nabeel24

Hey everyone! Hope everyone is having a great day!
 
So this is an update to my post I made a few days ago regarding denial of my N400. I'll post details below and will ask anyone who can help or give me advice to please to do so as I'm in a very sticky situation now. 
 
N400 Denial Letter:
- USCIS said I was denied because I had initially received my Green Card as an "Unmarried child of a skilled worker in immigrant classification E30."
- I received my Green Card on 03/2013.... I got married in 01/2013.. I obviously did not know this would cause ANY issue at all but here we are. 
- The USCIS letter states: "Based of the foregoing, you were no longer a child, and USCIS erred when it approved your I-485 application on March 12, 2013. " (Essentially states I received my Green Card Unlawfully...)
 
I already set up an infopass appointment 2 weeks out. The letter does not say my Green Card is being rescinded nor do I know if it will be or what in general is going to happen. I called the USCIS line and the person was surprised at the denial and also that they're noticing it 5 years later and denying me for it. 
 
I am extremely worried at what will happen now... I have a feeling USCIS won't fix this and on top of that what my Green Card status will be along with how I'll get a Citizenship in the near future. I just don't understand how or what they will do and it has been FIVE years! Not sure if they'll take away my GC and tell me to apply again with my USC wife or what it will be. My current job depends on the fact that I have a Green Card as it is a govt. job. 
 
If anyone has any advice at all... or faced any situation similar to this, please provide any advice. Thank you for the help!

I think you are very quick to blame...wow. On the letter itself, there are a couple of instances where they wrote there was an error. I quoted one line on the first post. I understand this was not fully their error, it's on both sides. When my dad did the 485 through a lawyer I doubt they mentioned to him about the married part since most people don't get married that early. Nonetheless, it happened, it's an error. Although, the paper says the "USCIS erred", I'd say it's an error on both sides and would like to resolve it. 

I think you are very quick to blame...wow. On the letter itself, there are a couple of instances where they wrote there was an error. I quoted one line on the first post. I understand this was not fully their error, it's on both sides. When my dad did the 485 through a lawyer I doubt they mentioned to him about the married part since most people don't get married that early. Nonetheless, it happened, it's an error. Although, the paper says the "USCIS erred", I'd say it's an error on both sides and would like to resolve it. 

I think you are very quick to blame...wow. On the letter itself, there are a couple of instances where they wrote there was an error. I quoted one line on the first post. I understand this was not fully their error, it's on both sides. When my dad did the 485 through a lawyer I doubt they mentioned to him about the married part since most people don't get married that early. Nonetheless, it happened, it's an error. Although, the paper says the "USCIS erred", I'd say it's an error on both sides and would like to resolve it. 

I have researched this a ton and have asked this question to an USCIS officer so I know this isn't the case. You do not have to receive the green card through marriage. Regardless, I'll post a link below with an explanation which has an example as well just for clarification. Might help or might not. 
 
https://citizenpath.com/applying-for-citizenship-through-marriage/
 
Quote from article:
Example 2
"Kyle obtained a green card through employment; he has been a permanent resident since 7/1/2009. After obtaining his permanent residence, he met Michelle, a U.S. citizen, and they got married on 7/1/2010. If Kyle and Michelle remain married, he will meet the continuous residence requirement for naturalization on 7/2/2013. (At this point he will have been a permanent resident for four years, but married to a U.S. citizen for only three years.) If the marriage falls apart before 7/2/2013, Kyle can still apply for citizenship after five years, 7/2/2014."