Jump to content
Kevin-n-Merlaine

Dual Citizenship

 Share

15 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

I've searched here several times in the past, and just did again. I can't seem to find much information though. Who here has done it and what's involved? Does she have to be naturalized here in the US first then re-apply for Phil citizenship? It's still down the road a ways I know, but if there was anything she could do now while she's still in Manila, to save some time or effort, that would be great :) BTW, I like the new layout here but I HATE how the topics come up when you search :bonk::bonk::angry:

-USCIS-

COMPLETED - March 9th, 2010

-NVC-

CASE COMPLETE - April 2nd, 2010

-INTERVIEW-

APPROVED - May 18th, 2010

POE - Detroit, June 11th, 2010

GREEN CARD - July 21st, 2010

SS CARD - August 13th, 2010

-ROC-

I-751 Sent March 23rd, 2012

NOA1 March 26th, 2012

Biometrics Appt. April 27th, 2012

Bio done early - April 18th, 2012

ROC Approved - September 12, 2012

10 Year GC - September 17, 2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've searched here several times in the past, and just did again. I can't seem to find much information though. Who here has done it and what's involved? Does she have to be naturalized here in the US first then re-apply for Phil citizenship? It's still down the road a ways I know, but if there was anything she could do now while she's still in Manila, to save some time or effort, that would be great :) BTW, I like the new layout here but I HATE how the topics come up when you search :bonk::bonk::angry:

We haven't done this yet, but I think I have a general idea what is involved.

First, she will become a naturalized U.S. citizen. When one becomes a U.S. citizen, they renounce any other citizenship they previously had. Thereby, losing Philippine citizenship.

However, according to Philippine law, a former Filipino CAN re-acquire Philippine citizenship. Therefore, she can then apply for re-acquisition of her Philippine citizenship. She would then have dual citizenship.

You can verify this information with the Philippine Consulate General - Chicago. This office has jurisdiction over Kansas. Hope that helps some!

NATURALIZATION
02/15/13 - Mailed N-400
02/19/13 - Received by Phoenix Lockbox (day 01)
02/21/13 - NOA1 issued (day 03)


REMOVAL OF CONDITIONS (WIFE)
02/18/12 - Eligible for Removal of Conditions on Residence
03/23/12 - Mailed I-751 to CSC
03/26/12 - Received by CSC (day 01)
03/31/12 - Received NOA1 (day 06)
05/02/12 - Biometrics done (day 38)
10/23/12 - Received approval email (day 212)
11/01/12 - Received green card (day 221)


IR-2 (STEPDAUGHTER)
06/01/10 - Mailed I-130 petition
06/03/10 - Package delivered to USCIS (day 01)
06/08/10 - NOA1 issued (day 06)
11/03/10 - Received approval email (day 154)
11/08/10 - Received approval notice in mail (day 159)


NATIONAL VISA CENTER (STEPDAUGHTER)
11/08/10 - NVC received case from USCIS
11/09/10 - NVC case # & IIN generated, email addresses given, DS-3032 sent via email & USPS (day 01)
11/16/10 - Received and paid AOS bill (day 08)
11/17/10 - AOS bill marked as PAID; AOS packet express mailed (day 09)
11/19/10 - Received and paid IV bill; DS-3032 accepted (day 11)
11/22/10 - IV bill marked as PAID; IV packet express mailed (day 14)
12/03/10 - Sign-in failed (day 25)
12/09/10 - INTERVIEW SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 10, 2011 @ 6:45AM
12/28/10 - Medical exam done at SLEC Manila - PASSED! (day 40)
01/10/11 - Interview at USEM Manila - APPROVED! (day 53)
01/21/11 - Stepdaughter received passport with IR-2 visa! (day 64)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Big thanks Markie!! :thumbs:

-USCIS-

COMPLETED - March 9th, 2010

-NVC-

CASE COMPLETE - April 2nd, 2010

-INTERVIEW-

APPROVED - May 18th, 2010

POE - Detroit, June 11th, 2010

GREEN CARD - July 21st, 2010

SS CARD - August 13th, 2010

-ROC-

I-751 Sent March 23rd, 2012

NOA1 March 26th, 2012

Biometrics Appt. April 27th, 2012

Bio done early - April 18th, 2012

ROC Approved - September 12, 2012

10 Year GC - September 17, 2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Ukraine
Timeline

I've searched here several times in the past, and just did again. I can't seem to find much information though. Who here has done it and what's involved? Does she have to be naturalized here in the US first then re-apply for Phil citizenship? It's still down the road a ways I know, but if there was anything she could do now while she's still in Manila, to save some time or effort, that would be great :) BTW, I like the new layout here but I HATE how the topics come up when you search :bonk::bonk::angry:

