scottv009

49 minutes ago, Hypnos said:

They wanted either your aunt's complete tax return, which includes all forms and schedules she submitted (not only the 1040), or a tax transcript, which has all of that information on it by default. 

 

You will probably need to reapply, this time supplying all of the information and documents they request. 

do you think it's possible to request them to reopen the case? anyone is successful by doing that?

1 hour ago, belinda63 said:

Did you send all the W-2s and supporting documents with it?

I sent them the 1040 tax form, I guess what they wanted to see is the tax transcrip

7 hours ago, geowrian said:

 What precisely did the denial letter state? That they never received a response to the RFE? Or that the response did not include what they asked for?

When did you send the response? Was it sent with a tracking number (and if so, I'm assuming it indicates it was delivered, right?)?

 

If the refusal is due to not responding by a certain date and you have evidence of sending the response to the proper address (from the RFE) before that date, then you can request that they reopen the case. A Motion To Reconsider (MTR) may or may not be necessary.

The one that I sent them wasn't what they ask for. That was my mistake of misunderstanding the tax papers.   

I sent them the 1040 tax form a day after I received the RFE notice. My question is that what are those possible ways to fix this problem? 

Hi family and friends, 

I am currently exhausted by my situation right now. I applied the I-485 for my mom who is 3 years overstayer. We went to the interview a week ago, everything went well except the officer asked for the 2018 tax transcript of my aunt( who is sponsoring for my mom because I have not enough income to sponsor her by myself) and I did not have that. He then sent me a RFE of my aunt 2018 tax which (W2, 1099 or transcript), I replied right a day after by sending him 2018 tax return (which what my aunt gave me). Today I received a decision letter of denial which saying that we failed to provide what they want. 

So please, anyone can help me with some advises what should I do next? should I hire a lawyer to help us in this case? 

Thank you All