Jump to content
Guinness

I-751E Notice of action Blue form

10 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Well Received Form I-797E today

You have not established that the marriage upon which you were granted conditional status was entered into in good Faith. You provided some evidence of marital bona fides. however, the documentation submitted is insufficient because of the following reasons.

1) All of the evidence submitted was dated recently and does not cover the entire marriage period with exception of tax returns that are incomplete, Statements such as W-2 were not attached.

I submitted transcripts for all years with both our names on them, but the wife has not worked so has not W-2s

do they want my W-2s or what do i send my entire tax returns ????

we plan to fly home in June for a visit Now worried about leaving country

We have been inseparable since meeting but don't have much with both our names tried to get car loan with both name but bank wont put her name on loan.

have thousands of pictures

what do we send Now pictures and affidavits from friends ??

Edited by Guinness

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They will want to see your W2s to show that you were filing as married....or the W2 shows a status of married. The W2s also show the address where both of you resided but you are saying your wife does not have them. Get all the documents again beginning the time that you got married. Send the tax returns for all the years you have been married. Send more affidavits, more photos, airline tickets if you have them, invitations with both your names...Just send them a whole bunch of evidence and simply overwhelm them.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you sure you sent the IRS transcripts? I ask because you mentioned the RFE says,

1) All of the evidence submitted was dated recently and does not cover the entire marriage period with exception of tax returns that are incomplete, Statements such as W-2 were not attached.

It's my understanding that they ask for W2s only when tax returns are sent. But if you send tax transcripts, that's better and there'd be no need for W2s.

Also, the evidence you send has to cover the duration of your marriage not just recent evidence. I'd suggest looking for any mail addressed to both of you.

Life Insurance, Auto insurance

Benefiary on retirement accounts

Cellphone family plans etc.

Good luck!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you sure you sent the IRS transcripts? I ask because you mentioned the RFE says,

1) All of the evidence submitted was dated recently and does not cover the entire marriage period with exception of tax returns that are incomplete, Statements such as W-2 were not attached.

It's my understanding that they ask for W2s only when tax returns are sent. But if you send tax transcripts, that's better and there'd be no need for W2s.

Also, the evidence you send has to cover the duration of your marriage not just recent evidence. I'd suggest looking for any mail addressed to both of you.

Life Insurance, Auto insurance

Benefiary on retirement accounts

Cellphone family plans etc.

Good luck!

I diffidently sent transcripts. that's what I don't understand thought I was giving more then they asked. also airline tickets home,

but believe they want the Wife's W-2 and we have none. guess I will need to send affidavits from friends and letter explaining the wife didn't work along with my W-2s Pictures

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Did you send tax transcripts pulled from the IRS site? Do they say you filed jointly?


USCIS - 40 DAYS
2012-10-30: FedEx delivered I-130 to Chicago Lockbox Mail Room
2012-11-01: NOA1 by email - MSC
2012-11-02: $420 (x3) debited from our account
2012-11-05: NOA1 hard copies received, Priority Date 2012-10-30
2012-12-11: NOA2


NVC - 26 DAYS
2013-01-02: Rec'd case#, IIN, BIN & OPTIN emails for EP sent
2013-01-03: Submitted DS-261 (x3)
2013-01-07: AOS bills invoiced and paid & OPTIN for EP accepted for each of us
2013-01-08: AOS bills appear as paid & AOS packages sent by email
2013-01-08: IV bill invoiced & paid (kids' only)
2013-01-09: IV bill appears as paid (kids' only)
2013-01-09: IV Package emailed & DS-260 submitted online (kids only)
2013-01-11: AOS received -notified by email
2013-01-11: IV bill invoiced & paid (for me)
2013-01-14: IV bill appears as paid (for me)
2013-01-14: IV Supporting Docs received for kids - notified by email
2013-01-14: IV Package emailed & DS-260 submitted online (me only)
2013-01-18: IV Supporting Docs received for me - notified by email
2013-01-18: Son#1 CASE COMPLETE - Son#2 checklist - saying $ on I-864 don't match tax return (but they do)-resubmitted
2013-01-23: AOS 2nd submission for Son #2 received - notified by email
2013-01-25: My CASE COMPLETE
2013-01-28: ALL 3 OF OUR CASES ARE NOW COMPLETE
2013-02-06: Packet 4 Received by email

MEDICAL ~ CONSULATE ~ POE REMOVAL OF CONDITIONS - 160 DAYS NATURALIZATION
2013-02-13: Medicals 2014-12-17: Delivered to California Lockbox 2015-12-15: Delivered to Phoenix Lockbox
2013-03-06: Interview 2014-12-19: 1 I-751 + 3 Biometrics Fees debited from our account 2015-12-16: Fees charged to Credit Card
2013-03-08: Visas in-hand 2014-12-22: Received NOA1 by mail. Receipt Date: 2014-12-17 2015-12-17: NOA
2013-03-12: Paid USCIS Immigrant Fee 2014-12-24: Received Biometrics Appointment Letter 2016-01-02: Biometrics Letter 2016-01-11: Biometrics
2013-03-14: POE 2015-01-06: Biometrics 2016-02-15: In Line for Interview 2016-02-19: Letter
2013-03-25: SSNs arrived 2015-05-27: Approved 2016-03-22: Interview
2013-04-01: Green Cards arrived 2015-06-03: New Green Cards arrived 2016-04-15: Oath Ceremony

