I'm soooo glad you said this, Karen. I've been in the situation in the past when I literally couldn't afford to attend a friend's wedding (more than once, in fact), and have had to think up some less embarrassing excuse than 'I'm too poor' as to why I couldn't go. There have been others, though (especially when for about three years running, I had several friends marrying over the course of a few months), when I've been able to afford (just about) to get myself to whichever far-flung part of the country they're marrying in and to pay for a hotel room for the night, but have SERIOUSLY not had anything to spare to get a gift. I've felt incredibly awkward, and embarrassed, and thought 'should I not go? should I go and send a present later? should I not go, but send a present?', and it's a horrible feeling - it'd be made even worse if I thought my friends would consider me 'rude' for not buying them something off their wedding list.
I can remember one friend who at least had a huge amount of affordable things on her list, but there have been plenty of others where the cheapest gifts have been at least £50 (around $100), and that's just not something I've been able to afford on many occasions. Particularly not when the weddings have involved about as much expense as the average annual holiday, what with the hen weekends (which usually involve flights and hotels), the weddings themselves (even the friends who live near me seem to get married at the other end of the country)... I just don't have several hundred pounds to spend each time someone gets married, and when I've been bombarded with emails from hen night organisers telling me I need to send a cheque for X amount for flights to Barcelona/Dublin/Wherever, and that the hotel will be Y amount, and that by the way, we'll all be chipping in Z amount towards a spa treatment/stripper/whatever for our friend (and when that has happened three times in one year), my main concern tends to be 'how on earth am I going to pay my rent this month?' not 'let me get my hands on that wedding gift list!'
I don't think it's 'rude' as such to send the registry with the wedding invites... I've never been offended by it. But I would say it's made me think 'sh*t, I can't afford to go to this wedding' - and there have been several weddings I've had to RSVP that I'm unable to attend (can't get out of work, you know I'd love to, blah blah), all because I really, really don't have the money. Is the buying of a gift from 'the list' a condition of being invited to the wedding? I'm assuming not, but it can feel like it when you really can't afford to do it!
As I'll be getting married on the other side of the Atlantic from where most of my friends (and of course all my family) live, I would be *so* happy just to see any of them on the day - I certainly won't be expecting presents from anyone. Why should I expect people to buy us things because we're getting married? If people want to be there with us and celebrate with us, that is beyond wonderful - we certainly won't be expecting anything else.
QUOTE(KarenCee @ Jan 16 2007, 02:56 AM)

QUOTE(Henia @ Jan 15 2007, 07:00 PM)

I think not rude, since I know I rather give someone want they need and want then have to guess...and end up being wrong or giving a sucky gift.

But what if the person invited to the wedding couldn't afford to purchase a gift on the registry list? If the bride and groom are tacky enough to think a gift wrong or tacky, then that's bad on their part...and a bit immature. Be thankful that you were thought of at all I say. Just MHO of course.
I wouldn't (and didn't) want our guests to feel beholden to a "list" IF they decided to bring a gift to our wedding...for which we never expected any gifts to begin with...I wasn't brought up that way. We received several nice picture frames...much needed...and very nice photo albums (creative memories style) and a few other nice gifts. I guess that's just my southern upbringing though. I hope I've done my momma proud.