Jump to content
Tim

Passed U.S. Citizenship Test, but request more evidence..weird??

 Share

35 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Canada
Timeline

Since you ask, here is the link to the documents required: http://www.uscis.gov/files/article/attachments.pdf

specifically for marriage based applications"

If you are applying for naturalization on the basis of marriage to a U.S. citizen, send the following four items:

1. Evidence that your spouse has been a U.S. citizen for the last three years:

• Birth certificate (if your spouse never lost citizenship since birth), or

• Naturalization certificate, or

• Certificate of Citizenship, or

• The inside of the front cover and signature page of your spouse’s current U.S. passport, or

• Form FS-240, “Report of Birth Abroad of a Citizen of the United States of America,” and

2. Your current marriage certificate; and

3. Proof of termination of all prior marriages of your spouse-divorce decree(s), annulment(s), or death certificate(s);

4. Documents referring to you and your spouse:

• Tax returns, bank accounts, leases, mortgages, or birth certificates of children, or

• Internal Revenue Service (IRS)-certified copies of the income tax forms that you both filed for the past three years, or

• An IRS tax return transcript for the last three years.

If you were married before, send:

Proof that all earlier marriages ended-divorce decree(s), annulments, or death certificates(s);

We sent in the exact 4 documents they requested (actually 5 as my husband had been married twice before so had 2 divorce documents) - copy of his birth certificate, copy of our marriage certificate, copies of his divorce decrees and the IRS tax return transcripts for the previous 3 years. I brought additional evidence to the interview but she was not interested in any of it. She didn't even want to see the originals of the copies submitted, so it sounds like the OP submitted exactly what was requested but the IO wanted to see more than was requested. Certainly it is her choice but it doesn't sound to me like the OP neglected to provide what was requested in the N-400 instructions and Guide to Citizenship.

Edited by Kathryn41

“...Isn't it splendid to think of all the things there are to find out about? It just makes me feel glad to be alive--it's such an interesting world. It wouldn't be half so interesting if we knew all about everything, would it? There'd be no scope for imagination then, would there?”

. Lucy Maude Montgomery, Anne of Green Gables

5892822976_477b1a77f7_z.jpg

Another Member of the VJ Fluffy Kitty Posse!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (pnd) Country: Canada
Timeline
This doesn't make any sense. Assuming she came on a K-1, the burden of proof was overcome at both the AOS and the ROC stages. All she has to do now is meet the N-400 conditions, n'est-ce pas?

And what are the N-400 conditions if i may ask? doesnt it require proof of continous marriage and co-habitation with your USC spouse if its based on marriage?

Yes it does. The INS knows people marry out of convience and will pass through the initial AOS and Green Card Stage then stay married, but chose to live their own seperate lives in different houses and date etc like they were single. For the N-400 based on marriage (3 years from your PR status) you need to demonstrate that you and your spouse are still married and still living as a married couple and not singles.

This is where you need to show all documentation from the AOS interviews up to the interview proving that you are still in a commited and loving and serious relationship. If there isn't enough evidence, they will require more to make sure that it is not a marriage of convience.

So just like the AOS stage, you now must re-submit anything and everything you can find to prove your marriage is legit. This includes joint bills, acccounts, photos, leases, morgages etc. Anything that shows you two sharing common things on legal documents...

I'm just a wanderer in the desert winds...

Timeline

1997

Oct - Job offer in US

Nov - Received my TN-1 to be authorized to work in the US

Nov - Moved to US

1998-2001

Recieved 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th TN

2002

May - Met future wife at arts fest

Nov - Recieved 6th TN

2003

Nov - Recieved 7th TN

Jul - Our Wedding

Aug - Filed for AOS

Sep - Recieved EAD

Sep - Recieved Advanced Parole

2004

Jan - Interview, accepted for Green Card

Feb - Green Card Arrived in mail

2005

Oct - I-751 sent off

2006

Jan - 10 year Green Card accepted

Mar - 10 year Green Card arrived

Oct - Filed N-400 for Naturalization

Nov - Biometrics done

Nov - Just recieved Naturalization Interview date for Jan.

