I don't think you can learn much from them. I mean what is the point? If you are happy in your marriage and someone else in a similar situation to you breaks up, why would that apply to you? I think the only thing we can do is be there for the person going through the painful breakup. If you are going to apply other peoples situations and experiances to your own marriage, then you will be destined for the same fate.
No two marriage are alike. Don't compare.
No two marriage are alike. Don't compare.
i disagree. just as i've seen convicted burglars educate people on how to better protect their homes, i believe dismissing the input from someone who's engaged in a marriage for benefit like this is quite reckless and premature.
I didn't say I was dismissing anyone's input. But at the same I am not going to apply it to my life. I see it here all the time on VJ. Someone breaks up and then I get messages from people saying "oh Im next because I have this in common with that couple". That is not how to make a marriage work.
Just because one person is being used for someone elses benefit doesnt mean you can label every marriage that way. Many women in mena have had bad relationships in the past and its hard to trust again, however, if you mistrust your spouse because of what happened with someone elses situation then you are doing an injustice to yourself and your marriage. I have seen people ruin a perfectly good relationship/marriage over false accusations.
it's not all about you, jp. said input may help someone else.
Did I say it was about me? Why is it an issue for you when I give my opinion. You disagree, that is fine, but there is no need to make it so personal. This is my opinion thats all.
it mighta been your statement of "I didn't say I was dismissing anyone's input. But at the same I am not going to apply it to my life."
it's not personal jp, calm down. i still hold that *someone* could well benefit from the prior topic.
I stand by my statement. Why would you apply someone else's bad experiance to your marriage? If your marriage is going well what is the point of disrupting it with someone elses bad experiance?
Hypothetically, lets say Nessa had an ex that was liar and cheated on her. How would you feel if dragged that baggage into your marriage? Constantly accusing of things you haven't done just bcz someone else did that to her in the past? What if your neightbor who is was in the military is having an affiar, and Nessa starts accusing you of the same.
Do you get my point? Even more importantly, we only know 1 side of the story and everyones there are 3 sides to every story. When Jackie and Mohammed broke up, everyone went into a frenzy, comparing their relationships to hers and jumping to conclusions. Maybe you can learn something *prior* to getting into a relationship but once you are in one, you can't use someone elses marriage experiances in your own marriage.