The US's formal position is that you are a US citizen (or not) and nothing else. If a Phillipine ccitizen becomes a US citizen, then as far as the US is concerned they are a US citizen. Period. There is no US law or regulation preventing anyone from being alsdo a citizen of another country. You do NOT give up your prior citizenship to become a US citizen and the US does not notify anyone in the Phillipines (or anywhere) that she has become a US citizen. Some other countries do not allow dual citizehship.

There is nothing for you to "check" on in the US. Just become a citizen and that is all. Regardless of the Phillipines position, she will always have a Phillipine birth certificate and can renew her passport over and over again IF she goes to the Phillipines to do so.

VERMONT! I Reject Your Reality...and Substitute My Own!

Gary And Alla

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Even though your wife has a long way to be a citizen of the US. She has to go communicate with the Philippine Embassy here in the US and process it. My aunt is a dual citizen but I am not so sure how she started it. I may have to ask her.

F2A

Petitioner (My Mom)

Beneficiary (My Sister 18 y.o)

06-07-19- Sent I-130

06-11-19- NOA1

02-19-20- "Initial Review, Transferred to another Visa Center"

03-11-20- APPROVED!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The US's formal position is that you are a US citizen (or not) and nothing else. If a Phillipine ccitizen becomes a US citizen, then as far as the US is concerned they are a US citizen. Period. There is no US law or regulation preventing anyone from being alsdo a citizen of another country. You do NOT give up your prior citizenship to become a US citizen and the US does not notify anyone in the Phillipines (or anywhere) that she has become a US citizen. Some other countries do not allow dual citizehship.

There is nothing for you to "check" on in the US. Just become a citizen and that is all. Regardless of the Phillipines position, she will always have a Phillipine birth certificate and can renew her passport over and over again IF she goes to the Phillipines to do so.

This makes more sense to me G&A, but if it's not necessary then why are there provisions for it and why did the Philippines pass the Citizenship Retention and Re-Acquisition Act of 2003? The way you explain it makes more sense to me as well but we know using government and sense in the same sentence is an oxymoron ;) We plan to own a home and retire/semi-retire there one day so it's very important that we're documented properly :thumbs:

-USCIS-

COMPLETED - March 9th, 2010

-NVC-

CASE COMPLETE - April 2nd, 2010

-INTERVIEW-

APPROVED - May 18th, 2010

POE - Detroit, June 11th, 2010

GREEN CARD - July 21st, 2010

SS CARD - August 13th, 2010

-ROC-

I-751 Sent March 23rd, 2012

NOA1 March 26th, 2012

Biometrics Appt. April 27th, 2012

Bio done early - April 18th, 2012

ROC Approved - September 12, 2012

10 Year GC - September 17, 2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Country:
Timeline

This makes more sense to me G&A, but if it's not necessary then why are there provisions for it and why did the Philippines pass the Citizenship Retention and Re-Acquisition Act of 2003? The way you explain it makes more sense to me as well but we know using government and sense in the same sentence is an oxymoron ;) We plan to own a home and retire/semi-retire there one day so it's very important that we're documented properly :thumbs:

While I agree that it doesn't make much sense we still plan for Anna (and Gabby) to do the paperwork as we don't know for sure where we'll be in 20 years and I'd hate for us to have to deal with some limitation because a paper-pusher discovered that she is a US Citizen who never filed to retain her Ph Citizenship.

BTW, apparently Germany has a strict process which involves requesting retention prior to naturalization so this isn't unique to the Philippines.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was my concern Bob/Anna. I wanted to make sure that..if it's lost, she can get it back. It's stupid to "lose" it in the first place. It should be as easy as signing a form during the immigration process...wait, that's crazy talk..sorry :bonk:. Like you, I have no idea where we'll be that many years down the road. She may decide she really likes lower humidity and 4 seasons, who knows. I know we'll want to own land or a home there though and it's tricky enough to buy a legal, deeded piece of property there and KEEP it. I want to make sure we don't inadvertently throw a monkey wrench in an already shaky machine.

