OldUser

I personally don't have experience with this, maybe it's OK? Based on what I see, USCIS generally has higher standards for a lot of things that a regular US person has to deal with: tax filings, criminal records etc. How can you prove to USCIS that you and your US spouse aren't evading taxes? Transcript from USCIS with 0 income is the best proof IMHO. Also, AFAIK, GC holder is should have reported world wide taxes in 2021, even if they came to the US on December 31st, 2021 on CR-1 visa. Are you sure you didn't have to report your income from elsewhere? I'm not a tax specialist or immigration lawyer, just throwing some ideas.

For 2021 you could always file taxes still with 0 income. Tax return transcript is all you need.

I think it was a mistake filing under 3 year rule given shaky marriage with cheating, abusing and addicted person. There's a chance you're going to be grilled about your relationship even at N-400 based on 5 year rule. But should you continue with application filed under 3 year rule? I don't think so. Sorry you're going through this. I think it's time to get the life sorted. Immigration can be put on back burner.

Stay calm, positive. Go through important questions with your spouse. Reherse civics questions. Bring the spouse and updated evidence.

The answers should be accurate and up to date at the time of interview, not just at the time of filing. If anything on the form changes between filing and interview (like training, arrests etc) - you need to tell the officer.

Does I-751 allow uploading stuff nowadays? I thought only N-400 did?

Turbotax transcripts? Yes you can. IRS transcripts are better, but my I-751 got approved with printouts of Turbotax PDFs. Just make sure to submitt all pages for all years.

Yes, I read it. The truth is this number rarely helps, and this is the conclusion many on VJ came to after going through this personally or reading many similar threads.

It's up to you which advice you take. You may try, or you may simply give up and let the case slide into denial. It's your case on the line, you may as well pick your priorities.

Wrong forum I guess? As far as I know there's no direct flights. You can have a stop ovet in Dubai, Doha, China.

I double checked. I think you're right, the premium processing fee can be paid by employee. Thank you for correcting

What do you mean by I-797? I-751?

Looks like being a Pakistani citizen is a requirement to have NICOP - https://www.nadra.gov.pk/identity/identity-nicop/ If you renounce Pakistan's citizenship I'm not 100% sure you'll be eligible for NICOP.

1. Neutralization? That's a scary term 😮 2. You don't need to replace naturalization certificate if you don't want. Paper trail (marriage certificates, divorce certificates, court order for name change) will allow you to prove who you are if ever need to get a US passport again and naturalization certificate is needed for some reason.

In USA you'll be only viewed as a US citizen despite having Pakistani citizenship. In Pakistan you'll only be viewed as a Pakistani citizen, despite having US citizenship. If you owe something to US (like worldwide income taxes), you cannot simply move to Pakistan and not pay them. If you owe something to Pakistan, you can move elsewhere to avoid it (US, etc), but some fine or punishment may be enforced the moment you come back to Pakistan. On a positive side, you can benefit from being a dual citizen. As a US citizen, you get 30 days in Pakistan per visit, whereas as Pakistani you can spend unlimited time there. Obviously, US passport allows you to travel to many more destinations visa free compared to Pakistani one.

Every N-400 has an interview. Interview is a perfect chance to do corrections to application. You can create an errata sheet describing all changes to N-400 you need to make. Let IO know before interview starts that you have some answers to update and hand them over the errata sheet.

I'd say yes and list the class name to explain. Then leave to IO to decide whether it really should be yes or switched to no.

Like the the H-1B itself, you cannot pay the premium processing fee yourself. But your employer can. It's worth explaining the benefits of doing it to employer 🙂

Depends on the laws of country. When taking oath becoming a US citizen, you promise to: "that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law; " Now imagine you're back in Pakistan and a war breaks out. Based on Pakistan's constitution, you may be required to fight in that war (please confirm with experts in Pakistani's laws). US citizenship won't help as you're a dual citizen and have duties to both countries. If you renounced Pakistani citizenship you probably won't need to participate in defending it.

Yes, you have duties to each country of citizenship, such as military service.

Not required but I would include copy of extension letter to make sure reviewer is aware you have I-751 pending.

They don't need a new SSN. They already have it. It's given once in a lifetime.

Looks like you had to start with I-90 for your green card error...

Request here https://egov.uscis.gov/e-request/displayNDNForm.do?sroPageType=ndn&entryPoint=init

Data point: https://np.reddit.com/r/USCIS/comments/boa88b/basically_forced_to_withdraw_application_at/ "He disappears and is gone for 10-ish minutes, apparently talking to a supervisor, comes back and tells me that my I-751 shouldn't have been processed because according to my divorce papers my wife and I separated 10 months prior to the I-751 being finalized, even though the final divorce date was 4 months AFTER that. Essentially he gives me the option of having my application denied, detained and to go in front of an immigration judge and potential deportation, or "voluntarily" withdraw my application. I was in complete shock, I've been living here perfectly happy with my 10 year green card not knowing there was some technicality that would prevent me from becoming a citizen, I ask if I can speak to someone else, he says no that he already spoke to his supervisor and that's where the options came from and that he couldn't offer me any kind of advice on the situation. He was extremely rude, blunt and not helpful or sympathetic at all. Pushed a blank piece of paper in front of me with a pen and made me write out that I withdraw my application."