not well enough. The lady was very nice and asked me lots of questions I could easily answer (university choice, career plan, financial support) before she referred to the refused admission with ESTA. She asked me to walk her through it and she showed understanding, which made me feel quite positive. I was prepared to present strong ties and even there her reaction seemed to be „good“. But to finish the interview of, she said: „Oh I see you didn’t mention you already had an appointment in May. I can’t overrule my managers decision, I am sorry“
 
I mean honestly, this is kind of unfair. I explained the misunderstanding with the refused admission and she showed her understanding for that. The previous denial was solely based on one question the embassy officer asked me: „what happened to Chicago?“
 
I don’t get it why she did not know from the beginning that this was my second attempt. I don’t blame myself this time because I answered everything well. I guess I’ve got to accept that I won’t get a student visa for wanting to be a student..

They are. It’s just still Kind if alright. My dad is capable of taking care but the past years he clearly becomes worse with the time. I definitely want to come back to support them in case I can purse my masters. 
 
my girlfriend is right now here in Germany and really likes it. So we now actually aim to come here after her studies are done. 
 
also I am about to start or re-start my own small business again. Do you think this would be a strong enough tie when it’s located here in Germany ?
No

Yes that’s what I assume as well. Just saw the redress program as a possible way to „fight“ a decision like that. 
 
the lawyer btw told me that there is a way to solve the issue. He also mentioned the DHS trip inquiry . I will keep you updated 

Thank you that helps a lot. So do you think instead of reapplying for this fall, only consider spring 2023/fall2023? 
 
I‘ll see what the lawyer has to say abt this. His names is Michael Jackson so my hopes are up 😄😄

As i said more than once now, I left and then re-entered before the grace period started

Yeah I already thought about that. But with a visa an officer at the border can not just deny you, it has to go through a judge. 
 
also I left during my J1 and re-entered when it was still active. My program didnt end on paper yet. Spent the grace period and left by end of January. Then I applied for esta and travelled at 30th of march again. 

Okay. But there are lots of people who receive their F1 in their second, third or even fourth/fifth attempt. Don’t you think I can work on building a strong case on why I will go back to Germany as soon as studies are completed and then have a go again ? I’ve read a lot that is sometimes also based on luck with the officers you have the interview with. Because in the end, their review is totally subjective..

I want to consult my lawyer starting next week and see what he suggests me to do. As long as I don’t feel confident in providing new circumstances I won’t reapply. 
 
do you think it would be a good idea to list the university campus as a „home adress“ while staying in the US instead of my girlfriends house? If they ask me why I changed it, I would say we broke up. 

@SusieQQQ
yes and I understand by now that that was the reason I was denied entry at that time. But isn’t it just common sense to talk about the possible future, its not equal to an intention for me.
 
my evidence would be that me and my girlfriend agreed to move to Germany after I complete my masters degree. Further I have a strong social life with engagements  in a soccer club. All of my family is also here and we are very close. My mom and dad are not in a good shape health wise, so I want to support them again as soon as possible. Also I want to use my degree to apply at Mercedes-Benz where I had an internship and they are located here. It’s my dream position and going for an international master is benefiting me for that.

Is there any way to fight the statement? With an appropriate lawyer or the traveler redress inquiry program ?
 
the statement says: 
Q: during the initial interview you stated that you are planning to look for internships and maybe looking into a Masters programs in the US, is this correct ?
A: Yes 
—> I was clearly referring to the past in terms of the internship, and the future with the masters program
 
Q: you told the officer that you will have a side job if the opportunity came along, is this correct? 
A: Yes.
—> in the initial interview the topic in our conversation was about my future with my Girlfriend and I even added that I know that I would need the appropriate visa for that 

@SusieQQQ
yes and I understand by now that that was the reason I was denied entry at that time. But isn’t it just common sense to talk about the possible future, its not equal to an intention for me.
 
my evidence would be that me and my girlfriend agreed to move to Germany after I complete my masters degree. Further I have a strong social life with engagements  in a soccer club. All of my family is also here and we are very close. My mom and dad are not in a good shape health wise, so I want to support them again as soon as possible. Also I want to use my degree to apply at Mercedes-Benz where I had an internship and they are located here. It’s my dream position and going for an international master is benefiting me for that.

Okay. But there are lots of people who receive their F1 in their second, third or even fourth/fifth attempt. Don’t you think I can work on building a strong case on why I will go back to Germany as soon as studies are completed and then have a go again ? I’ve read a lot that is sometimes also based on luck with the officers you have the interview with. Because in the end, their review is totally subjective..

I want to consult my lawyer starting next week and see what he suggests me to do. As long as I don’t feel confident in providing new circumstances I won’t reapply. 
 
do you think it would be a good idea to list the university campus as a „home adress“ while staying in the US instead of my girlfriends house? If they ask me why I changed it, I would say we broke up.