AOS denied medical mistake

[bulapapi 5]

So, I received a denial after submitting an RFE for an expired medical. I didn't know that one of my vaccination (Tdap) was expiring when I submitted it, my civil surgeon never mentioned anything. I had it done back in May 2017 at CVS. But Tdap supposed to last for 10 years, correct? but on the cvs record it says it expires in 2 years. So, I got denied based on that. So devastating. What should I do? Can I file for a motion to reopen since this is such a small, honest mistake?

I don't wanna start all over and wait for 2 years again just like what I did... and going through interview again. I'm so depressed. Please suggest :(

[milimelo 4,494]

Motion to reopen won’t work. You have to start a new AOS. 

[bulapapi 5]

8 hours ago, milimelo said:

Motion to reopen won’t work. You have to start a new AOS. 

Why though?

[Jenny17655 284]

I'm confused, you received an RFE for an expired medical? What did you submit in response to the RFE?

[bulapapi 5]

2 hours ago, Jenny17655 said:

I'm confused, you received an RFE for an expired medical? What did you submit in response to the RFE?

The medical of course 

[Shiran 1,134]

8 hours ago, Jenny17655 said:

I'm confused, you received an RFE for an expired medical? What did you submit in response to the RFE?

It is worded weirdly. The way I am reading he got an RFE because his medical was expiring. He did a different one and submitted it, but civil surgeon didn't notice that Tdap vaccination was too old which lead to denial.

[bulapapi 5]

3 minutes ago, Shiran said:

It is worded weirdly. The way I am reading he got an RFE because his medical was expiring. He did a different one and submitted it, but civil surgeon didn't notice that Tdap vaccination was too old which lead to denial.

The Tdap wasn’t too old. I got the vaccine back in 2017 and the doctor and the pharmacist said Tdap lasts for 10 years. But on the paperwork, next to the date I received my Tdap. There is an expiration date that says “Expires on 05/18/2019” They might have confused it for the Tdap expiration but that was actually the expiration of the vial bottle. 

[bulapapi 5]

On 5/30/2019 at 11:25 PM, milimelo said:

Motion to reopen won’t work. You have to start a new AOS. 

FYI, my denied green card application was reopened and approved after 20 days of them receiving it!