QUOTE(diadromous mermaid @ Feb 14 2008, 11:02 AM)

QUOTE(pushbrk @ Feb 14 2008, 11:37 AM)

QUOTE(diadromous mermaid @ Feb 14 2008, 05:25 AM)

QUOTE(pushbrk @ Oct 31 2007, 03:23 PM)

FYI, one can request a petition be withdrawn but if it has already resulted in a visa and/or green card, a withdrawal request won't release you from the I-864 obligation. Frankly, I don't see such a request having any practical meaning or impact at all after visa/green card issue.
Well, it (the request to withdraw endorsement of a petition for an alien) has a
very practical meaning and purpose if one learns that the alien's sole motivation was to gain PR.
Please, let's not argue. This is an old thread. The petitioner action you refer to entails more than the simple "I-864 withdrawal request" one would make before permanent residence status is granted. Perhaps a discussion of those actions and when they can be relevant would be quite enlightening. If you think such an action is relevant, please provide any advice to the OP, you think will be helpful. My statement is a true one but is not the same as the petitioner actions to which you refer.
I wasn't arguing, thank you. I was correcting your misinformation.
Let's get some facts straight....
QUOTE
FYI, one can request a petition be withdrawn
Yes, that is accurate
QUOTE
but if it has already resulted in a visa and/or green card, a withdrawal request won't release you from the I-864 obligation.
This is not accurate and therefore not true. If a request to withdraw one's endorsement on an alien's petition that resulted in a green card is accepted (in other words accompanied by sufficient substantive evidence to support the request) it will result in the obligation under the I-864 being released.
QUOTE
Frankly, I don't see such a request having any practical meaning or impact at all after visa/green card issue
Inaccurate again. If the alien is conferred status through the marriage-based process, withdrawal of endorsement by the USC petitioner would result in the alien's loss of status, and the petitioner being let off the hook for the Affidavit of Support. Significant impact.
By the way, on a personal note, why is it that if anyone adds to something you've written (note that I didn't state that what you wrote was wrong in my first quote) I simple placed more accurate information around it, you consider that I am arguing? Are you that sure of yourself that you think your word is everything and that if someone doesn't agree with you in totality that they are being impudent? That really bugs me!
I've already explained we're talking about apples and oranges. I'd love to know more about your oranges scenario, but it entails more than a simple "request to withdraw an I-864". It involves something more than ending a relationship which can be done for any number of reasons that would not justify revoking a green card, including just not getting along. It involves evidence and something you refer to as support for a petition. (See, I'm listening and learning.) The apples I'm talking about are well, "apples" and as such the information I've provided about those apples is correct, no matter how different things may be in your orange grove. I love oranges. How do you like them apples?
I couldn't resist the reference to apples, since I'm in my childhood home town today, the "Apple Capital of the World", Wenatchee, WA.
"Apples" = To whom it may concern: I hereby withdraw the I-864 affidavit of support I provided in support of case #xxxx. Thank you.
"Oranges" = Something far more. Please educate us.