CR1/ denied / proof of relationship. HELP

[luck999 0]

My interveiw was on 14 may montreal for cr1. officer only took 10 min and said i need to provide proof of relationship. and she returned my passport. i have no idea what does that mean . i have phone records for last 6 month and gave photo album 100 pictures. (which she keep). she told me send via mail/loomis i dont have to come again. can somebody please help what i need to send now and how long its going to take to get visa. my satus is showing AP ? what doest that mean. please help me.

[Ms Hogan 295]

I'm sorry but it is surprising when interviews in Montreal don't go well. They are usually very straight-forward. What type of evidence did you send in the first place? What kind of questions did they ask you?

[Boiler 43,393]

I agree very odd, you have one post so nobidy knows your story.

[Done--Really 331]

And please be very precise about the EXACT information you submitted, as well as the specific questions that were asked -- without both, it's hard to give any advice

[luck999 0]

I'm sorry but it is surprising when interviews in Montreal don't go well. They are usually very straight-forward. What type of evidence did you send in the first place? What kind of questions did they ask you?

Thanks for replying folks.

where we met?

how big is wedding?

what kind of work she do?

what kind of work i m doing?

asked pictures ? provided 100 pics

phone records ? provided last 6 month

i have Indian passport may be that is a reason.

every thing is good she said . tax/ no criminal history nothing

at the end she said she need more evidence for proof of relationship. and denied under section B221 and asked me to send evidence through mail. Now my status showing AP.

ANY IDEA WHY?

[Boiler 43,393]

Arranged marriage?

What is your status in Canada.

[luck999 0]

Arranged marriage?

What is your status in Canada.

Work permit

APPLIED PERMANENT RESIDENT FOR BOTH OF US. GAVE CIC LETTER TO SHOW CONSULATE OFFICER TOO. LEGAL STATUS IN CANADA.

[Boiler 43,393]

So an arranged marriage, that could be why.

[Ebunoluwa 6,136]

My interveiw was on 14 may montreal for cr1. officer only took 10 min and said i need to provide proof of relationship. and she returned my passport. i have no idea what does that mean . i have phone records for last 6 month and gave photo album 100 pictures. (which she keep). she told me send via mail/loomis i dont have to come again. can somebody please help what i need to send now and how long its going to take to get visa. my satus is showing AP ? what doest that mean. please help me.

Note: Evidence of a Bonifide Marriage

The USCIS now requires that when filing an I-130 for a spouse that you include evidence of a bonifide marriage. They list examples of acceptable evidence as: 1. Documentation showing joint ownership or property; or 2. A lease showing joint tenancy of a common residence; or 3. Documentation showing co-mingling of financial resources; or 4. Birth certificate(s) of child(ren) born to you, the petitioner, and your spouse together; or 5. Affidavits sworn to or affirmed by third parties having personal knowledge of the bona fides of the marita lrelationship (Each affidavit must contain the full name and address, date and place of birth of the person making the affidavit, his or her relationship to the petitioner of beneficiary, if any, and complete information and details explaining how the person acquired his or her knowledge of your marriage); or 6. Any other relevant documentation to establish that there is an ongoing marital union.

[Done--Really 331]

Fine, but what evidence did you actually submit ?? Trust me -- we can't help without knowing more.

[Ebunoluwa 6,136]

Bring more evidence of communication from the start of the relationship to current also.

Any receipts from trips, hotels, visits etc....and some co mingling I posted above from the VJ guide.

[luck999 0]

THANKS EVERYONE FOR REPLING.

FOR EVIDENCE I SHOWED MY CALL RECORDS LAST 6 MONTH

WEEDING ALBUM 100 PIC

SHE LAST VISTED HERE IN CANADA 1 YEAR AGO SINCE THAT TIME WE ARE WAITING FOR NVC BUT NOW SHE IS COMING HERE NEXT WEEK I HOPE IT HELP.

BUT IS THERE ANYTHING SAME (AP) CASE ON VISA FOURM HOW LONG DOES IT TAKES.

[Boiler 43,393]

All is clear.

You answered your own question.

[Rob L 3,811]

THANKS EVERYONE FOR REPLING.

FOR EVIDENCE I SHOWED MY CALL RECORDS LAST 6 MONTH

WEEDING ALBUM 100 PIC

SHE LAST VISTED HERE IN CANADA 1 YEAR AGO SINCE THAT TIME WE ARE WAITING FOR NVC BUT NOW SHE IS COMING HERE NEXT WEEK I HOPE IT HELP.

BUT IS THERE ANYTHING SAME (AP) CASE ON VISA FOURM HOW LONG DOES IT TAKES.

It is interesting that USCIS was ok with your file and the Embassy was not convinced. Is there anything in the questions that the interviewer asked that may give you a clue as to why the Consulate sees things differently?

suggestions for evidence (just a starting list)

• Here is one thing that may help: Have your wife add you to bank accounts and insurance plans as a beneficiary. The same can be said for your bank account.
• Also when she filed her 2014 taxes did she include you has her spouse ( married filing jointly , married filing separate ) ? It is a challenge because one needs to file a W7 to get a tax id number , but there are ways to file without one
• Any intermingling of funds between bank accounts ( you helped her, she helped you)
• Documents a trips taken together, boarding passes for example
• Print outs of Social media or email that would indicate you are a couple.

At this point I would just bury the embassy with evidence.

[luck999 0]

It is interesting that USCIS was ok with your file and the Embassy was not convinced. Is there anything in the questions that the interviewer asked that may give you a clue as to why the Consulate sees things differently?

suggestions for evidence (just a starting list)

• Here is one thing that may help: Have your wife add you to bank accounts and insurance plans as a beneficiary. The same can be said for your bank account.
• Also when she filed her 2014 taxes did she include you has her spouse ( married filing jointly , married filing separate ) ? It is a challenge because one needs to file a W7 to get a tax id number , but there are ways to file without one
• Any intermingling of funds between bank accounts ( you helped her, she helped you)
• Documents a trips taken together, boarding passes for example
• Print outs of Social media or email that would indicate you are a couple.

At this point I would just bury the embassy with evidence.

Bank accounts. NO

insurance plans . YES

Tax . YES

Bank transfers. YES

trips. NO

PICTURES/ SOCIAL MEDIA / PHONE records. YES last 6 months

i am confused why? only weird thing in interview i believe is she was confused that . HOW CAN BE A WHITE GIRL IS A HINDU RELIGION.

except that i dont think anyone can prove more evidence bcaz thats every body got in most cases.