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can someone please confirm that if you send them IRS transcripts that you dont need to include W-2 form's ?

or did they now make it a requirement if you send IRS transcripts that you must include w-2 FORMS


USCIS:
07/07/2012 - I-130 Sent
07/09/2012 - I-130 Received & Accepted
07/12/2012 - NOA1 Received
03/08/2013 - NOA2 Approved
03/13/2013 - NOA2 Received

NVC:
03/18/2013 - Case arrived at NVC
03/29/2013 - Received case #, IIN, gave e-mail addresses
03/29/2013 - E-mailed DS-3032
04/02/2013 - AOS bill invoiced & PAID
04/04/2013 - AOS bill appears as PAID
04/05/2013 - DS-3032 accepted
04/06/2013 - AOS Package sent
04/08/2013 - IV bill invoiced & PAID
04/10/2013 - IV bill appears as PAID
04/10/2013 - IV Package sent
04/22/2013 - AOS/I-864 accepted
04/22/2013 - Case Complete

Embassy:
05/08/2013-Embassy Received

06/05/2013-Medical
06/20/2013-Interview Date
06/20/2013-Interview passed and approved
06/27/2013-Visa at hand
07/13/2013-POE-JFK, NYC

ROC:

04/18/2015 - I-751 Sent
04/20/2015 - Vermont Service Center Received
05/07/2015 - Check Cashed
05/29/2015 - Biometrics Done
02/23/2016-Green Card Ordered for production
03/03/2016-Green Card received at home {Thanks to Jehovah, the Creator}

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Send tax transcripts that you get from the IRS (either request them to be mailed or download and print them). You won't need W2's with transcripts. Also, transcripts are from the IRS which PROVES you filed. They want the proof. Anyone can send in a filled out tax form, doesn't mean it was filed.


XMY93gI.jpgXMY9m5.png

AAD1m5.pngThankYouUSA-Kosova.jpg

See my Timeline for details of our visa journey
17-Aug-2011 Our Wedding Day in Kosovo heart9.gif
07-Nov-2011 Filed I-130
21-Nov-2011 NOA1
23-Aug-2012 NOA2 Approved 276 days
10-Jan-2013 Case complete via email

28-Feb-2013 Interview, result AP
11-Apr-2013 Embassy appointment - VISA APPROVED and issued in 4 hours
30-Apr-2013 POE Chicago O'Hare - He's home!

04-Sep-2014 Moved to northern California

12-Mar-2015 Filed ROC
16-Mar-2015 Documents delivered
18-Mar-2015 Check cashed
19-Mar-2015 NOA1 dated 03/16/2015 received in mail
13-Apr-2015 Biometrics completed
02-Feb-2016 Contacted USCIS about case, was told it's on hold because of security checks (email)
04-Mar-2016 Moved to Wisconsin
12-Aug-2016 New Biometrics appointment
14-Sep-2016 Contacted USCIS again about case (email said we should hear from them by Oct 6)
22-Sep-2016 Letter from USCIS dated 9/20 explaining the Service Request is currently being reviewed by an officer.
22-Sep-2016 Letter from USCIS dated 9/20 with Interview appointment for both of us for 28-Sep-2016
28-Sep-2016 Interview, both of us, separated, not hard, 10 min. each, result---said hubby will get GC in about 10 days
26-Oct-2016 *****STILL WAITING*****
02-Nov-2016 Card is being produced!!!
08-Nov-2016 Card is mailed
10-Nov-2016 Card is Delivered!!!! YAY

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Send tax transcripts that you get from the IRS (either request them to be mailed or download and print them). You won't need W2's with transcripts. Also, transcripts are from the IRS which PROVES you filed. They want the proof. Anyone can send in a filled out tax form, doesn't mean it was filed.

I sent IRS transcripts direct from IRS did not send any W2s thinking Transcripts would be better, But the Wife has NO W2s to file she has not worked in the USA and we have no plans for her to start.

So not really sure what they want> plan to write them a letter this week include my W2s along with affidavits from several friends saying they know us to be happily married. also itinerary of our up coming trip home. but now the wife is worried about getting back into country. Because 2 year card is expired. but we do have letter when if we file say ok to travel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I sent in tax transcripts wih no W-2s. My wife does not work, has a different last name, was not on the mortgage, but we were approved. We sent in evidence of joint bank accounts from the date she was added to the ROC submission covering each quarter. She was added as a joint user on my credit card, so I sent in statements from when she was added to ROC submission. I showed when I aded her as a beneficiary and emergency contract with my employer. I showed she was added to my life insurance policy as beneficiary. I showed she was added to my inherited IRA as beneficiary. I showed her car title with both are names on it. I submitted another certified copy of our Marriage Certificate. We do not have wills or Health Care Power of Attorney or Power of Attorney, yet. I am the only one on all bills. We also sent in evidence--photos and itineraries--of all trips were took together

I would get another set of tax transcripts mailed from the IRS. I would send in all evidence you have from the date of marriage to present. Include your affidavits and trip information of any trips taken together. Write a letter attesting that you are two people trying to combine your lives and got married to accomplish this and not for the purposes of circumventing immigration law--I wrote such a cover letter and outlined the evidence I was including but I feel this was more for my benefit then the USCIS but who knows.

