Enough supporting our I-751 ??

[jess100 53]

What do you all think about the supporting evidence we are submitting.  We don't mix our bank accounts because we both have businesses, and it makes taxes and accounting a lot easier to not mix these-we just pay from my personal account..  I'm concerned this will be a red flag-so do we have enough to overcome that? if it's not evident, I travel with my husband for his business-which is why there is so much business travel in the beginning.

 

 

 

INCOME TAXES

Copy of 2016 and 2017 tax returns showing both names, common address, and both businesses; SPOUSE has BUSINESS, LLC and US CITIZEN has rental apartments, seen on Schedule E.

 

BUSINESS

Copy of New York State Taxation & Finance Business Registration for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS, LLC showing US CITIZEN as contact person(printed directly from the website)

Copy of Articles of Organization for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS LLC showing US CITIZEN as contact person/responsible person.

 

BUSINESS TRAVEL FOR SPOUSE'S BUSINESS, LLC

 

DEC 2016 Smithsonian Art Market, New York City

Copy of Airbnb reservation for SPOUSE and US CITIZEN in NYC-reserved by US CITIZEN

Copy of US CITIZEN'S checking account showing parking & meals paid by US CITIZEN from checking account XXXX

photo of us in front of St. Patrick's Cathedral, NYC

 

 

DEC 2017-Smithsonian Art Market, Washington, DC

Airbnb receipt showing reservation made by SPOUSE and paid by US CITIZEN (ONLINE BANK; Card #XXXX)

copy of participating show artists naming SPOUSE

copy of US CITIZEN's bank statement showing that I paid food in DC?

Copy of tickets to Senate for both of us

 

 

MAY 2018- XXXX Art Show, Ulster Co. Fairgrounds, New Paltz NY

Copy of Airbnb reservation for US CITIZEN and SPOUSE made by SPOUSE (paid by XX)

Copy of ONLINE BANK debit card of US CITIZEN and receipt for cash withdrawl from Ulster Co. Fairgrounds, showing we both were at this show together for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS.

Copy of Woodstock New Paltz show brochure

Copy of check sent by SPOUSE to show orgaizer to participate in this event.

 

 

SEPT 2018- Art Show Ulster Co. Fairgrounds

Copy of payment by SPOUSE to show promoter

copy of hotel receipt paid by US CITIZEN

 

 

RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS

 

Copy of US CITIZEN's Deferred Compensation Retirement Fund-showing SPOUSE as beneficiary

Copy of US CITIZEN's Retirement Account #2 “Confirmation of Beneficiaries” dated 7/2016 showing SPOUSE as beneficiary. (4 accounts/4pages)

Note that I have chosen that the children of SPOUSE also benefit.

 

BANKING

 

Copy of statement from LOCAL Credit Union that SPOUSE and US CITIZEN share access to SPOUSE's personal account

 

Copy of voided check of SPOUSE showing personal account number, and both names.

 

Copy of loan application from LOCAL Credit Union for SPOUSE for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS, LLC co-signed by US CITIZEN

 

Copy of US CITIZEN's LOCAL Credit Union account showing SPOUSE as the payable on death designation

 

Copy of US CITIZEN's BANK security box permissions showing SPOUSE having access.

 

Copy of bank account at BANK of US CITIZEN ( page screenshot ) showing SPOUSE having access. (bank does not have any formal document stating same).

 

We share a card linked to US CITIZEN's LOCAL BANK account__________for emergencies, but have never used it. How to show these are linked?

 

 

WILL AND POWER OF ATTORNEY

 

Copy of “Last Will and Testament” of US CITIZEN showing SPOUSE and US CITIZEN's daughter will each inherit a house.

 

Copy of Power of Attorney of US CITIZEN showing SPOUSE as having power to act independently as successor agent.

 

HEALTH/HEALTH INSURANCE

 

Copy of US CITIZEN health insurance “member eligibility” through Excellus Blue Cross/Blue Shield showing SPOUSE as covered person, downloaded from BC/BS website

 

Copy of health insurance “ID card confirmation” showing SPOUSE on US CITIZEN's BC/BS Excellus health insurance (BC/BS does not issue cards bearing covered person's name).

 

Copy of SPOUSE's bill for ENT (doctor) specialist in LOCAL CITY, NY

Copy of bill for SPOUSE's ENT bill paid by US CITIZEN from ONLINE BANK (bill pay account)

 

 

TRAVEL

MEDICAL TRAVEL

CLINIC, CA. AUGUST 2017

Copy of plane tickets to San Jose, CA. for US CITIZEN & SPOUSE to see Dr. XXX for tick borne diseases, at CLINIC .

