October 2012 Filer-And we Recieved an RFE:-(

[Proud Phinay 0]

I recieved an RFE last April 22, 2013.

Here is what we submitted...Last October 2012...

What else do we need to submit? This all what we got.

We didn't have kids. We haven't bless to have one yet.

PLEASE give me an idea in how to deal with this matter

Im going crazy here

Please find supporting documents are as follows: (Part 1)

• Copies of passport and green card (front and back)
• Copy of Certificate of Marriage
• Copies of joint bank account statement and our visa cards from Wells Fargo Bank
• Copy of title of our vehicle showing joint ownership
• Copy of our 2011 joint US tax return
• Copy of USCIS online change of address dated 7/30/2012 21:19
• Copy of our drivers license showing our new address
• Copy of my wife’s proof of employment SSN, letter from her employer and check stubs showing our new address

Please find supporting documents are as follows:(Part 2)

• Statement from my life insurance company showing my wife as beneficiary
• Three original sworn affidavits by U.S. citizen friends attesting to our relationship and marriage
• Copies of photos of our families and friends in important occasions from year 2012, 2011 and 2010
• Copies of our proof of residence from bills and cards from families and friends in US and Philippines
• Letter from our Church
• Copies of our Disney tickets year 2012 and 2010
• Copies of our tickets from the concert of and sales receipt from the Zoo

Edited May 11, 2013 by Proud Phinay

[Ronn63 41]

It may be something silly, like a signature missing or something. Just wait to see what they want. They usually turn around RFE's pretty quickly.

[Proud Phinay 0]

I got an RFE this April 22, 2013...They said what ever we sent them is not sufficient...I have nothing else to send them anyways.I sent them what we got...

Any advice? Idea in here please!!!

[VJ-Newbie 5]

Dear Proud Phinay,

I am so sorry to read about your RFE. Can you post the precise language of the RFE so that we can get a better sense of what the USCIS is requesting?

Be encouraged! We shall all get through this.

Edited May 12, 2013 by VJ-Newbie

[Proud Phinay 0]

Asking about Children as a result of marriage.

We dont have kids yet no luck yet.

Medical records- we dont have it because we can't afford to have one.

Evidence that you and your spouse resided together-Were staying in our church since my husband is a Pastor of a small church.

The only bills we pay is internet bill. So we dont have lease.

[Proud Phinay 0]

My husband a has a life insurance im the beneficiary.

[bewildering 9]

My husband a has a life insurance im the beneficiary.

Hmmm,

Well, we know the problem. You changed address since the AOS, but the USCIS has very little evidence you are living together. I think this is the main issue.

You have no legal document about your new house? Can the church provide a lease? Perhaps the Bishop/Deacons(professionals) can write a notarized letter detailing your living circumstance?

[Vishnya 4]

I recieved an RFE last April 22, 2013.

Here is what we submitted...Last October 2012...

What else do we need to submit? This all what we got.

We didn't have kids. We haven't bless to have one yet.

PLEASE give me an idea in how to deal with this matter

Im going crazy here

Please find supporting documents are as follows: (Part 1)

• Copies of passport and green card (front and back)
• Copy of Certificate of Marriage
• Copies of joint bank account statement and our visa cards from Wells Fargo Bank
• Copy of title of our vehicle showing joint ownership
• Copy of our 2011 joint US tax return
• Copy of USCIS online change of address dated 7/30/2012 21:19
• Copy of our drivers license showing our new address
• Copy of my wife’s proof of employment SSN, letter from her employer and check stubs showing our new address

Please find supporting documents are as follows:(Part 2)

• Statement from my life insurance company showing my wife as beneficiary
• Three original sworn affidavits by U.S. citizen friends attesting to our relationship and marriage
• Copies of photos of our families and friends in important occasions from year 2012, 2011 and 2010
• Copies of our proof of residence from bills and cards from families and friends in US and Philippines
• Letter from our Church
• Copies of our Disney tickets year 2012 and 2010
• Copies of our tickets from the concert of and sales receipt from the Zoo

Copies of joint bank account statement and our visa cards from Wells Fargo Bank - did you send statements for each month?

Copy of USCIS online change of address dated 7/30/2012 21:19 - ​did you send previous lease agreement? this time sublease letter or so

Any phone bills? Any membership? You have a car, what about insurance? What about tax return for 2010+ you can send 2012 now

Basically from strong documents you have send only bank statements, one year TAX, and title! Good luck, send them as many papers as u have!