I would go ahead and travel as you have the extension letter which extends the GC for another year--just make certain the airline you are traveling on recognizes the extension letter as some cheaper ones do not. If they do not like the new evidence, you will be called for an interview. Just make certain your travel plans do not interfere with any possible interview.

Dave

P. S. My W-2s showed single claiming 0 deductions until recently due to my tax situation. You do not have to change to married on your W-4. You just have to file your taxes as married. The W-4 dictates how much your employer withholds from you paycheck each payday. I wanted them to withhold the maximum amount so I would not have to pay estimated taxes or not a large amount of estimated taxes.

Edited by Dave&Roza

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I sent IRS transcripts direct from IRS did not send any W2s thinking Transcripts would be better, But the Wife has NO W2s to file she has not worked in the USA and we have no plans for her to start.

So not really sure what they want> plan to write them a letter this week include my W2s along with affidavits from several friends saying they know us to be happily married. also itinerary of our up coming trip home. but now the wife is worried about getting back into country. Because 2 year card is expired. but we do have letter when if we file say ok to travel

I would also request and send another copy of the tax transcript. On the off-chance that some duma$$ sent you a request for the wrong information as in the W2s just send them so satisfy them but also send the transcript with a note that says you are submitting the tax transcripts once again for their records. That's what I would do. Don't call them out for not paying attention to what they're doing but just provide what they're asking for and a little more along with it (even though you already sent the tax transcripts). I mean what if it's a newbie and they are looking at a tax transcript you sent and they're so stuck on the fact that there are no W2s they aren't even realizing they don't need them. I had an RFE where they said the two amounts on my AOS and tax return didn't match. They DID match but rather than trying to argue through it I just resubmitted the forms. I know it is a bit different now, two years later, but it may still be easier to just provide what they're asking for.


USCIS - 40 DAYS
2012-10-30: FedEx delivered I-130 to Chicago Lockbox Mail Room
2012-11-01: NOA1 by email - MSC
2012-11-02: $420 (x3) debited from our account
2012-11-05: NOA1 hard copies received, Priority Date 2012-10-30
2012-12-11: NOA2


NVC - 26 DAYS
2013-01-02: Rec'd case#, IIN, BIN & OPTIN emails for EP sent
2013-01-03: Submitted DS-261 (x3)
2013-01-07: AOS bills invoiced and paid & OPTIN for EP accepted for each of us
2013-01-08: AOS bills appear as paid & AOS packages sent by email
2013-01-08: IV bill invoiced & paid (kids' only)
2013-01-09: IV bill appears as paid (kids' only)
2013-01-09: IV Package emailed & DS-260 submitted online (kids only)
2013-01-11: AOS received -notified by email
2013-01-11: IV bill invoiced & paid (for me)
2013-01-14: IV bill appears as paid (for me)
2013-01-14: IV Supporting Docs received for kids - notified by email
2013-01-14: IV Package emailed & DS-260 submitted online (me only)
2013-01-18: IV Supporting Docs received for me - notified by email
2013-01-18: Son#1 CASE COMPLETE - Son#2 checklist - saying $ on I-864 don't match tax return (but they do)-resubmitted
2013-01-23: AOS 2nd submission for Son #2 received - notified by email
2013-01-25: My CASE COMPLETE
2013-01-28: ALL 3 OF OUR CASES ARE NOW COMPLETE
2013-02-06: Packet 4 Received by email

MEDICAL ~ CONSULATE ~ POE REMOVAL OF CONDITIONS - 160 DAYS NATURALIZATION
2013-02-13: Medicals 2014-12-17: Delivered to California Lockbox 2015-12-15: Delivered to Phoenix Lockbox
2013-03-06: Interview 2014-12-19: 1 I-751 + 3 Biometrics Fees debited from our account 2015-12-16: Fees charged to Credit Card
2013-03-08: Visas in-hand 2014-12-22: Received NOA1 by mail. Receipt Date: 2014-12-17 2015-12-17: NOA
2013-03-12: Paid USCIS Immigrant Fee 2014-12-24: Received Biometrics Appointment Letter 2016-01-02: Biometrics Letter 2016-01-11: Biometrics
2013-03-14: POE 2015-01-06: Biometrics 2016-02-15: In Line for Interview 2016-02-19: Letter
2013-03-25: SSNs arrived 2015-05-27: Approved 2016-03-22: Interview
2013-04-01: Green Cards arrived 2015-06-03: New Green Cards arrived 2016-04-15: Oath Ceremony

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -


Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×