Copy of Dr. XXXX's bill for US CITIZEN and SPOUSE both dated 8/8/17

Copy of Airbnb rentals in Sunnyvale, CA and Santa Rosa, CA

Photos of US CITIZEN & SPOUSE in redwoods camp ground near San Francisco, CA

 

RECREATIONAL TRAVEL

9-10/2016

Copy of Airbnb receipt for Maine __________date (to visit family)

photo of us and US CITIZEN's daughter and boyfriend at restaurant near Bristol, ME

photo of CITIZEN & SPOUSE on the dock in Bristol, ME

 

 

5/2017

Copy of Airbnb reciepts in Silver City, NM (reserved by/paid by -I will add this info) ..

Photo of us at Buckhorn Tavern, Silver City, NM

Photo of us at scenic pull-off on mountain road going to Ruidoso, NM

 

4/2017 CITY, MAINE

Copy of Airbnb receipt for Bristol, Maine (to visit US CITIZEN's family)

Photos of US CITIZEN & SPOUSE at Pemaquid Point lighthouse, Bristol ME

Photo of CITIZEN & SPOUSE at LL Bean store, Freeport, ME

 

 

APRIL 2018-Mexico City

Copies of plane tickets from Mexico City to NY for both of us (SPOUSE went to Mexico earlier for family emergency-US CITIZEN joined him later)

Photos of us in “Marco Polo Restaurant”, in CITY, STATE, Mexico

Photos in Mexico City near statue XXXXX

Airbnb receipt for Mexico City (paid by /reserved by)

 

AUG 2018 Philadephia, PA

Airbnb receipt for Philadelphia, PA

Photo of us at Independence Hall

Copies of our tickets to the Museum of the American Revolution

Photo of CITIZEN & SPOUSE with US CITIZEN's nephew, XXX in front of the Museum of Art

 

 

PHOTOS of WEDDING

 

Photos of wedding ceremony held at our farm on June 18, 2016 for family and close friends.

Photo of us getting tent and decorations ready

2 photos of the ceremony on our farm

1 photo of us planting an apple tree on our farm after ceremony

2 photos us at restaurant after wedding ceremony

 

PHOTOS with FAMILY

Photos of US CITIZEN family reunion, CITY, PA. June 2018 with US CITIZEN & SPOUSE in back, standing

 

CORRESPONDENCES

 

Thank you card from US CITIZEN's nephew, XXX stating it was good to see both of us in Maine. See above Maine trip.

 

Letter of close friend, stating knowledge of our relationship.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[AlluringSoul 185]

1 hour ago, jess100 said:

What do you all think about the supporting evidence we are submitting.  We don't mix our bank accounts because we both have businesses, and it makes taxes and accounting a lot easier to not mix these-we just pay from my personal account..  I'm concerned this will be a red flag-so do we have enough to overcome that? if it's not evident, I travel with my husband for his business-which is why there is so much business travel in the beginning.

 

 

 

INCOME TAXES

Copy of 2016 and 2017 tax returns showing both names, common address, and both businesses; SPOUSE has BUSINESS, LLC and US CITIZEN has rental apartments, seen on Schedule E.

 

BUSINESS

Copy of New York State Taxation & Finance Business Registration for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS, LLC showing US CITIZEN as contact person(printed directly from the website)

Copy of Articles of Organization for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS LLC showing US CITIZEN as contact person/responsible person.

 

BUSINESS TRAVEL FOR SPOUSE'S BUSINESS, LLC

 

DEC 2016 Smithsonian Art Market, New York City

Copy of Airbnb reservation for SPOUSE and US CITIZEN in NYC-reserved by US CITIZEN

Copy of US CITIZEN'S checking account showing parking & meals paid by US CITIZEN from checking account XXXX

photo of us in front of St. Patrick's Cathedral, NYC

 

 

DEC 2017-Smithsonian Art Market, Washington, DC

Airbnb receipt showing reservation made by SPOUSE and paid by US CITIZEN (ONLINE BANK; Card #XXXX)

copy of participating show artists naming SPOUSE

copy of US CITIZEN's bank statement showing that I paid food in DC?

Copy of tickets to Senate for both of us

 

 

MAY 2018- XXXX Art Show, Ulster Co. Fairgrounds, New Paltz NY

Copy of Airbnb reservation for US CITIZEN and SPOUSE made by SPOUSE (paid by XX)

Copy of ONLINE BANK debit card of US CITIZEN and receipt for cash withdrawl from Ulster Co. Fairgrounds, showing we both were at this show together for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS.

Copy of Woodstock New Paltz show brochure

Copy of check sent by SPOUSE to show orgaizer to participate in this event.

