Figured I would crack this thread back open since I'm visiting VJ forum again while my husband goes through the naturalization process. I lived in NZ for 13 years before we moved to the US. My husband and I both have Kiwisavers with reasonably large balances and have encountered the following issues with tax filing that really irk me:
Our professional tax preparers (both Expat Tax Online who I used for years when I lived in NZ and now expat tax specialists Bright!Tax that we've used for join filing the past 2 years) told us that Kiwisaver does not meet the IRS requirements to be filed as a pension fund.
Instead our Kiwisavers have been filed as foreign investment accounts meaning the returns are treated as capital gains and added as income on our 1040, even though they are locked in Kiwisaver and NOT realized gains. This wasn't an issue when the market was crappy during covid and we had no or negative returns but it has been an issue for our 2023 and 2024 returns (adding ~15k to our taxable income).
We don't really want to transfer our Kiwisaver funds to the US because the exchange rate isn't great BUT we might end up doing that before the end of 2025 if we can't figure something out.
Really interested to hear others' experiences and advice here! @KK_Shanks @Jacq1227 @visacats