I751 waiver RFE

[Yodaa 1]

Hello everyone, I responded with my attorney to an RFE that uscis send me 2 month ago, on our RFE responds I’ve provide as much that I could have, pictures, both ID showing same address, my personal bank account statement that shows that I lived with her, gift that I bought, and affidavit from friends and family. 
 

My ex wife is not cooperative so I had to filed myself. Now that said I’m still wondering couple of things. 
 

In my response to that RFE my attorney didn’t provide text messages inside, and I’am wondering why in that case, I’ve asked her by email and didn’t get an answer yet.
 

Also I don’t have a ton of big evidence to show, instead than picture, ID, and transaction. She was the primary holder of our joint bank account so I cannot get any statement from the bank, and we lived to her parents house so no bills to show, we filed taxes separately as she wanted to claim our child to get more money from IRS.

 

How likely USCIS can denied the case at that point? Is any of you know the process and how they working those kind of cases?
 

Thank you!!
 

 

[Ecaen87 43]

5 hours ago, Yodaa said:

Hello everyone, I responded with my attorney to an RFE that uscis send me 2 month ago, on our RFE responds I’ve provide as much that I could have, pictures, both ID showing same address, my personal bank account statement that shows that I lived with her, gift that I bought, and affidavit from friends and family. 
 

My ex wife is not cooperative so I had to filed myself. Now that said I’m still wondering couple of things. 
 

In my response to that RFE my attorney didn’t provide text messages inside, and I’am wondering why in that case, I’ve asked her by email and didn’t get an answer yet.
 

Also I don’t have a ton of big evidence to show, instead than picture, ID, and transaction. She was the primary holder of our joint bank account so I cannot get any statement from the bank, and we lived to her parents house so no bills to show, we filed taxes separately as she wanted to claim our child to get more money from IRS.

 

How likely USCIS can denied the case at that point? Is any of you know the process and how they working those kind of cases?
 

Thank you!!
 

 

You mentioned that she claimed your child, did you include your child birth certificate? It shows both parent names.

How about car insurance, or any other bill together, costco o sams club membership, gym membership. Trips together, boarding passes, hotel reservations. You have to show them that you had combined finances and responsibilities.

 

It is difficult to guess what their decision would be. Sometimes with much less evidence they approve it and other times with tons of evidences they keep asking for more. It all depends on the IO reviewing your case.

Edited April 25, 2021 by Ecaen87

[Yodaa 1]

On 4/25/2021 at 2:44 AM, Ecaen87 said:

You mentioned that she claimed your child, did you include your child birth certificate? It shows both parent names.

How about car insurance, or any other bill together, costco o sams club membership, gym membership. Trips together, boarding passes, hotel reservations. You have to show them that you had combined finances and responsibilities.

 

It is difficult to guess what their decision would be. Sometimes with much less evidence they approve it and other times with tons of evidences they keep asking for more. It all depends on the IO reviewing your case.

I don’t have any of that basically I had to move for work as we were in a village like, this was for money purposes. She had a Chex system issue so impossible to have her in a bank account. After all she clear everything we had a 360 bank account but capital one won’t share any statement with me as I was the secondary holder. Basically I have couple receipt that I shown, then pictures my own bank account statement to shown that we were living together, our child birth certificate, affidavit, for trips I have pictures of it, and flight ticket when I was going back and forth to visit her and my son, Amazon orders etc. Both ID’s shown same last name and address until that I moved out for work. 
 

On the RFE they asked commun assets which I couldn’t give as we were living at her parents house, so no bills she didn’t like going work out so I was the one to hold a gym membership. 

[Lemonslice 4,887]

How often would you see each other?  Any documents showing that?

Edited April 26, 2021 by Lemonslice

[Yodaa 1]

8 hours ago, Lemonslice said:

How often would you see each other?  Any documents showing that?

I do actually until the brake up I moved for work in august 2017 then I visit them twice, and spend Xmas over there. Then in January she wanted to get divorce, ( to many issues ). So from there, not much, she tried to get back to me few month later I accepted until that I found that she cheated on me a month later. Childish relationship. But I kept traveling and boarding pass from time that I have traveled over there. 
 

My second thought tho is that it depends a lot of the officer that reviewing the case as every cases is unique. So at that point seat tight but I still wanna dig more to find more document. I remembered about the baby registry, so it might be a good start to make more documentation.