-
Posts
484 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Partners
Immigration Wiki
Guides
Immigration Forms
Times
Gallery
Store
Blogs
Posts posted by Always+Forever
-
-
Did you read this?....
Section 214(d) of the Act states that CIS shall approve the Form I-129F when a petitioner submits
evidence to establish that helshe and the beneficiary have met within the two-year period immediately
the filing of the Form I-129F, have a bonafide intention to marry and are legally able and willing to
marry within 90 days of the beneficiary's arrival in the United States. In denying the instant petition,
the director appears to have imposed an additional requirement on the petitioner - establishing the
genuineness of her relationship to the beneficiary. However, no such requirement exists for the
approval of a Form I-129F, and the AAO finds the director to have erred in imposing it. While section
214(d) of the Act stipulates that the petitioner must establish that she and the beneficiary have a
bonafide intention to marry, this language is not synonymous with a requirement that the petitioner
establish the closeness of their relationship. The AAO has found nothing in the record to indicate the
petitioner and beneficiary do not intend to marry within 90 days of the beneficiary's arrival in the
United States.
In reaching its decision, the AAO notes the concerns expressed by the consular officer and,
subsequently, the director regarding presenting sufficient evidence of a credible relationship between
the petitioner and the beneficiary. However, as noted above, section 2 14(d) of the Act requires only that
the petitioner establish that the petitioner and the beneficiary have previously met in person within two
See Footnote No. 1
years before the date of filing the petition, have a bona fide intention to marry, and are legally able and
actually willing to conclude a valid marriage in the United States within a period of ninety days after the
alien's arrival. As discussed above, the filing date of the instant petition is September 21,2007, and thus
the petitioner and the beneficiary were required to have met between November 21, 2005 and
November 21,2007. The evidence of record reflects that ths meeting requirement has been met. The
record reflects no previous marriages for either the petitioner or the beneficiary, and contains an
affidavit signed by the petitioner and the beneficiary affirming and declaring their intent to marry within
90 days of the beneficiary's arrival to the United States. Accordingly, the reservations expressed by the
consular officer and the director are not probative for the purposes of these proceedings.
The director's denial of the instant petition is based on the petitioner's failure to establish a bonafide
fiancCe relationshp with the beneficiary. As the director erred in imposing such a requirement on the
petitioner, the AAO finds the petitioner to have overcome the basis for the director's denial of the
instant petition. Accordingly, the AAO will sustain the petitioner's appeal and withdraw the director's
denial of the petition.
The burden of proof in these proceedings rests solely with the petitioner. Section 291 of the Act, 8
U.S.C. 1361. The petitioner has sustained that burden.
ORDER: The appeal is sustained. The denial is withdrawn. The petition is approved
So...like we thought...they denied us with no grounds for it...i think the problem is that it usually takes years to even get to that point of finding out anything
Malika
-
-
Another interesting link: USCIS Fraud Referral Sheet
Malika
-
Does this mean we all have a bad marker in our file now? I know there have been a lot of successful re-filers.
Ok...from what i understand (i may be wrong) the bad marker only gets put on the case if it is actually denied through USCIS or your ignore any NOIR/NOID u receive. From what i have read...as long as u reply to anything u receive in regards to the case, then you should be fine...like i said....i may be wrong...i'm hoping some ppl who have been through this recently will be able to shed some light on this.
Malika
-
yeah..i agree...i wonder if there is anything all of us can do if we call got together...hmm imagine all of the K1s & I130s involved in this....its has to be 100s maybe 1000s, and then their families that are also affected.
Malika
-
Was just scanning around & came across this site describing the Tran V Napolitano.....i read through the case just now, and this article seems to give an easy to understand view of what it had to say. Hoping this gets through quickly, cuz from the sounds of it...at this point...my K1 has no chance
Consular returns of K1s Lawsuit Atleast if this passes...in the future we will have a chance to rebuttle BEFORE it leaves the embassy....imagine that
Well hope everybody has a great 4th of July...atleast all the fireworks should help us get our minds off of the waiting for a few moments
Malika
-
u read my mind canadian_wife. You can also check out this group in the MENA forum for ppl filing through Casa: The hoping not to get denied at Casablanca thread Here is the main link for the MENA forum also: Middle East and North Africa There are so great & very knowledgable ppl on there they can help u through just about anything. Inshallah everything will go good for u & your husband.
Malika
-
yeah...something to look forward to would be good....we r in this darn stand still...waiting to see if they will even look at our case or sit on it till it expires...the joys of no control. Keep thinking winning the lottery would be nice....wonder why i haven't won yet...hmm...oh yeah, i don't have a ticket
Hope everybody has a good 4th...i'm trying to avoid the spiral downward & the desire to just hide & avoid everyone & all their questions.