 

 

SEPT 2018- Art Show Ulster Co. Fairgrounds

Copy of payment by SPOUSE to show promoter

copy of hotel receipt paid by US CITIZEN

 

 

RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS

 

Copy of US CITIZEN's Deferred Compensation Retirement Fund-showing SPOUSE as beneficiary

Copy of US CITIZEN's Retirement Account #2 “Confirmation of Beneficiaries” dated 7/2016 showing SPOUSE as beneficiary. (4 accounts/4pages)

Note that I have chosen that the children of SPOUSE also benefit.

 

BANKING

 

Copy of statement from LOCAL Credit Union that SPOUSE and US CITIZEN share access to SPOUSE's personal account

 

Copy of voided check of SPOUSE showing personal account number, and both names.

 

Copy of loan application from LOCAL Credit Union for SPOUSE for SPOUSE'S BUSINESS, LLC co-signed by US CITIZEN

 

Copy of US CITIZEN's LOCAL Credit Union account showing SPOUSE as the payable on death designation

 

Copy of US CITIZEN's BANK security box permissions showing SPOUSE having access.

 

Copy of bank account at BANK of US CITIZEN ( page screenshot ) showing SPOUSE having access. (bank does not have any formal document stating same).

 

We share a card linked to US CITIZEN's LOCAL BANK account__________for emergencies, but have never used it. How to show these are linked?

 

 

WILL AND POWER OF ATTORNEY

 

Copy of “Last Will and Testament” of US CITIZEN showing SPOUSE and US CITIZEN's daughter will each inherit a house.

 

Copy of Power of Attorney of US CITIZEN showing SPOUSE as having power to act independently as successor agent.

 

HEALTH/HEALTH INSURANCE

 

Copy of US CITIZEN health insurance “member eligibility” through Excellus Blue Cross/Blue Shield showing SPOUSE as covered person, downloaded from BC/BS website

 

Copy of health insurance “ID card confirmation” showing SPOUSE on US CITIZEN's BC/BS Excellus health insurance (BC/BS does not issue cards bearing covered person's name).

 

Copy of SPOUSE's bill for ENT (doctor) specialist in LOCAL CITY, NY

Copy of bill for SPOUSE's ENT bill paid by US CITIZEN from ONLINE BANK (bill pay account)

 

 

TRAVEL

MEDICAL TRAVEL

CLINIC, CA. AUGUST 2017

Copy of plane tickets to San Jose, CA. for US CITIZEN & SPOUSE to see Dr. XXX for tick borne diseases, at CLINIC .

Copy of Dr. XXXX's bill for US CITIZEN and SPOUSE both dated 8/8/17

Copy of Airbnb rentals in Sunnyvale, CA and Santa Rosa, CA

Photos of US CITIZEN & SPOUSE in redwoods camp ground near San Francisco, CA

 

RECREATIONAL TRAVEL

9-10/2016

Copy of Airbnb receipt for Maine __________date (to visit family)

photo of us and US CITIZEN's daughter and boyfriend at restaurant near Bristol, ME

photo of CITIZEN & SPOUSE on the dock in Bristol, ME

 

 

5/2017

Copy of Airbnb reciepts in Silver City, NM (reserved by/paid by -I will add this info) ..

Photo of us at Buckhorn Tavern, Silver City, NM

Photo of us at scenic pull-off on mountain road going to Ruidoso, NM

 

4/2017 CITY, MAINE

Copy of Airbnb receipt for Bristol, Maine (to visit US CITIZEN's family)

Photos of US CITIZEN & SPOUSE at Pemaquid Point lighthouse, Bristol ME

Photo of CITIZEN & SPOUSE at LL Bean store, Freeport, ME

 

 

APRIL 2018-Mexico City

Copies of plane tickets from Mexico City to NY for both of us (SPOUSE went to Mexico earlier for family emergency-US CITIZEN joined him later)

Photos of us in “Marco Polo Restaurant”, in CITY, STATE, Mexico

Photos in Mexico City near statue XXXXX

Airbnb receipt for Mexico City (paid by /reserved by)

 

AUG 2018 Philadephia, PA

Airbnb receipt for Philadelphia, PA

Photo of us at Independence Hall

Copies of our tickets to the Museum of the American Revolution

Photo of CITIZEN & SPOUSE with US CITIZEN's nephew, XXX in front of the Museum of Art

 

 

PHOTOS of WEDDING

 

Photos of wedding ceremony held at our farm on June 18, 2016 for family and close friends.

Photo of us getting tent and decorations ready

2 photos of the ceremony on our farm

1 photo of us planting an apple tree on our farm after ceremony

2 photos us at restaurant after wedding ceremony

 

PHOTOS with FAMILY

Photos of US CITIZEN family reunion, CITY, PA. June 2018 with US CITIZEN & SPOUSE in back, standing

 

CORRESPONDENCES

 

Thank you card from US CITIZEN's nephew, XXX stating it was good to see both of us in Maine. See above Maine trip.