2007

Jan - Naturalization Interview Completed

Feb - Oath Letter recieved

Feb - Oath Ceremony

Feb 21 - Finally a US CITIZEN (yay)

THE END

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Colombia
Timeline

Thought my wife's IO was paranoid by checking all of our submitted copies against our originals and we surprised her by having our electric bill with both our names on it. Think I would be lost if they called me in and asked me the names of my wife's relatives, all Spanish that I have difficulty in pronouncing. Caused me to wonder why my wife has English given names.

Can only wonder why they are giving you a hard time, do you and your wife look suspicious? We can share experiences, but sure doesn't help you. My wife's IO either conveniently or inconveniently misplaced her application, got my senators' office to straighten that out when we didn't hear anything like promised. Since you were not approved, do not have that 120 period in which they are suppose to send you your oath letter. Suppose you could contact your senators' office and see if they can help. In my cover letter, invited the USCIS to come out to our home, but they never showed up, didn't want to meet me, just wanted to see my papers.

Called one of those rescue dog places, they wanted to come out to my home just for a mutt dog, surprised the USCIS doesn't do the same.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One thing we all seem to be forgetting is the word JOINT. The list of documents you submit should show joint ownership. If you have health insurance, they just dont want to see your card just to make sure you have health insurance, its a case of; is your wife under yours or are you under hers. When they ask for tax transcripts and you both file seperately it is suspicious.

If one of you has a business i would understand but a case where both parties are working and you are married and filing seperately would even sound suspicious to me and i dont work for the USCIS (please dont misunderstand suspicious to mean wrong).

It is not against the law to file taxes seperately even if you are married, that much is true.

The IO is doing her job, she is trying to get a complete picture and am sure she would rather be doing another interview than interviewing the same couple over and over and over again.

Simply put, there must be a reason why she wants more evidence.

The reason i asked the question in my earlier post was because the earlier poster was trying to insinuate that if you have gone through K1 and AOS, the proof of living together must have been established. Yes, but its still required for the N-400 based on marriage.

Thought my wife's IO was paranoid by checking all of our submitted copies against our originals and we surprised her by having our electric bill with both our names on it. Think I would be lost if they called me in and asked me the names of my wife's relatives, all Spanish that I have difficulty in pronouncing. Caused me to wonder why my wife has English given names.

Can only wonder why they are giving you a hard time, do you and your wife look suspicious? We can share experiences, but sure doesn't help you. My wife's IO either conveniently or inconveniently misplaced her application, got my senators' office to straighten that out when we didn't hear anything like promised. Since you were not approved, do not have that 120 period in which they are suppose to send you your oath letter. Suppose you could contact your senators' office and see if they can help. In my cover letter, invited the USCIS to come out to our home, but they never showed up, didn't want to meet me, just wanted to see my papers.

Called one of those rescue dog places, they wanted to come out to my home just for a mutt dog, surprised the USCIS doesn't do the same.

09/20/2009 (Day 01): N-400 Mailed to Lewisville, TX (Express Mail with Delivery Confirmation)

09/22/2009 (Day 03): N-400 Delivered @ Lewisville, TX @ 9:30am

09/24/2009 (Day 05): Check Cleared

09/28/2009 (Day 08): NOA Received (Priority Date: 09/24/2009)

10/30/2009 (Day 40): (FP Notice Received (scheduled for 11/17/2009)

10/30/2009 (Day 40): (FP done via walk-in on 10/30/2009)

11-07-2009 (Day 48): Touched online for "testing & interview"

11/09/2009 (Day 50): Interview Letter Received

12/10/2009 (Day 81): Interview Date @ 12:30pm (re-scheduled for Dec 21 @ 12:30pm)

02/03/2010 (Day 137): Oath

Link to comment
Share on other sites

why did you file your income tax returns as "Separately

Probably a bit of a red flag!~

thanks for you reply,

I know...

she asked me why did you file your income tax separately, but not together? It means she is totally doesn't understand tax law at all. I told her when you and your spouse filing income return as "Separately", it means you're responsible for your own tax and your spouse responsible for his/her own tax, but it doesn't mean you two live apart. I told her whichever way "together, or separately" give you more benefit, and the tax laws allow you to do it

Of course you're correct. There is no requirement to file taxes jointly. But the tax laws are set up so that the vast majority of married couples will save money by filing jointly, often a significant amount of money. If your finances are typical, the investigator would have to wonder, "why was it so important for them to keep their finances separate that they considered it worth giving up the thousands of dollars in tax savings they would have received by filing a joint return?"

