Jump to content

14 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Okay finally my lawyer recieved the RFE it was for evidence to proove that my husband makes enough to support us. Okay here is the deal in 2005 he only made $15,000 for the yrs as per the tax returns.Right now he is making $ 13.50 per hr is this enough for proof. Anyone pls tell me your experince on this ???. He has new job. He has only been there 3 months does it matter? I will be getting a letter form his employer to mail back to USCIS saying how long he has been with them and how much he makes.Do I need anything else?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Timeline

shoe,

Can't tell you if your husband's current income will be considered adequate or not. It is adequate in amount, but with only 3 months on the job and a history of less than adequate income there may not be sufficient confidence that the current income is sustainable.

What you need is anything that will show that current income is adequate and is sustainable. Adequate is easy and you seem to have that covered, sustainable can be more problematic. Try to get the employer to be as positive in that regard as they are willing to be, but recognize that no savvy employer is going to state that a job is permanent.

Yodrak

Okay finally my lawyer recieved the RFE it was for evidence to proove that my husband makes enough to support us. Okay here is the deal in 2005 he only made $15,000 for the yrs as per the tax returns.Right now he is making $ 13.50 per hr is this enough for proof. Anyone pls tell me your experince on this ???. He has new job. He has only been there 3 months does it matter? I will be getting a letter form his employer to mail back to USCIS saying how long he has been with them and how much he makes.Do I need anything else?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Okay with the new law that I just read about is says thst the only tax return that matters in the most recent yr. In 2005 he missed it by $ 1,000. Right now since he is making $13.50 per hr as I indicated b4 but since its not time to file taxes for 2006 yet we dont have any IRS form to submit. He will get a letter from his employer to send to USCIS but Im wondering if this is going to slow down the whole process. The main reason he did not meet the guideliness is because he did not work for the whole year due to being laid off. Guess all this does not matter does it? Im loosing my mind because we dont have anyone to be a joint sponor. I cannot believe this is happening.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We have sort of a similar situation. My husband just moved to a new job (although his previous W2s as well as current salary indicates that we meet the 125% poverty limit.) I just came from an immigration clinic and it was suggested that because his tenure at his new job is rather short, it would be best to also provide a bank letter. Not sure if this helps.

Okay with the new law that I just read about is says thst the only tax return that matters in the most recent yr. In 2005 he missed it by $ 1,000. Right now since he is making $13.50 per hr as I indicated b4 but since its not time to file taxes for 2006 yet we dont have any IRS form to submit. He will get a letter from his employer to send to USCIS but Im wondering if this is going to slow down the whole process. The main reason he did not meet the guideliness is because he did not work for the whole year due to being laid off. Guess all this does not matter does it? Im loosing my mind because we dont have anyone to be a joint sponor. I cannot believe this is happening.

From the same immigration consultant, it's understandable that you still don't have the W2s for 2006 so you can submit your packet without it. However, be sure to bring it with you on your interview date (Assuming you've already filed taxes then.)

12/02/06 (Saturday)- mailed I-130/AOS/EAD to CHI via express mail

12/04/06 (Monday)- Packet delivered to CHI/Receipt date in NOA1 (Day 1)

12/08/06 - Checks cashed (Day 4)

12/11/06 - Received NOA1/I-797C Notice (Day 7)

12/14/06 - Touched: I-130/AOS/EAD (Day 10)

12/18/06 - Touched: I-130/EAD (Day 14)/ Received Biometrics Letter

12/19/06 - Touched: I-130/EAD (Day 15)

12/27/06 - Had Biometrics taken (Day 23)

12/28/06 - Touched: AOS/EAD (Day 24)

01/04/07 - Touched: AOS/EAD (Day 32)

01/22/07 - Received Interview Letter for March 8, 2007 (Day 50) (Thank you Lord!!!)

02/21/07 - Touched: I-130/AOS (Day 80)

02/22/07 - Touched EAD (Day 81)

02/26/07 - EAD approved as per email from CRIS (Day 85)--- Yay!!!

02/28/07 - EAD card ordered (Day 87)

03/02/07 - Received EAD

03/08/07 - Interview Day (Day 95)-- Approved! Whoohoo! Thank you Lord!!

03/09/07 - Email notice: "Notice mailed welcoming the new permanent resident"

03/13/07 - Email notice: "Card production ordered"

03/19/07 - Permanent Resident Card and "Welcome to America" notice received!!! Yahoo!!!