-USCIS-

COMPLETED - March 9th, 2010

-NVC-

CASE COMPLETE - April 2nd, 2010

-INTERVIEW-

APPROVED - May 18th, 2010

POE - Detroit, June 11th, 2010

GREEN CARD - July 21st, 2010

SS CARD - August 13th, 2010

-ROC-

I-751 Sent March 23rd, 2012

NOA1 March 26th, 2012

Biometrics Appt. April 27th, 2012

Bio done early - April 18th, 2012

ROC Approved - September 12, 2012

10 Year GC - September 17, 2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was my concern Bob/Anna. I wanted to make sure that..if it's lost, she can get it back. It's stupid to "lose" it in the first place. It should be as easy as signing a form during the immigration process...wait, that's crazy talk..sorry :bonk:. Like you, I have no idea where we'll be that many years down the road. She may decide she really likes lower humidity and 4 seasons, who knows. I know we'll want to own land or a home there though and it's tricky enough to buy a legal, deeded piece of property there and KEEP it. I want to make sure we don't inadvertently throw a monkey wrench in an already shaky machine.

Yeah, I'm not sure why one loses citizenship, either. But you are right, the Philippines would not have a Re-acquisition Act if otherwise.

It's a very good idea to secure dual citizenship for the future. Like you and Bob, my wife will also apply for dual citizenship in a few years. We, too, are planning to retire in the Philippines...one day. We want the option of buying real estate without any restrictions. And one of the requirements is, Filipino citizenship. So, we want to make 100% sure there are no potential snags down the line.

NATURALIZATION
02/15/13 - Mailed N-400
02/19/13 - Received by Phoenix Lockbox (day 01)
02/21/13 - NOA1 issued (day 03)


REMOVAL OF CONDITIONS (WIFE)
02/18/12 - Eligible for Removal of Conditions on Residence
03/23/12 - Mailed I-751 to CSC
03/26/12 - Received by CSC (day 01)
03/31/12 - Received NOA1 (day 06)
05/02/12 - Biometrics done (day 38)
10/23/12 - Received approval email (day 212)
11/01/12 - Received green card (day 221)


IR-2 (STEPDAUGHTER)
06/01/10 - Mailed I-130 petition
06/03/10 - Package delivered to USCIS (day 01)
06/08/10 - NOA1 issued (day 06)
11/03/10 - Received approval email (day 154)
11/08/10 - Received approval notice in mail (day 159)


NATIONAL VISA CENTER (STEPDAUGHTER)
11/08/10 - NVC received case from USCIS
11/09/10 - NVC case # & IIN generated, email addresses given, DS-3032 sent via email & USPS (day 01)
11/16/10 - Received and paid AOS bill (day 08)
11/17/10 - AOS bill marked as PAID; AOS packet express mailed (day 09)
11/19/10 - Received and paid IV bill; DS-3032 accepted (day 11)
11/22/10 - IV bill marked as PAID; IV packet express mailed (day 14)
12/03/10 - Sign-in failed (day 25)
12/09/10 - INTERVIEW SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 10, 2011 @ 6:45AM
12/28/10 - Medical exam done at SLEC Manila - PASSED! (day 40)
01/10/11 - Interview at USEM Manila - APPROVED! (day 53)
01/21/11 - Stepdaughter received passport with IR-2 visa! (day 64)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The US's formal position is that you are a US citizen (or not) and nothing else. If a Phillipine ccitizen becomes a US citizen, then as far as the US is concerned they are a US citizen. Period. There is no US law or regulation preventing anyone from being alsdo a citizen of another country. You do NOT give up your prior citizenship to become a US citizen and the US does not notify anyone in the Phillipines (or anywhere) that she has become a US citizen. Some other countries do not allow dual citizehship.

There is nothing for you to "check" on in the US. Just become a citizen and that is all. Regardless of the Phillipines position, she will always have a Phillipine birth certificate and can renew her passport over and over again IF she goes to the Phillipines to do so.

do you have to surrender your passport when one gets naturalized?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Philippines
Timeline

do you have to surrender your passport when one gets naturalized?

No, but you cannot renew it until you do the oath ceremony to re-acquire your philippine citizinship. It's a simple ceremony that can be done at the Philippines embassies here in the U.S. or on a return trip to the Philippines. From what I've read here and online doing my own research it is a requirement to re-obtain your Philippines citizinship once you have naturalized to the U.S. It's something to do with the wording of the oath when becoming a U.S. citizen, I can't remember the specifics.