[Proud Phinay 0]

I-751 REMOVAL OF CONDITIONS ON RESIDENCE (CRI89)

I recieved an RFE last April 22, 2013

Here is what we submitted...Last October 2012...

Please find supporting documents are as follows: (Part 1)

• Copies of passport and green card (front and back)
• Copy of Certificate of Marriage
• Copies of joint bank account statement and our visa cards from Wells Fargo Bank
• Copy of title of our vehicle showing joint ownership
• Copy of our 2011 joint US tax return
• Copy of USCIS online change of address dated 7/30/2012 21:19
• Copy of our drivers license showing our new address
• Copy of my wife’s proof of employment SSN, letter from her employer and check stubs showing our new address

Please find supporting documents are as follows:(Part 2)

• Statement from my life insurance company showing my wife as beneficiary
• Three original sworn affidavits by U.S. citizen friends attesting to our relationship and marriage
• Copies of photos of our families and friends in important occasions from year 2012, 2011 and 2010
• Copies of our proof of residence from bills and cards from families and friends in US and Philippines
• Letter from our Church
• Copies of our Disney tickets year 2012 and 2010
• Copies of our tickets from the concert of and sales receipt from the Zoo

AND THEY ARE ASKING FOR MORE EVIDENCE LIKE!!!

1. Childrens as a result of Marriage

> Unfortunately we dont have kids yet.

2. Evidence that you and your spouse resided together and share responsibility for a common residence.

>We were only paying Ligth bill,Internet bill no water bill bcoz were using water pump. But when we moved

from 2010 to another place we dont have the receipt since that was 3 years ago. Then my wife's name is not

in the bill.We tried to put her name but the company said they can't bcoz she's not paying the bills and she dont

work yet.

>Then from 2011 from our new home we were paying internet bills & water bill with both our names. But the lease is only in my name.

The only problem is were not able to kept it.Then from the house we moved again for the second time and that where we are staying rigth now

in our church.In our church were only paying our internet bill and its in both our names.Our church help us due to down economy.

3. Evidence of combined financial resources may include financial records showing joint ownership of assets and joint responsibility for liabilities.

>My wife got job last April 2012 we sent her pay stub,letter from the company where she's working and her SSN.

>We sent this as well Copies of joint bank account statement and our visa cards from Wells Fargo Bank.

>Statement from my life insurance company showing my wife as beneficiary.

>Copy of our 2011 joint US tax return

>Our bills is only the Brigth House bill that the internet bill

>We didn't have health insurance bcoz we can't afford it.

4.Affidavits from third parties who have knowledge of the bona fides of our marital relationship.

> Which we sent them already then they us to send them again. I dont understand why.

What are the things that I need to do. All I knew is that we sent them what we have.

Do I need an ATTORNEY or can I ask for the help of our Senator? Which is the best?

I NEED ALL THE ADVICE, IDEA I CAN GET HERE!!!

PLEASE HELP US. THANK YOU IN ADVANCE..

All our papers our dated and signed:-)

[catsy 3]

Hi... Sorry to hear about RFE.. You should try sending copies of club membership cards if u have, copies of credit cards, if u have any loans together like car loan or personal loan u can send the loan agreement.. My husband and i live with my parents for now so we didnt have any lease agreement nor utility bills to send but we had all the other stuff i mentioned above and thankfully was approved recently.. So just try to send as much proof as u can..

[Jon and Krissy 452]

Getting an RFE is a drag. I know it's easy to say, but don't let it get you down. Send whatever else you have, worst case scenario, you'll get an interview and it will of course be granted.

If it makes you feel any better (hopefully not worse!) I think the RFEs are often random and luck of the draw. You sent more complete evidence than we did, but we got no RFE. TANJ (There Ain't No Justice).

Best,

Jon

[bigdog 376]

Add 3/4 Notorized statements from USC's bout your marriage and relationship. Your evidence seems light, ours was over 100 pages.

[PaulAbby 4]

Sorry to hear about the RFE, Here are a couple of my thoughts on how you should respond.

1. Write cover letter that also shows a time line on your married life together especially indicating when and why you have moved. They may have gotten confused with the different addresses that you have had. Make sure this is easy to see like a bulleted list as i am not sure how much they may actually read on the cover letter.

2. Provide copies of your 2012 income tax

3. Provide Letter from Deacons/Elders on living arrangement in Church. (This should look like an official free lease agreement between the church and the two of you)

4. Additional photos since Oct of vacation, social events, etc.

5. Continued bank account information from Oct to now.

6. Any additional information that you can come up with.

Hang in there as i know this is discouraging........