For background:

http://taxation.lawyers.com/tax-planning/M...Tax-Return.html

If you can present evidence that shows how your tax situation is one of those unusual ones where you saved money by filing separately, then that evidence may help your case significantly.

04 Apr, 2004: Got married

05 Apr, 2004: I-130 Sent to CSC

13 Apr, 2004: I-130 NOA 1

19 Apr, 2004: I-129F Sent to MSC

29 Apr, 2004: I-129F NOA 1

13 Aug, 2004: I-130 Approved by CSC

28 Dec, 2004: I-130 Case Complete at NVC

18 Jan, 2005: Got the visa approved in Caracas

22 Jan, 2005: Flew home together! CCS->MIA->SFO

25 May, 2005: I-129F finally approved! We won't pursue it.

8 June, 2006: Our baby girl is born!

24 Oct, 2006: Window for filing I-751 opens

25 Oct, 2006: I-751 mailed to CSC

18 Nov, 2006: I-751 NOA1 received from CSC

30 Nov, 2006: I-751 Biometrics taken

05 Apr, 2007: I-751 approved, card production ordered

23 Jan, 2008: N-400 sent to CSC via certified mail

19 Feb, 2008: N-400 Biometrics taken

27 Mar, 2008: Naturalization interview notice received (NOA2 for N-400)

30 May, 2008: Naturalization interview, passed the test!

17 June, 2008: Naturalization oath notice mailed

15 July, 2008: Naturalization oath ceremony!

16 July, 2008: Registered to vote and applied for US passport

26 July, 2008: US Passport arrived.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Since you ask, here is the link to the documents required: http://www.uscis.gov/files/article/attachments.pdf

specifically for marriage based applications"

If you are applying for naturalization on the basis of marriage to a U.S. citizen, send the following four items:

1. Evidence that your spouse has been a U.S. citizen for the last three years:

• Birth certificate (if your spouse never lost citizenship since birth), or

• Naturalization certificate, or

• Certificate of Citizenship, or

• The inside of the front cover and signature page of your spouse’s current U.S. passport, or

• Form FS-240, “Report of Birth Abroad of a Citizen of the United States of America,” and

2. Your current marriage certificate; and

3. Proof of termination of all prior marriages of your spouse-divorce decree(s), annulment(s), or death certificate(s);

4. Documents referring to you and your spouse:

• Tax returns, bank accounts, leases, mortgages, or birth certificates of children, or

• Internal Revenue Service (IRS)-certified copies of the income tax forms that you both filed for the past three years, or

• An IRS tax return transcript for the last three years.

If you were married before, send:

Proof that all earlier marriages ended-divorce decree(s), annulments, or death certificates(s);

We sent in the exact 4 documents they requested (actually 5 as my husband had been married twice before so had 2 divorce documents) - copy of his birth certificate, copy of our marriage certificate, copies of his divorce decrees and the IRS tax return transcripts for the previous 3 years. I brought additional evidence to the interview but she was not interested in any of it. She didn't even want to see the originals of the copies submitted, so it sounds like the OP submitted exactly what was requested but the IO wanted to see more than was requested. Certainly it is her choice but it doesn't sound to me like the OP neglected to provide what was requested in the N-400 instructions and Guide to Citizenship.

You/I think you are hot and have everything required in the submission. :bonk:

I missed writting the A# on the back of the check. It's been cashed tho and have the NOA1.

First time I've ever seen or seen posted requiring you to write your A# on the back of the check or money order.

K1 denied, K3/K4, CR-1/CR-2, AOS, ROC, Adoption, US citizenship and dual citizenship

!! ALL PAU!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: AOS (apr) Country: Philippines
Timeline

With everything being discussed here, it appears that its a lot easier to file for citizenship after getting divorce and then wait for the 5 year rule.