While there is no specific law in the U.S. barring dual citizenship, one can be found to have renounced their citizenship if they become a citizen of a foreign country after being a citizen of the U.S. This rarely happens, but has in the (fairly distant) past. Therefore, it is also possible for the original U.S. spouse to become a dual citizen of the U.S. and Philippines as well. I plan to do that as well as have Vicky being a dual citizen, I plan to also do the same later in life.

K1:

Began chatting online 1-2-09, Met in Philippines 9-5 to 9-15-09, Mailed I-129F 9-17-09, I-129F delivered by USPS 9-21-09, Check cashed 9-21-09, NOA1 issued 9-21-09, NOA1 paper copy received 9-28-09, NOA2 issued 12-18-09, NVC received date 12-24-09, NOA2 paper copy received 12-28-09, NVC sent date 12-29-09, Embassy received date 01-05-10, Medical 01-07-10 & 01-11-10 approved/ passed, Interview date 01-14-10 APPROVED! MY HONEY'S COMING!, Visa delivered 1-27-10 Manila time, Arrival in U.S. 2-4-10 POE Minneapolis/ St. Paul

Married! 2-14-10 in Las Vegas

AOS:

Applied for SSN 2-17-10 Received SSN and Cert. Marriage Cert. 3-2-10

Mailed AOS packet 3-3-10

AOS paperwork confirmed delivered 3-4-10

Email/ text notification of NOA1s 3-12-10

*touch* 3-15-10 AOS & EAD

Paper copy NOA1s received 3-16-10

*touch* 3-17-10 AOS & EAD

Received biometrics appointment letter 3-20-10, appointment set for 4-12-10

Case transferred to CSC 3-31-10!! Yay!!

Received email notice 4-6-10 I-485 received at CSC

Biometrics done 4-12-10, Milwaukee, WI ASC

Vicky got her driving permit, 4-12-10

*touch* 4-13-10 AOS & EAD

*touch* 4-21-10 AOS only

*touch* 4-22-10 AOS only

EAD card production ordered 5-14-10.

*touch* 5-17-10 EAD only

EAD card production ordered 5-19-10 (again?)

Received "Welcome to USA" letter 5-25-10, permanent resident application approved!

EAD card received 5-29-10

Greencard received 6-11-10

Positive pregnancy test 6-12-10

Link to comment
Share on other sites

do you have to surrender your passport when one gets naturalized?

When my husband was naturalize, he didn't surrender his Philippine passport. He was planning to apply for a dual citizenship too in the future. I think one is required to surrender his Philippine passport once he renounced it forever ( his brother did when he applied in the army).

AOS Journey from K-1

14 April 2010 - Sent I-485,I-765 (Did not apply for AP)

18 April 2010 - Delivered (Sunday)

26 April 2010 - Checks cashed

27 April 2010 - Touched (both forms)

28 April 2010 - Touched (both forms)

29 April 2010 - Touched (both forms)

03 May 2010 - NOAs received (postmarked April 26, 2010 dated April 23, 2010)

05 May 2010 - Biometrics Appointment letter (postmarked April 29, 2010)

07 May 2010 - Biometrics Walk in Done

07 May 2010 - Touch Both EAD and AOS

10 May 2010 - Touch Both EAD and AOS

17 May 2010 - Received New passport under married name

19 May 2010 - Original Biometric Appointment both EAD and AOS

28 June 2010 - EAD approved by email

01 July 2010 - Touch for EAD and another card production email

02 July 2010 - Touch EAD

06 July 2010 - Infopass Schedule

06 July 2010 - Received Interview appointment dated June 29, 2010

09 July 2010 - Touch on EAD dot changed to Post Decision

12 July 2010 - Touch on EAD

13 July 2010 - EAD card received in mail

04 August 2010 - Interview of I-485 (approved)

06 August 2010- Email Card Production for I-485

11 August 2010- Another Email for Card/ Document Production for I-485

12 August 2010- Post Decision Activity Notice has been sent based on email

01 September 2010 - GC received via PO BOX.

Removal of Condition

22 May 2012 - Sent ROC application

29 May 2012 - Confirmed delivered by USPS

11 Jun 2012- Check has been cashed

13 Jun 2012 - Extension letter received dated May 29, 2012 postmarked 6/8/2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No, but you cannot renew it until you do the oath ceremony to re-acquire your philippine citizinship. It's a simple ceremony that can be done at the Philippines embassies here in the U.S. or on a return trip to the Philippines. From what I've read here and online doing my own research it is a requirement to re-obtain your Philippines citizinship once you have naturalized to the U.S. It's something to do with the wording of the oath when becoming a U.S. citizen, I can't remember the specifics.

