QUOTE(meauxna @ Mar 30 2007, 09:17 PM)

QUOTE(Captain Ewok @ Mar 30 2007, 07:51 PM)

The last point we all agreed on is that the locking of threads should be a last measure and used infrequently. Locking a thread should not be about an ego trip or anything else; it should truly be when a topic has become harmful to the community and not just one persons ego or opinion.
I realize it's a bit of Monday morning quarterbacking as we say here and I'm sorry I couldn't join the chat at that time, but I do have a comment about the above.
I think that you are trying to piecemeal solve the individual complaints that come along, with pieces of solutions. What I still see missing is a definition of this 'community'.
Depending on my mood, I could see 50 threads a day that should be locked, or one. This is nothing to do with my ego, it's to do with how I am perceiving the role of VJ on that given day.
We don't really know what is acceptable behavior here (other than the blatently obvious) and we have very different ideas of it. Rob thinks he should be able to post about Jesus all day and no one should mock him. Andy doesn't like the term 'post whore' and finds it borderline anti-TOS. Lisa thinks there should be as little interference as possible because we're all adults. People make fun of a woman using babelfish to translate her serious question, and it becomes a VJ classic, and I was on the sticking-up-for-her side getting trashed along with her. Members *consistantly* join with false aliases to have fun with made-up posts. Those posts take answers away from people in genuine need. Polite requests are replied to with a STFU (look it up if need be).
One thing you've got to give to the Usenet groups--at least there is a standardized code of behavior, and most people follow it. Silly crap like the above gets pruned out and no one complains. The group is for information. We still make friends, but we keep the group on topic.
When you asked earlier today what exactly it was that people were asking for, I was astounded. I was simply going to go back through the thread and clip the things I had already posted here. You did come back and say you had re-read the entire thread, so I saved the post gathering for another time (never).
You either have one person running everything on this site, or you get members to get emotionally invested in the SITE and its information, not just the outcome of their 'class' or friends. Not a handful of people, a CULTURE of people. The only way people are going to bother with keeping info updated and threads in control is when they CARE about the outcome. You don't have that now, so what you have is one guy doing everything, and it is not enough.
I think that your suggested fixes here will calm everything down for awhile, but I don't think it's going to solve anyone's 'problem' with VJ. A handful of people is not enough to keep this machine running, and I see very few new recruits who want to contribute in what
I think is the appropriate way.
And, I know that that is just
my opinion. I get to make the decisions where I pay the bills.

My impression of this site is:
1.) A place to get immigration suggestions, support and anecdotal, yet skilled experience. This will fall short of legal advice though, be sure of that!
2.) A place with integrity, which has the members respecting each other. Yet disagreement is fully acceptable and appreciated, but with some level of respect. As we all know, this frequently does not happen, and tends to digress into name calling and bashing.
3.) A place where, "out of control threads" are shut down. As this is once again, an immigration forum. Over the top comments and threads are not needed, and do not promote the intent of the site.
I simply offer that additional admin help, limited to the final discretion of the good Captain, would be appropriate.
For those that feel the need to post any freaking thing they want, well, is it really benefiting those immigrating? No, it is not.
Agreed, I have posted a few off topic items, yet I always try to see both sides. If the site will benefit from restraint, why not promote it?
Self analysis is a useful tool; do you find yourself arguing more than helping the potential immigrant? With respect to the much argued post count, in my case, has been helping and supporting others. How about you?