Jan 2009 - Divorce final

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Timeline

shoe,

There's no new law and current income (I-864 Lines 23 and 24) is what counts most in determining if the Sponsor meets the requirements. Not last year's tax return (Line 25), that's secondary.

Document the current income with the employer's letter and paystubs, and do something to show that this will be continuing income (not a temporary or contract position that will end).

Are you talking with your attorney about this? What are the attorney's suggestions to you?

Yodrak

Okay with the new law that I just read about is says thst the only tax return that matters in the most recent yr. In 2005 he missed it by $ 1,000. Right now since he is making $13.50 per hr as I indicated b4 but since its not time to file taxes for 2006 yet we dont have any IRS form to submit. He will get a letter from his employer to send to USCIS but Im wondering if this is going to slow down the whole process. The main reason he did not meet the guideliness is because he did not work for the whole year due to being laid off. Guess all this does not matter does it? Im loosing my mind because we dont have anyone to be a joint sponor. I cannot believe this is happening.
Edited by Yodrak
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: United Kingdom
Timeline

We are having similar problems. We just got our RFE asking us to prove 125% Poverty Line Income because my wife's earnings for last year were below the line. She has a better paid job now but it is not secure employment and her hours per week are variable. We don't have anyone that is willing to take on the legal responsibilities of becoming a Co-Sponsor (I don't blame them) and all the money I brought over with me has run out - I've had to borrow another $4000 from my savings in the UK to keep us going for the next few months.

I have recently been offered a job but Homeland Security say that I will not be eligible for EAD until we can prove that my wife's income is enough to support us. Is it just me or is that just ###-backwards? If they'd let me work then it wouldn't matter what my wife is earning because she wouldn't have to support me!

People are starting to tell us to get an immigration lawyer involved but given our minimal funds we are reluctant to start paying someone $crazy an hour unless it's likely to help us get my work permit quickly.

Can anyone offer us any hope?

Cate and Liver's Timeline At A Glance:

18 Oct 2005 - Fiance petition sent off...

31 Oct 2005 - Receive first NOA

10 Feb 2006 - Application for petition approved!

10 Mar 2006 - Visa application pack received.

24 Mar 2006 - Liver had his medical examination in London

24 Apr 2006 - Received an interview date

10 May 2006 - The Interview at the US Embassy in London

11 May 2006 - K-1 Visa arrives first thing in the morning

21 May 2006 - Flew out to North Carolina (neglected to complete I-94 due to misinterpreting the instructions...)

27 May 2006 - Married!

14 Jun 2006 - Applied for I-102 (replacement for I-94)

11 Jul 2006 - I-102 Approved

31 Jul 2006 - Completed application for Social Security Card

24 Aug 2006 - Received Social Security card

28 Aug 2006 - Got my first US Photo ID

?? Oct 2006 - Applied for AoS and EAD

?? Nov 2006 - Received NOA for AoS and EAD

?? Nov 2006 - Received RFE to prove 125% Poverty Line Income Requirement

29th Nov 2006 - Biometrics Appointment

?? Dec 2006 - Sent additional affidavit of support with evidence from cosponsor

16 Jan 2007 - Received notice that my I-485 case has been transferred to California processing centre 'to speed up processing'

18 Jan 2007 - Received Work Permit

7 Feb 2007 - Received Conditional Permanent Resident Card!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Timeline

Liver Perfect,

Have a consultation with an immigration attorney to discuss this specific issue.

And have your wife get a 2nd job. It may be a hard life for a while, but it would get you past this hurdle. (To paraphrase L'Oreal - are you worth it?)

Yodrak

We are having similar problems. We just got our RFE asking us to prove 125% Poverty Line Income because my wife's earnings for last year were below the line. She has a better paid job now but it is not secure employment and her hours per week are variable. We don't have anyone that is willing to take on the legal responsibilities of becoming a Co-Sponsor (I don't blame them) and all the money I brought over with me has run out - I've had to borrow another $4000 from my savings in the UK to keep us going for the next few months.

I have recently been offered a job but Homeland Security say that I will not be eligible for EAD until we can prove that my wife's income is enough to support us. Is it just me or is that just ###-backwards? If they'd let me work then it wouldn't matter what my wife is earning because she wouldn't have to support me!

People are starting to tell us to get an immigration lawyer involved but given our minimal funds we are reluctant to start paying someone $crazy an hour unless it's likely to help us get my work permit quickly.

Can anyone offer us any hope?

