Jump to content
paul.

I-864 question 21 problem

 Share

5 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Hi guys, I tagged on to the end of another thread a few days ago and am afraid no one saw it, so I'm making a thread in the right forum, I hope!

old thread

Issue:

My wife, the petitioner, moved back in with her parents to save cash while we go through this process. Her mother is going to be a joint sponsor and so we are filling an I-864 for the petitioner and an I-864A for the joint sponsor as we all live under the same roof. We also have our Grandmother-in-law living in the same house, so with me, the immigrant, included, the total household size is 5.

So I am putting the following, please can anyone confirm that I am correct.

21a. 01 - immigrant

21b. 01 - petitioner

21c. 00 - although married, I assume 0 is correct.

21d. 00 - no kids, no siblings under 21.

21e. 02 - Father-in-law and Grandmother-in-law.

21f. 00

21g. 01 - Mother-in-law is co-sponsor

21h. 05 - total household size

A further question is that because the father-in-law and grandmother-in-law has enough income to sustain themselves, they don't consider themselves "dependant" on the co-sponsor or the petitioner, so does that make a difference? I wouldn't think so, but I need to satisfy their worries.

- OUR TIMELINE -

04/25/08 - sent I-130 to Chicago lockbox

05/05/08 - received NOA1, assigned to VSC

11/07/08 - transferred to CSC

12/16/08 - NOA2 by email - I-130 approved

12/20/08 - NOA2 in mail - 240 days

12/22/08 - NVC receive package

01/05/09 - we receive AOS Bill and DS-3032

02/12/09 - medical 04th Mar 2009 - NVC Complete - 314 days

04/28/09 - interview passed - 370 days

06/20/09 - visa arrived by courier

06/21/09 - POE Dallas Fort-Worth - 398 days to gain permanent residence (CR-1)

02/22/11 - Sent I-765 to Vermont Service Center

03/03/11 - Received receipt for I-765

04/04/11 - AOS interview and biometrics in Oklahoma City - took all of 20 minutes, no sweat

Currently waiting on my 10-year Green Card - Best wishes to everyone going through their journey!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi guys, I tagged on to the end of another thread a few days ago and am afraid no one saw it, so I'm making a thread in the right forum, I hope!

old thread

Issue:

My wife, the petitioner, moved back in with her parents to save cash while we go through this process. Her mother is going to be a joint sponsor and so we are filling an I-864 for the petitioner and an I-864A for the joint sponsor as we all live under the same roof. We also have our Grandmother-in-law living in the same house, so with me, the immigrant, included, the total household size is 5.

So I am putting the following, please can anyone confirm that I am correct.

21a. 01 - immigrant

21b. 01 - petitioner

21c. 00 - although married, I assume 0 is correct.

21d. 00 - no kids, no siblings under 21.

21e. 02 - Father-in-law and Grandmother-in-law.

21f. 00

21g. 01 - Mother-in-law is co-sponsor

21h. 05 - total household size

A further question is that because the father-in-law and grandmother-in-law has enough income to sustain themselves, they don't consider themselves "dependant" on the co-sponsor or the petitioner, so does that make a difference? I wouldn't think so, but I need to satisfy their worries.

I have a similar situation, so I have the same question, I hope someone who has already filled this out can give you a positive answer, that's how I was thinking of doing it..

From K3 to CR-1 Route

08/29/2008- NOA1 from I-130 (initially going K3)

09/09/2008- NOA1 from I-129f

09/19/2008- Touch for I-130

(canceled I129f after speaking with Senator)

12/15/2008- Touch for I-129f probably to cancel, received withdrawal notice for 129f

12/23/2008 APPROVED for I-130 12/24/2008- Touch on I-130

NVC

12/29/2008- NVC case number assigned.