12/29/2007 Got married in the Philippines
03/28/2008 Got 10yr B1/B2 visa
04/12/2008 Arrived in US under B1/B2 visa
08/06/2008 Filed I-539 visa extension
10/23/2008 I-539 approved
02/23/2009 USC wife filed I-130 Chicago Lockbox
02/26/2009 I-130 delivered to Chicago Lockbox
02/27/2009 Medical exam I-693
03/01/2009 Negative result on TB skin test
03/04/2009 I-130 received by California Service Center
03/05/2009 Check cashed by USCIS
03/06/2009 Medical Exam form I-693 released by civil surgeon
03/07/2009 NOA Receipt Notice for I-130
03/14/2009 Mailed I-485, I-864, I-693, I-765 & I-131 thru USPS
03/16/2009 "The Package" delivered to Chicago Lockbox
03/16/2009 I-94 expired after 11 months since arrival
03/25/2009 Check cashed by USCIS
03/26/2009 Received NOA for I-485, I-765, I-131
03/28/2009 Received notice for Biometrics Appointment (April 9)
04/02/2009 Approval Notice for I-130 received
04/09/2009 Biometrics done
05/07/2009 Received Advance Parole Document
05/08/2009 Received Interview Letter
05/09/2009 Received EAD card
05/11/2009 Applied for SSN
05/16/2009 Received SSN
06/23/2009 AOS interview approved
06/27/2009 Welcome Letter received
07/05/2009 Green Card received
06/01/2011 Mailed I-751 Form
06/07/2011 Received NOA for I-751
07/11/2011 Biometrics Done

03/19/2015 Mailed N-400

03/30/2015 NOA Received

04/15/2015 Biometrics Appointment

06/23/2015 Interview

07/22/2015 Oath Ceremony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (pnd) Country: Canada
Timeline
With everything being discussed here, it appears that its a lot easier to file for citizenship after getting divorce and then wait for the 5 year rule.

Yes but the OP didn't mention anything about divorce or marrying illegaly for citizenship. It just seems they weren't prepared with the evidence needed. My IO told me a lot of people don't bring much of anything and he has to deny them until they can bring evidence. It's not like people dont' have the documents or evidence, it's just that many don't think they need much.

And yes applying after 5 years on a Green Card will be a lot easier then 3 years based on marriage.

As I said I always filed married, filing single and my IO never questioned that at all. We just didn't own anything at all to benefit from it, plus I had the same job and she had multiple jobs, so my income tax was simple and she would have to get hers professionally done. No biggie.

I never brought her to my interview at all, I was asked where she was and I told them at work. Again not a big issue. This is because I had enough documentation that the IO didn't even want to see the rest of the stuff I brought as he said he had more then enough to accept and pass my interview...

I'm just a wanderer in the desert winds...

Timeline

1997

Oct - Job offer in US

Nov - Received my TN-1 to be authorized to work in the US

Nov - Moved to US

1998-2001

Recieved 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th TN

2002

May - Met future wife at arts fest

Nov - Recieved 6th TN

2003

Nov - Recieved 7th TN

Jul - Our Wedding

Aug - Filed for AOS

Sep - Recieved EAD

Sep - Recieved Advanced Parole

2004

Jan - Interview, accepted for Green Card

Feb - Green Card Arrived in mail

2005

Oct - I-751 sent off

2006

Jan - 10 year Green Card accepted

Mar - 10 year Green Card arrived

Oct - Filed N-400 for Naturalization

Nov - Biometrics done

Nov - Just recieved Naturalization Interview date for Jan.

2007

Jan - Naturalization Interview Completed

Feb - Oath Letter recieved

Feb - Oath Ceremony

Feb 21 - Finally a US CITIZEN (yay)

THE END

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: IR-1/CR-1 Visa Country: Russia
Timeline

Tim,

did your wife wait 5 years before applying for citizenship? That's my impression from your post.

In this case you should not have to prove that you still have a valid marriage.

CR-1 Timeline

March'07 NOA1 date, case transferred to CSC

June'07 NOA2 per USCIS website!

Waiver I-751 timeline

July'09 Check cashed.

Jan'10 10 year GC received.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks for all help and support.

hi tim,

sorry to hear about your situation.i'm just wondering, within that 5 years with your wife, do you have kids?

uglygirl,

nope, not yet, we're still poor, i don't wanna my children running around naked without diapers because their mommy and daddy couldn't afford to buy diapers for them...maybe next year. :)

Tim,

did your wife wait 5 years before applying for citizenship? That's my impression from your post.

In this case you should not have to prove that you still have a valid marriage.

rika60607, she has green card "residence since" Feb, 2006

11/01/2009: Sent I-130 to CHICAGO lockbox for mother

11/10/2009: NOA1 received

07/13/2010: passed interview

09/22/2010: Mother arrived U.S.A

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Citizen (apr) Country: Colombia
Timeline

Have to agree with the AOS and I-751, the N-400 seemed very redundant especially proof of divorce and the marriage certificate, again. Joint finances and common addresses were key with the I-751, the N-400 was like a combination of the AOS and I-751.