Edited by Yodrak
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Country: United Kingdom
Timeline
We are having similar problems. We just got our RFE asking us to prove 125% Poverty Line Income because my wife's earnings for last year were below the line. She has a better paid job now but it is not secure employment and her hours per week are variable. We don't have anyone that is willing to take on the legal responsibilities of becoming a Co-Sponsor (I don't blame them) and all the money I brought over with me has run out - I've had to borrow another $4000 from my savings in the UK to keep us going for the next few months.

I have recently been offered a job but Homeland Security say that I will not be eligible for EAD until we can prove that my wife's income is enough to support us. Is it just me or is that just ###-backwards? If they'd let me work then it wouldn't matter what my wife is earning because she wouldn't have to support me!

People are starting to tell us to get an immigration lawyer involved but given our minimal funds we are reluctant to start paying someone $crazy an hour unless it's likely to help us get my work permit quickly.

Can anyone offer us any hope?

First, understand that you could have applied for your AOS/EAD much earlier than you have. I'm just saying, accept your part in the delay.

Second, why are they so sucky about this?!

You mention savings---did you mention them on the I-864? Your assets are allowed to be included, and that may have made a difference (probably not the way these folks are 'checking' I-864s, buuuut). Any other assets you two can scare up?

Also, I seem to recall having this convo with you before you got here---didn't you guys have a plan worked out? Did something go wrong with that?

Third, there's not going to be any 'fast' EAD no matter who helps you. That's sucky, sorry to bear the news.

Solution-wise, Yodrak's summed it up. Nothing is really going to happen until you get that I-864 + I-485 moving.

Now That You Are A Permanent Resident

How Do I Remove The Conditions On Permanent Residence Based On Marriage?

Welcome to the United States: A Guide For New Immigrants

Yes, even this last one.. stuff in there that not even your USC knows.....

Here are more links that I love:

Arriving in America, The POE Drill

Dual Citizenship FAQ

Other Fora I Post To:

alt.visa.us.marriage-based http://britishexpats.com/ and www.***removed***.com

censored link = *family based immigration* website

Inertia. Is that the Greek god of 'can't be bothered'?

Met, married, immigrated, naturalized.

I-130 filed Aug02

USC Jul06

No Deje Piedras Sobre El Pavimento!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: United Kingdom
Timeline

Well, we have persuaded my wife's parents to co-sponsor me now so that's a start. :)

As far as assets go, nothing much happening. Just my savings, half of which I used to support myself up until the present (I opted to self-sponsor at the time of my Visa interview). The money I'm transferring over is the majority of my remaining savings. We didn't include my savings on the I-864 because by our calculations my wife was earning enough to meet 125% poverty, but it seems that USCIS are using some other kind of math (probably paying more attention to what she earned LAST year). So we're going to send them more evidence of her current earnings plus a second I-864 from her parents.

One of the other people we asked to co-sponsor me keeps telling us to hire an immigration lawyer and even offered to help us out with legal fees if we do. Is there any value in us doing this at this point, given that, as meauxna says, there is no way of speeding up the EAD process? I have an inherent distrust of lawyers at the best of times and loathe the idea of paying someone a fortune to do something if I can do it myself just as well.

In other news, I now have a biometrics appointment booked for the end of November. Unfortunately we have to drive 5 hours to reach the place and then 5 hours back. Can anyone tell me how long these appointments tend to last, and what is involved? I believe that they just take fingerprints and photos. Am I right?

Cate and Liver's Timeline At A Glance:

18 Oct 2005 - Fiance petition sent off...

31 Oct 2005 - Receive first NOA

10 Feb 2006 - Application for petition approved!

10 Mar 2006 - Visa application pack received.

24 Mar 2006 - Liver had his medical examination in London

24 Apr 2006 - Received an interview date

10 May 2006 - The Interview at the US Embassy in London

11 May 2006 - K-1 Visa arrives first thing in the morning

21 May 2006 - Flew out to North Carolina (neglected to complete I-94 due to misinterpreting the instructions...)

27 May 2006 - Married!

14 Jun 2006 - Applied for I-102 (replacement for I-94)

11 Jul 2006 - I-102 Approved

31 Jul 2006 - Completed application for Social Security Card

24 Aug 2006 - Received Social Security card

28 Aug 2006 - Got my first US Photo ID

?? Oct 2006 - Applied for AoS and EAD

?? Nov 2006 - Received NOA for AoS and EAD

?? Nov 2006 - Received RFE to prove 125% Poverty Line Income Requirement

29th Nov 2006 - Biometrics Appointment

?? Dec 2006 - Sent additional affidavit of support with evidence from cosponsor

16 Jan 2007 - Received notice that my I-485 case has been transferred to California processing centre 'to speed up processing'

18 Jan 2007 - Received Work Permit

7 Feb 2007 - Received Conditional Permanent Resident Card!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shoe:

I haven't sent in my AOS application (will be on Wed when I get back my medical), but here is what I did.

