American Idol Season 10

[Jenn! 918]

Did anyone notice that Casey whispered "I love you" to Haley when she survived the cut?

awwww

I loved their duet last night. I have new found respect for Haley - I hope she gets what the judges says and makes better song choices.

Was not sorry to see Paul go. I didn't hate him, but it was his time.

[JohnSmith2007 353]

awwww

I loved their duet last night. I have new found respect for Haley - I hope she gets what the judges says and makes better song choices.

Was not sorry to see Paul go. I didn't hate him, but it was his time.

Yeah, they make a cute couple. I have always liked Haley. I like her Janis Joplin style. I hope she plays on that some more.

[Yurika & Jim 77]

I'm glad Paul is gone. Couldn't stand his "dancing".

"Dancing"? That's more "Skipping around on stage" His skipping always made me embarrassed...

Yes. He shouldn't hold wireless mic. Keep playing guitar please!!

I loved his "Blackbird" in Vegas week though...

Well, I've never been a fan of Stefano. So, I hope he's next (finally)!!

[Zee Bee 61]

Sigh....boring show tonight, except for James. I normally love Jacob, but I do feel like he's been holding back a lot lately.

We'll see what happens tomorrow.

[Yurika & Jim 77]

Sigh....boring show tonight, except for James. I normally love Jacob, but I do feel like he's been holding back a lot lately.

We'll see what happens tomorrow.

Yeah. I even enjoyed Stefano!! This means others were not so good...

My personal bottom 3 of the night: Scotty, Jacob, Lauren...

James' super high second octave singing was quite impressive! Go James Go

[Jenn! 918]

I am pulling for Hailey now to stay in it as long as possible. Girl power!

I think it's Stefano's time to go.

[Krikit 1,163]

I have house guests so I missed Thursday's Idol. Stefano was a good choice.

Did anyone notice that Casey whispered "I love you" to Haley when she survived the cut? Those two have really become an item.

I never saw that. I was busy multi-tasking so only had my eye on the TV occasionally. For some reason Haley irritates the heck out of me. She has a great voice but I find her too annoying. Just like Scotty McLeery. lol. I predict that James will win.

[Snickerz 0]

Top 3 that I like are James, Haley and a tie between Scotty/Casey - haha

[aminah 6]

Does James remind anyone else of Adam Lambert? I wasn't super impressed with him in the beginning, I didn't like his "tail" and still don't. But I gotta admit that the boy catches my attention when he sings.

[Krikit 1,163]

Does James remind anyone else of Adam Lambert? I wasn't super impressed with him in the beginning, I didn't like his "tail" and still don't. But I gotta admit that the boy catches my attention when he sings.

He came out one show and his hair had been Lambertized. Hated it. Maybe that's why you think that. lol

[Yurika & Jim 77]

So... last week was very quiet here... Anyone, any thoughts about leaving of Casey???

Anyway, tonight...

I was disappointed with my James. He looked out of form. Little pitchy, high notes weren't that clear high...

My personal ranking of tonight's performances

1. Scotty 2. Lauren 3. Haley 4. Jacob 5. James

Tomorrow... say good bye to Jacob?

[K and T 0]

Go Jacob!

I mean go home!!!

My list was 1.James 2.Haley 3.Scotty 4.Lauren 5.Jacob

[Amy and Nick 37]

I miss Casey! Seeing his video of his time on the show made me so sad!!

[K and T 0]

As expected.. goodbye Jacob.

[Krikit 1,163]

I've had visitors and now I'm out of town so I haven't been able to watch. I was expecting Casey to go because he growls too much and it is a bit of an irritant. Jacob had to go because he's more "Music Theatre" or "Gospel Idol" than "American Idol". Haley still bugs the ####### out of me, even though she has a great voice. Ditto for the C&W stars. I still think that James should win. He has the best stage presence and showmanship. The others haven't progressed that far, yet. As far as talent goes, they are all #1.