I-751 Problem

[manishaatmo 0]

Hi

i am from India currently living is america.i got married in 2008 with my husband who is a us citizen but he is also indian. we met in india 2005 and madly fall in love. from there we dated until i arrived in america and was married. in february, we filed an I-751 to remove the conditions on my green card. however the uscis had sent and RFE asking for more evidence of our marriage the sad part is shortly after we filed the I-751 jointly we our lives took us different ways due to careers and such. during the filing we were having problems with our relationship but were trying to reconcile and work our problems out. But as of now we are no longer living together but remain very close ties. I do not want to go back to India at all we have strong evidence that our marriage was in good faith up until the split and we are still legally married however they want more evidence submitted soon. much of which we have but we dont have together a lease that is current or children together. we would like the best advice on how to move forward with this ...we are leaning on telling the usics what is really going on would this be a good approach? i would love to get a lawyer but we dont have so much money to spend and would be putting myself at risk with money if i had to go back with less. also we have people who can submit affidavits for us during the time we spent together and such we only have two and half weeks to reply to the RFE any help of similar expericenes would be greatly helpfu lthank you

[rahulv 4]

I am sorry that things are not working out between you and your husband after around 6 years together. But the bottom line is you need your ROC and you of course did enter the marriage in good faith, that's all you have to prove.

What more evidence does the RFE requires?

Also it would help if you could attach the list of what you already sent?

[mvc 0]

Sorry to hear that too but we are on the same situation.. Lately my husband and I are not getting along with each other too and we filed the ROC jointly.. and I have a scheduled biometrics on Aug 5..

You are lucky because your husband is still cooperating but for me he is threatening me telling that the immigration officer was there looking for me and he told them I am with boyfriend which is I am working that day.. But according to other vj members here I cannot file a self petition unless we are divorce.

Need more advises from you guys because things are really going rough..Thanks

[deus360 9]

why is the USCIS issuing so my RFE to so many people? The proportion of RFE has gone up abruptly this last 4 month, don't know why.

manishaatmo, just try sending tax transcripts, that's probably the most import piece of evidence you can send to the USCIS

Edited July 30, 2011 by deus360

[nycfeng 2]

What evidences have you already sent?

[Brother Hesekiel 2,236]

There are two ways to file:

1) jointly, if your marriage is going well and you two are living together in harmony

2) singularly, if you are divorced.

The way I understand it, you are not happily married anymore and do not live together, so you can't file jointly or, at least you can't continue letting the joint petition run its course.

You are also not divorced.

You are in a twilight zone that does not exist in the world of the USCIS. You will either get together with your husband quickly, or your will need to get a divorce, equally quickly.

[manishaatmo 0]

We were planning to tell them everything honestly about our break up and trying to reconcile . We are going to send more evidence proving our marriage was entered in good faith. many of which are many and many emails and messages we sent back and forth over the years even before we wed. We were very much in love and feel we can prove our marriage was real. We sent with the 1

st I175 a partial W2 form also partial bank statment with both our names photos. partial copy of tax return transcript,partial copy of appartment lease,a copy of our health insurance,cable bill(does not have his name on it) phone bill,etc

thank you so much guys for sharing your thoughts and experience with me

i am also very sorry to hear about you. why your husband is being so mean to you? whats your stautus here now?