Malika
-
I agree...any waiting is torture....cuz its not like we haven't waited atleast a yr by the interviews. I'm thinking the 3 mths i spent there is making it even worse...atleast with the short trips I didn't get in to a routine, etc. Also doesn't help that there doesn't seem to be any routine in how the cases r handled. Atleast we have eachother to lean on....i don't know about everyone else, but not many around me understand. Keeping the hope though. Inshallah a miracle will happen & CSC will start reviewing returned K1s
maybe if i say pretty please with a cherry on top
Malika
-
i had my interview at american embassy in cairo at 06-03-2010 about my fiance k1 visa , so i wounder why the cairo counselor refuse my fiancee visa and even after they stamp it , also after he told us we got approved at the interview ?
i just need to know what the reason for that after we call the embassy 4 times and they said its already approved , and we waiting for the dhl to send it to my fiancee home , and after that we got the passport had the visa in it but over the visa there was a stamp say cancled without prejudice , what that suppose to mean ?
and also it had a letter said , that the embassy dont convienced about our relationship , and they send our case back to usa , what that mean ?
also the passport had a pink paper said iv , what that mean ???
what they need else after all they see at the interview and i visit him 4 times and had a real relationship , and we answer all the quiz right at the interview .
what i have to do now
im here in egypt , did i have to embassy again to see whats going on , and why that happened , i dont mind really just wanna do any thing to dont loose my love of my life
if the counselor need to cancel it why he dont tell us in the beginning , why he let us happy for 1 mounth , even i was arrange for our trip back to states together and then stap us in the back ?????
any help will be appreciated
I'm so sorry to hear about that happening to you guys....talk about torture. I haven't heard of that happening, but hopefully someone else will know more. Did they give u a refusal worksheet or anything like that?? What exactly did the paper say?
Malika
-
ok everybody....got the spreadsheet working...check it out in my signature...will get together the questionnaire for everyone to add their info....let me know if u have any info u wanna add, etc
Malika
-
To track a returned petition/application with a pouch number, you can contact the Diplomatic Pouch Service in Washington:
•Diplomatic Pouch Service: 202-663-1588
I just called & the guy was really nice
Still hasn't arrived in their system yet though....atleast it gives me someone else to annoy
Looks like so far we have:
(4) 1st petition K1.......(2) Married & CR1, (1) Refile K1, (1) Waiting
(1) 1st Petition CR1....waiting 10 mths (is that right illnevergetthis??)
Still trying to get the spreadsheet working...hopefully soon so we can get better details for everyone
Malika
-
well...i made a spreadsheet & tried the googledocs....won't load the spreadsheet
-
awesome...i haven't gotten to that point yet...so thanks for the help
-
thinking about trying to put together a chart together so we can all keep track of where everyone is...any ideas of what i should include would be get. To Start with:
When you met:
How many & how long visits before filing the 1st petition:
If you started with K1 or CR1:
1st petition interview date:
Date returned to USCIS for review, specify if for AP review or refusal (denial) review
What you have done since (i.e. waiting, refile K1, marry & CR1)
Specify when u refiled K1, or got married & filed CR1 (date for each)
If filed 2nd petition, how long after case returned to USCIS
Specify where u r in the process for 2nd petition
Any other ideas...let me know
Malika
-
that's what i was thinking....we all need to stick together
-
Hello, my Dear All
Today i called to embassy and the guy he told me that we transfer ur case to NVC on June 24 2010 and we also send u ur original documents and passport and also wedding photos he also told me that u can check ur status in NVC...
plz plz plz plz help i m feel really hurting....
need advise...
I'm also on the 221(g) refusal road....here's a link on the MENA forum that has a lot of info Returned Petitions via 221g . Was told by USCIS today that they r supposed to review it within 120 days of leaving the embassy....but who knows how true that is
I also created a thread for fellow MENA ppl going through the same process...hope we can help eachother out: Sent back for review thread Best of Luck.
Malika
-
love the song Aya....I haven't been in the happiest moods so here's mine...i couldn't decide so i put both...lol
Malika
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tZWqqz9G-A
-
ok...just called USCIS & they said that the case should be reviewed in 120 days from date it left embassy...hear from others that is a laugh, but it can't hurt to try
Better than nothin...lol
Malika
-
Thought it might be good to have a place to go to see what everyone is doing....we are still waiting for our case to get back to USCIS. Keep getting told to go get married...told by senator's office that CSC is supposed to review the case if it arrives unexpired. Feels like being pulled in both directions. How is everyone else doing???
Malika
-
Looks like we were 4 for 4 for June
July has 3 listed...all K1s
So bahisgirl, pinkamirah, and khadija & ibrahim...anyone else coming up???
How r all of u July interviews doing??
Hope we can keep the approvals coming!!
Malika
-
12 months...wow...i don't know how u're doing it...we've been apart for only 2 weeks & I'm going crazy. I guess part of it is that we were sent back to USCIS, and we have no clue if CSC will even review it...the idea of another yr in nausiating. I don't know why they love to torture us...but seriously i think some of them enjoy it
hope everyone has a good 4th & they feel in good moods & give some of us "freedom"
Malika
-
CONGRATS SARAH!!!! I'm soooo happy for u guys!!!
Guess all this hoping is getting ppl approved.....woohoo!!! Hope there r more to come.
Malika
-
Congrats msheesha & Vanessa...I'm so happy that we are finally hearing APPROVED out of Casa!!!!
INSHALLAH you will hear it too tomorrow Sarah!!! All our prayers are with you!!!
Malika
The hoping not to be denied at Casablanca thread
in Middle East and North Africa
Posted
I think about all u can do is go in the way u feel comfortable with & go from there. They are going to make up their minds no matter how much or how little evidence u have. I've heard approvals & denials both ways. I think they've made up their minds before they even come in for the interview. And of course they want to test your relationship....if your relationship isn't strong enough to get through all of this...then there is no way u will make through a marriage...atleast in my opinion
Best of luck to those with up coming interviews.
Malika