Jump to content
Peikko

The election of Meles Zenawi with 97% of seats reflects a worrying trend away from multiparty systems throughout Africa

4 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Posted

In his ruling party's landslide victory in weekend parliamentary polls, Ethiopia's prime minister Meles Zenawi saw an enthusiastic popular endorsement of polices that are gradually leading the country out of poverty and backwardness. But western observers and human rights groups saw something quite different: the alarming advance, mirrored in other African states, of what might be termed one-party democracy.

Meles's Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front, in power since 1991, and its allies won about 97% of parliamentary seats, assuring it another five-year term. Opposition groups were decimated. With most results in, the eight-party Medrek (Forum) coalition, the All Ethiopia Unity Organisation, and the Ethiopian Democratic party took only two seats between them, despite fielding candidates in most constituencies.

The comprehensiveness of Meles's victory seemed to take even the government by surprise. It quickly recovered. "Logic dictates that the party was bound to succeed. In democracies a government with a sound track record remains in power … There is therefore no room for anyone, be it the contesting parties or the international media, to reiterate alleged irregularities and rigging of votes," an official statement said.

Berhanu Kebede, Ethiopia's ambassador in London, said voters had rewarded Meles for his achievements. "The government has registered successful development and growth polices. There has been double-digit growth for the past seven years. Primary school and health sector coverage have greatly improved. There has been more investment in infrastructure in the past 10 years than in the previous 100," he said.

In contrast to the ruling party's "mature and experienced leadership", the opposition was disorganised and lacked a clear strategy and policies, Berhanu said. It had comprehensively lost a series of nine televised debates on healthcare, foreign policy and other issues. He dismissed concerns expressed by EU poll observers about the lack of a "level playing field" and accused Human Rights Watch, an independent human rights advocacy organisation, of pursuing a hostile agenda and relying on "hearsay".

In a hard-hitting report this week, Human Rights Watch said the government "intimidated voters and unlawfully restricted the media" prior to the polls and employed "repressive legal and administrative measures" to restrict freedom of expression. Its findings echoed complaints by Medrek during the campaign that its candidates had been harassed, some had been jailed, and three members had been killed.

Government critics claim the opposition's poor showing is a product of a crackdown that followed the last polls in 2005, when about 200 people died in post-election unrest, opposition leaders were jailed, and the then main anti-government alliance, the Coalition for Unity and Democracy, later broke up in disarray. The hope of political change was stifled during that period, it is argued, and has yet to revive.

Though still unwelcome to the government, European and US criticism has been muted, reflecting a mutual interest in maintaining counterterrorism and other co-operative ties with Meles, who is widely seen as the sort of African leader the west can do business with. "While the elections were calm and peaceful and largely without any kind of violence, we noted with some degree of remorse that [they] were not up to international standards," Johnnie Carson, the top US diplomat for Africa, said.

But Carson hastened to add that Washington valued its relationship with Ethiopia and "appreciate the level of collaboration we receive". The US views Ethiopia as crucial to maintaining stability and countering Islamist extremism in the Horn of Africa, notably in neighbouring Somalia. Like other western countries such as Britain, a major bilateral aid donor, the US is highly unlikely to take any action over election irregularities, real or imagined.

Hard-nosed calculations of this type inform western approaches to other African "one-party democracies", an attitude that could be said to encourage the trend away from genuine multiparty systems, thereby undermining the drive for good governance. But the problem is rooted in Africa itself. One analyst dubbed the trend "winner-takes-all politics". And it is spreading.

In Uganda, President Yoweri Museveni, once hailed as an African democratic role model, appears, Mugabe-style, to have installed himself in office for life. In Burundi and Rwanda, the runup to elections this summer is following a familiar pattern: alleged increased ruling-party repression and intimidation of opponents, media restrictions, and reduced access for independent observers and NGOs. Even in South Africa, self-styled continental showcase, political life is dominated by one party, the African National Congress. It is difficult to envisage conditions in which the ANC would voluntarily relinquish power.

In Congo, meanwhile, observers suggest mounting official pressure on the UN peacekeeping force to withdraw is linked to the government's wish to avoid too close international scrutiny of next year's presidential and parliamentary elections. "The consolidation of democracy in the Democratic Republic of Congo is stalled on almost all fronts," a recent International Crisis Group report warned. "Civil liberties are regularly threatened and key institutional reforms … have made no significant progress."

The Africa Progress report, published this week to mark Africa Day, highlighted the importance of legitimate governance. "Africa's development and the welfare of its people depend above all upon the political commitment and capacity of its leaders," it said.

Speaking recently in Cameroon to mark 50 years of independence from colonial rule of a cluster of African countries, Kofi Annan, chairman of the panel that produced the progress report, remained optimistic about Africa's prospects overall but suggested too many of those same leaders were falling down on the job: "There are still too many instances of corruption, of elite capture of resources, of growing inequality in work and opportunity, abuse of electoral processes and selective adherence to the rule of law."

Link

Refusing to use the spellchick!

I have put you on ignore. No really, I have, but you are still ruining my enjoyment of this site. .

Filed: Timeline
Posted

There was no election in Ethiopia. They had something closer to an election five years ago. Following that, butcher Zenawi had over 200 people killed in the streets of Addis Ababa - in broad daylight no less - that dared to question his supposed victory. Thousands were arrested and jailed. In the run-up to this sham election, dissenters were quieted and intimidated early on so that Zenawi can pretend that people actually voted for him. Ha. Just from a tribal point of view - still a matter of importance in Ethiopia as it is in much of Africa - Zenawi is Tigray. His tribe makes up only 6% of the population (the Smoalis actually have a larger presence there) while the Oromo and Amhara with 35% and 27%, respectively make up the majority of the population. Does anyone really believe that the majority of either of these large tribes would vote for a guy from a minority tribe - the same tribe that actually makes up most of neighboring Eritrea which Ethiopia had been at war with for years and with which it still has very tense relations? Whoever does ought to take some reality pills.

All I can say is that I made sure my wife and daugther were back home prior to this sham election taking place.

Posted
...European and US criticism has been muted, reflecting a mutual interest in maintaining counterterrorism and other co-operative ties with Meles, who is widely seen as the sort of African leader the west can do business with. "While the elections were calm and peaceful and largely without any kind of violence, we noted with some degree of remorse that [they] were not up to international standards," Johnnie Carson, the top US diplomat for Africa, said.

But Carson hastened to add that Washington valued its relationship with Ethiopia and "appreciate the level of collaboration we receive". The US views Ethiopia as crucial to maintaining stability and countering Islamist extremism in the Horn of Africa, notably in neighbouring Somalia. Like other western countries such as Britain, a major bilateral aid donor, the US is highly unlikely to take any action over election irregularities, real or imagined.

It's this bit that bothered me most - we in the west continually display double standards and somehow expect that the outcome is going to be universally positive in areas where democracy is at best tenuous and often non existent. Terrible really.

Refusing to use the spellchick!

I have put you on ignore. No really, I have, but you are still ruining my enjoyment of this site. .

Filed: Timeline
Posted
It's this bit that bothered me most - we in the west continually display double standards and somehow expect that the outcome is going to be universally positive in areas where democracy is at best tenuous and often non existent. Terrible really.

I guess sometimes it's a bit of a trade-off. One thing that Zenawi has brought to Ethiopia is a good bit of stability and quite a bit of economic development. And he is a partner to the US in terms of dealing with Islamic terrorism on the Horn of Africa. A democracy they do not have in Ethiopia - and likely won't have for decades to come. But look around the continent and you'll realize that both Ethiopa and western interests in the region could be much worse off. Reality sucks...

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...