Difficult to say about whether filing separately or jointly will give a tax advantage, the standard deduction for filing separately is $5,450, and exactly twice that for filing jointly. Depending upon your income, if low, doesn't make that much difference, if high, combining your incomes may put you in a higher tax bracket. Where the advantage come in with filing jointly is with dependents, we could not deduct our college tuition expenses if filing separately. And make too much for a child tax credit, but would be nice if we were earning less.

But commented, if even filing separately would give us a tax break, wouldn't do it anyway just to keep the USCIS happy. In the State of Wisconsin with our additional high income taxes, definitely to our advantage to file jointly with extra tax breaks. But you can only file jointly state wise if you filed jointly for the feds.

Healthcare is definitely cheaper with a family plan than two single plans and our kid gets a free ride. My auto insurance went down when I added my wife to my policy, guess this figured this young wild guy would finally settle down. Wife felt awkward when I added her to my home deed, did that myself for a ten buck registration fee, attorneys are crazy for what they charge, but that was Nick AND Connie. Also added her to my vehicles, but used Nick OR Connie, saves headaches if either of us should die in trying to sell the vehicles. One friend had a problem with adding his wife, was his bank, mortgage, and the fact they wanted to close out his old loan, charge him closing and refinancing, attorney fees for the deed, and a higher interest rate. They were called in for an interview, but they brought that information from their back and their IO said it was reasonable he didn't add her name.

I brought in a similar letter from my bank explaining they couldn't add my wife because she didn't have an SSN with the APA for our AOS. We fortunately had a very understanding IO and she didn't even want to see it, but suggested we take care of all that stuff before her two year card was about expire.

We also enclosed other legal documents that showed we shared a common address for the UCS interview, and that utility bill as we had a friend that got an RFE because she didn't bring one.

You have to bend over backwards for the USCIS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-3 Visa Country: Philippines
Timeline

hi tim,

Probably that's one of the reasons why that consul doubted your marriage since you guys are married for 5 years.could be or couldnt be the reason, but you know some people can just couldnt get it especially if the wife is foreigner. with my case, we are poor, i think our baby helped for me to pass. i got permanent visa last week even if my hubby and i are only married for 2 years, i'm only in the US for less than a year. and i also believe in luck, you maybe got the hard consul.i'll pray for you guys...tc. and god bless

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thanks for all of your support guys,

for income tax returns, I double check it again, we filed income tax returns as "Separately" in 2006, 2007, but we filed it as "Married Joint together" in 2008 because we had a salon business and it gives us larger deduction.

if my wife get approval for her citizenship, then it is cool, no problem. however, if a denial. I got more than enough money to hire good attorneys to take it to the court. (yep, I choose it a hard way) on my law suit, it will against the interview lady (not USCIS). this is not just for me, but for all other people, who came after me to have a such very hard and weird interview with her.

the intense of my lawsuit will get her az.z fired for wasting everybody's time & money and replacing her with someone else more professionally and more understanding. I understand that she just doing her job and get paid for interview people, but this is really crazy and not acceptable. on my lawsuit also include all the money & expenses for business & every body working at our salon for any business-closing days.

I know I got all evidence that prove my wife and I are a real couple, we work together, live together, home ultility bills and apartment Lease Contract show our address and our name, business is in her name but ultilities bills are in my names..we don't have our names together in bank account because I had bad credit (the bank refuse to open any account for me). Car insurance is also in our names. I even challenge the crazy lady to come to our salon check if we're working toghether and ask our clients if we're a couple or not....or even come to our apartment to check if we live together or not. ...what a mentally crazy lady.

Tim

11/01/2009: Sent I-130 to CHICAGO lockbox for mother

11/10/2009: NOA1 received

07/13/2010: passed interview

09/22/2010: Mother arrived U.S.A

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh, by the way, there are two interview ladies. first one is for U.S. citizenship test, second one is for "adjustication office", that is the label on her door's office, which means she "adjust" the case...

anyway...either way of the outcome, we are really for it

Tim

11/01/2009: Sent I-130 to CHICAGO lockbox for mother

11/10/2009: NOA1 received

07/13/2010: passed interview

09/22/2010: Mother arrived U.S.A

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...