01/08/2009- DS3032 & AOS fee bill generated

01/08/2009- Husband emailed DS3032

01/10/2009- Received AOS fee bill in mail, payment pending

01/13/2009- AOS fee bill shows PAID online

01/14/2009- DS3032 acceptance email received

01/14/2009- IV fee bill payment in process online

01/15/2009- IV fee bill PAID (unable to print or email cover sheet)

01/15/2009- Sent I-864 package

01/21/2009- Hubby sent DS230 package RFE? on 01/22/2009

01/26/2009- RFE states IV fee not received, however I have a receipt, so I called NVC

01/27/2009- Rec email from NVC inquiry-fees received and DS230 will be sent.

1/30/2009- DS230 received by NVC

02/05/2009- RFE for court clearance, my fault, I misunderstood "applicable"

02/12/2009- Express mailed Court Clearance

02/17/2009- AVR says it has received the checklist letter response.

02/20/2009- CASE COMPLETE!!!!!!!!!!! :)

02/25/2009- Case Forwarded to Embassy!

03/03/2009- Email received APPOINTMENT LETTER!

03/18/2009- Embassy called husband changing interview to April 30. :(

04/16/2009- Medical Exam. Passed

04/30/2009- Interview PASSED

Removing Conditions

02/14/2011- Mailed I-751

02/22/2011- NOA 1 received. GC extended one year.

03/15/2011- Biometrics appt

04/21/2011- Decision made = APPROVED

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did the same thing as you guys i was told by a friend of mine who is a lawyer to put on 21c 0 as on the instructions says that don't count someone twice.

080826-_EDSXyUxFY7L.jpg

Feliz con mi amor...

Ni la distancia ni el tiempo podran separar dos vidas determinadas a estar unidas...

Neither time nor distance can separate two lives that are destined to become one..

USCIS- VERMONT OFFICE

I-130 NOA 1 03/05/08

I-129f NOA 1 06/12/08

I-130 NOA2 12/14/08

I-129f NOA2 12/14/08

NVC

12/18/2008 Assigned Case number

12/22/2008 DS3032 and AOS bill generated

12/26/2008 Received INN by mail

12/26/2008 paid AOS bill

12/27/2008 sent DS3032 and I-864 package

12/29/2008 DS3032 choice of agent confirmation

12/29/2008 paid DS230

01/03/2009 sent DS230 package

01/07/2009 Complete Affidavit review and acceptance

01/12/2009 Case complete

04/13/2009 interview (approved)

K3 @ Embassy

sent to US embassy at SDO 12/19/08

received 12/23/08

interview date 04/22/09

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Canada
Timeline

The way i did mine, and it made it thru, was I and my mother filled out a I-864 each even though that is my residence. The way i understand the I-864A is that it means that my mother makes her income available to me to be able to support my husband, which isn't the case and i am not dependent on her at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for replying guys, that has helped me relax a little.

I am putting 21c. as 0 as stated above and as my wife is dependent on her family, her mother is filing an I-864A for joint support. I am putting both Father and Grandma on as dependants too, as technically they are and they earn enough to cover it all, so better safe than sorry I hope.

- OUR TIMELINE -

04/25/08 - sent I-130 to Chicago lockbox

05/05/08 - received NOA1, assigned to VSC

11/07/08 - transferred to CSC

12/16/08 - NOA2 by email - I-130 approved

12/20/08 - NOA2 in mail - 240 days

12/22/08 - NVC receive package

01/05/09 - we receive AOS Bill and DS-3032

02/12/09 - medical 04th Mar 2009 - NVC Complete - 314 days

04/28/09 - interview passed - 370 days

06/20/09 - visa arrived by courier

06/21/09 - POE Dallas Fort-Worth - 398 days to gain permanent residence (CR-1)

02/22/11 - Sent I-765 to Vermont Service Center

03/03/11 - Received receipt for I-765

04/04/11 - AOS interview and biometrics in Oklahoma City - took all of 20 minutes, no sweat

Currently waiting on my 10-year Green Card - Best wishes to everyone going through their journey!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...