 

Letter of close friend, stating knowledge of our relationship.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Oh my lord... This is so detailed!!! Yes, this is sufficient. For taxes, you only have 2016 and 2017 available? If you have more, include more. Everyone has a different story but this is a lot of evidence and I think it should be fine. You need to show some sort of co-mingling. Insurance and Will are great as long as you are listed as a beneficiary. Looks good to me.

[hixsy 26]

The only thing I'm not seeing in your list is documents showing you both living together - lease agreements, house deed, utility bills etc.  The evidence you have is good, but feel the addition of those things would strengthen that.

[Lemon23 400]

4 hours ago, AlluringSoul said:

Oh my lord... This is so detailed!!! Yes, this is sufficient. For taxes, you only have 2016 and 2017 available? If you have more, include more. Everyone has a different story but this is a lot of evidence and I think it should be fine. You need to show some sort of co-mingling. Insurance and Will are great as long as you are listed as a beneficiary. Looks good to me.

I agree on this, co-mingling assets and liabilities would be the best evidences and one of the paper work that USCIS usually looking for specially for utility bills.

[jess100 53]

16 hours ago, hixsy said:

The only thing I'm not seeing in your list is documents showing you both living together - lease agreements, house deed, utility bills etc.  The evidence you have is good, but feel the addition of those things would strengthen that.

Thanks for your reply.  That's the thing-I already owned the house and car before he came here-I'm a bit worried that I don't have anything in that area.

Will try to get something else to substantiate this

[jess100 53]

15 hours ago, Lemon23 said:

I agree on this, co-mingling assets and liabilities would be the best evidences and one of the paper work that USCIS usually looking for specially for utility bills.

 

20 hours ago, AlluringSoul said:

Oh my lord... This is so detailed!!! Yes, this is sufficient. For taxes, you only have 2016 and 2017 available? If you have more, include more. Everyone has a different story but this is a lot of evidence and I think it should be fine. You need to show some sort of co-mingling. Insurance and Will are great as long as you are listed as a beneficiary. Looks good to me.

 

15 hours ago, Lemon23 said:

I agree on this, co-mingling assets and liabilities would be the best evidences and one of the paper work that USCIS usually looking for specially for utility bills.

Thanks for these replies-he only arrived in 2016 so that's all the back tax reports we have. (haven't done 2018 yet of course)  Def need more co-mingling which will be hard because we keep it apart for businesses.

[Villanelle 4,122]

I dont know. I read through this and its clear you guys are involved in "business" together but you are not suppose to be proving a business relationship- you need to show a personal one. Have you written an affidavit? How does it look? No personal correspondence between you and your business partner/spouse? Cards, letters, love notes etc. 

Please dont be offended by my comments. Im not sure why exactly your list of evidence is coming off as more of business relationship then a personal one to me but it is. Ive read A LOT of these check my evidence threads over the years and this is just the feeling I get- the adjudicator may feel the same way. Try to round out your packet with more personal stuff. Look through other ROC threads especially those creating alternative evidences. 

[tamcloud 92]

On 9/14/2018 at 4:17 PM, hixsy said:

The only thing I'm not seeing in your list is documents showing you both living together - lease agreements, house deed, utility bills etc.  The evidence you have is good, but feel the addition of those things would strengthen that.

I would agree with having more evidence of co-habitation included. A lease/deed would be great, otherwise even including utility bills with both your names would be good. Otherwise, you've got a strong packet, IMO.

[jess100 53]

On 9/15/2018 at 12:18 PM, Damara said:

I dont know. I read through this and its clear you guys are involved in "business" together but you are not suppose to be proving a business relationship- you need to show a personal one. Have you written an affidavit? How does it look? No personal correspondence between you and your business partner/spouse? Cards, letters, love notes etc. 

Please dont be offended by my comments. Im not sure why exactly your list of evidence is coming off as more of business relationship then a personal one to me but it is. Ive read A LOT of these check my evidence threads over the years and this is just the feeling I get- the adjudicator may feel the same way. Try to round out your packet with more personal stuff. Look through other ROC threads especially those creating alternative evidences. 

Wow thanks for pointing that out.  I didn't think the officer would come away with that idea, but you make an excellent point.   I did include photos (& documents) of us traveling together to see family , and all of us at family reunion and travel for fun.  I could add  some more personal things-

thanks again

21 hours ago, tamcloud said:

I would agree with having more evidence of co-habitation included. A lease/deed would be great, otherwise even including utility bills with both your names would be good. Otherwise, you've got a strong packet, IMO.

Thanks for your response.  Will try to find some utility bills!!