So this is the Allegiance, and the bold the part that renounce all other allegiance..

I hereby declare, on oath, that I absolutely and entirely renounce and abjure all allegiance and fidelity to any foreign prince, potentate, state, or sovereignty of whom or which I have heretofore been a subject or citizen; that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I will bear arms on behalf of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform noncombatant service in the Armed Forces of the United States when required by the law; that I will perform work of national importance under civilian direction when required by the law; and that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; so help me God.[1]

While there is no specific law in the U.S. barring dual citizenship, one can be found to have renounced their citizenship if they become a citizen of a foreign country after being a citizen of the U.S. This rarely happens, but has in the (fairly distant) past. Therefore, it is also possible for the original U.S. spouse to become a dual citizen of the U.S. and Philippines as well. I plan to do that as well as have Vicky being a dual citizen, I plan to also do the same later in life.

And this is the oath to regain your Phils citizenship back, without, renouncing your US citizenship.

"I,________________, solemnly swear that I will support and defend the Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines and obey the laws and local orders promulgated by the duly constituted authorities of the Philippines, and I hereby declare that I recognise and accept the supreme authority of the Philippines and will maintain true faith and allegiance thereto, and that I impose this obligation upon myself voluntarily without mental reservation or purpose of evasion."

I'm also looking to get my dual-citizenship status as well...

"No saan nga makaammo nga nangtaliaw ti naggapuanna, Saan a makadanon ti papananna..."


*04/23/10 - GC recieved in the mail!! d( -_-)b
*07/30/12 - ROC Approved!!
*08/08/12 - 10/yr GC received in the mail!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Timeline

I was born in the Philippines and moved to Chicago at the age of 1. I acquired US citizenship through my parents at the age of 7. I was born in the Philippines and therefore was a natural citizen of the Philippines. In 2008 I planned on being in the Philippines to do a little work for my Father and would have to be there for a year or more.. I decided it would be a good idea to get my dual citizenship. I filled out the paper work and walked it to the embassy and paid my fee. They have a schedule for taking the oath and ceremony. I think they do it once a month. I basically just picked the day I wanted to take my oath and I showed up and filled out more paper work and had my dual citizenship that day. They mailed me the official forms a couple months later. The process in 2008 wasn't that hard.. It only took me 2 or 3 weeks and the fee was minimal.. I still havent gotten a passport though, but I do have the official documents.

On a side note, my friend also did the same thing, and they actually had a separate ceremony for him because he could wait the 3 weeks for the scheduled oath days. In other words, they are pretty accommodating... At least in my experience that is..

I hope this helps...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was born in the Philippines and moved to Chicago at the age of 1. I acquired US citizenship through my parents at the age of 7. I was born in the Philippines and therefore was a natural citizen of the Philippines. In 2008 I planned on being in the Philippines to do a little work for my Father and would have to be there for a year or more.. I decided it would be a good idea to get my dual citizenship. I filled out the paper work and walked it to the embassy and paid my fee. They have a schedule for taking the oath and ceremony. I think they do it once a month. I basically just picked the day I wanted to take my oath and I showed up and filled out more paper work and had my dual citizenship that day. They mailed me the official forms a couple months later. The process in 2008 wasn't that hard.. It only took me 2 or 3 weeks and the fee was minimal.. I still havent gotten a passport though, but I do have the official documents.

On a side note, my friend also did the same thing, and they actually had a separate ceremony for him because he could wait the 3 weeks for the scheduled oath days. In other words, they are pretty accommodating... At least in my experience that is..

I hope this helps...

Thanks! It sounds like a pretty easy process once the "not so easy" process is done here in the US.

-USCIS-

COMPLETED - March 9th, 2010

-NVC-

CASE COMPLETE - April 2nd, 2010

-INTERVIEW-

APPROVED - May 18th, 2010

POE - Detroit, June 11th, 2010

GREEN CARD - July 21st, 2010

SS CARD - August 13th, 2010

-ROC-

I-751 Sent March 23rd, 2012

NOA1 March 26th, 2012

Biometrics Appt. April 27th, 2012

Bio done early - April 18th, 2012

ROC Approved - September 12, 2012

10 Year GC - September 17, 2012

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...