Our 2005 income tax return shows an income lower than 125% of the poverty guidelines, mainly because my husband was in Canada with me and didn't work at all that year until May, 2005.

So, I added a letter from the employer, a recent pay stub (showing gross earnings to date for 2006) and a letter from him (hubby) explaning why he had almost no income for 2004 and not as much as needed to sponsor me for 2005.

I'm hoping that this is sufficient. I added these extra things in anticipation of potential questions they may have about his ability to support me based on last years taxes.

Liver Perfect:

I would think that if you can prove that her job is fairly stable (if any job really is), and that you meet the 125% of the poverty guidelines, that they may consider that sufficient. But I really have no idea how they apply this rule. It appears to me from what I have read that it is CURRENT income that counts, so maybe they just want extra proof to verify her income.

It'd be great though if you had a co-sponsor who had enough income (and stable income) to meet the requirements.

As far as EAD goes, they really don't care if you will be/ could be/ can be working to help support the family unit (if you are the beneficiary). They are only interested in making sure that the person sponsoring you meets the guidelines.

When you go to the AOS interview, if you are working at that time and have income and have lived with your spouse for at least 6 months, I believe that you can count your income towards meeting the 125%.

You could bring in a new affidavit of support and submit that one and at that point they may not even require a co-sponsor.

Edited by jane2005

2001 Met

2005 Married

I-485/I-130

12/06/2006-------Mailed I-130/1-485

12/16/2006--------Recieved NOA 1 (I-130 & I-485)

12/18/2006--------Touched I-130/I-485

01/20/2007--------Biometrics

05/10/2007 -- Interview, Approved!

05/22/2007 GREEN CARD arrives!!!

02/2009 - File to lift conditions

I-765

12/14/2006--- Mailed EAD App.

01/20/2007--- Biometrics

02/09/2005-------Sent in request to Congressional office for assistance with expediting EAD.

02/13/2007 -------- EAD Approved!

02/26/2007 - ------EAD received

Removal of Conditions:

05/12/2009 -- Overnighted application by USPS express mail (VSC).

05/14/2009 -- Green Card expired.

05/23/2009 --- Check cleared bank.

05/26/2009 -- Received NOA (NOA date May 15, 2009, guess they aren't deporting me).

05/29/2009- Biometrics Notice date

06/01/2009- Received Biometrics Letter

06/18/2009 - Biometrics

09/23/2009 - date of decision to approve (letter received), just waiting for card. No online updates whatsoever.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think your lawyer is probably correct. For the officer looking at your application, they see that last year's taxes show that your spouse didn't meet the 125% guideline.

It seems logical that they would want you to send in verification that the current yearly income DOES meet the 125%.

Your answer makes me feel a bit better and I hope I've headed off a potential RFE by including the extra information with my application.

2001 Met

2005 Married

I-485/I-130

12/06/2006-------Mailed I-130/1-485

12/16/2006--------Recieved NOA 1 (I-130 & I-485)

12/18/2006--------Touched I-130/I-485

01/20/2007--------Biometrics

05/10/2007 -- Interview, Approved!

05/22/2007 GREEN CARD arrives!!!

02/2009 - File to lift conditions

I-765

12/14/2006--- Mailed EAD App.

01/20/2007--- Biometrics

02/09/2005-------Sent in request to Congressional office for assistance with expediting EAD.

02/13/2007 -------- EAD Approved!

02/26/2007 - ------EAD received

Removal of Conditions:

05/12/2009 -- Overnighted application by USPS express mail (VSC).

05/14/2009 -- Green Card expired.

05/23/2009 --- Check cleared bank.

05/26/2009 -- Received NOA (NOA date May 15, 2009, guess they aren't deporting me).

05/29/2009- Biometrics Notice date

06/01/2009- Received Biometrics Letter

06/18/2009 - Biometrics

09/23/2009 - date of decision to approve (letter received), just waiting for card. No online updates whatsoever.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
“;}
×
×
  • Create New...