Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: thursday thread
VisaJourney.com > General Discussion Area > Regional Discussion > Middle East and North Africa

Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
peezey
QUOTE(wife_of_mahmoud @ Dec 1 2006, 01:53 PM) *

QUOTE(peezey @ Dec 1 2006, 02:20 PM) *

I guess we need to start a new thread to discuss what makes a Muslim country a Muslim country, because under your standards, Morocco isn't one. Because they use a combination of French provincial law and sharia, you shold definitely inform 99% of the population they do not live in a Muslim country. Then we'd have to move on to Indonesia, Bangladesh, and even India.


Where did you get the idea that "under my standards," Morocco could not be considered a "Muslim country" ??????

There are clear differences between Morocco and Lebanon -- in fact you just typed out a major one yourself: Morocco uses a combination of French provincial law and sharia. In contrast, Lebanon does not use sharia at all.

Also, Morocco does not have a sizeable minority of non-Muslims -- only about 1% of Morocco’s population is Christian, and only about .02% are Jewish. But in Lebanon, nearly 40% of the population is Christian, and by law, Christians are guaranteed a certain amount of representation in the Lebanese government.

So, due to its overwhelmingly Muslim population and its inclusion of Islamic principles in its laws, I would have to say that Morocco certainly should be considered a “Muslim country.”


Ok, then I am confused about what you consider defines a Muslim country. Please explain what makes one such.
charles!
QUOTE(peezey @ Dec 1 2006, 12:56 PM) *

QUOTE(wife_of_mahmoud @ Dec 1 2006, 01:53 PM) *

QUOTE(peezey @ Dec 1 2006, 02:20 PM) *

I guess we need to start a new thread to discuss what makes a Muslim country a Muslim country, because under your standards, Morocco isn't one. Because they use a combination of French provincial law and sharia, you shold definitely inform 99% of the population they do not live in a Muslim country. Then we'd have to move on to Indonesia, Bangladesh, and even India.


Where did you get the idea that "under my standards," Morocco could not be considered a "Muslim country" ??????

There are clear differences between Morocco and Lebanon -- in fact you just typed out a major one yourself: Morocco uses a combination of French provincial law and sharia. In contrast, Lebanon does not use sharia at all.

Also, Morocco does not have a sizeable minority of non-Muslims -- only about 1% of Morocco’s population is Christian, and only about .02% are Jewish. But in Lebanon, nearly 40% of the population is Christian, and by law, Christians are guaranteed a certain amount of representation in the Lebanese government.

So, due to its overwhelmingly Muslim population and its inclusion of Islamic principles in its laws, I would have to say that Morocco certainly should be considered a “Muslim country.”


Ok, then I am confused about what you consider defines a Muslim country. Please explain what makes one such.

http://www.visajourney.com/forums/index.ph...mp;#entry598246
good idea, btw, for such a thread topic.
wife_of_mahmoud
QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 1 2006, 02:25 PM) *

QUOTE(wife_of_mahmoud @ Dec 1 2006, 12:19 PM) *


*You* are the one that cited the article as a reference point for your theory of an imminent change in the Lebanese legal system.

My question is: how are you drawing that conclusion based on the article you posted ?

Sorry it was over your head. jest.gif

oh let's see. perhaps you missed these parts........

-Hezbollah, Lebanon's most powerful Shi'ite Muslim group, and its pro-Syrian allies had called on Lebanese from across the country to take part in the protest (i'm sure they are doing that just because they are nice guys and have no plans for lebanon)

-Large numbers of security forces, backed by armored troop carriers, were deployed. Scores of soldiers, using barbed wire and metal barriers, cordoned off the complex housing the government's offices in downtown Beirut. (this sounds to me like civil war might occur - again)

and why is this going on?
-Hezbollah has been at loggerheads with Siniora's government over what it says was its failure to back the group during the July-August war with Israel.

so let's see........Hezbollah, Lebanon's most powerful Shi'ite Muslim group - Hezbollah, which is backed by Syria and Iran - what exactly do you think they will stand to gain from this deal? just replacing the govenment, or replacing the government with hezbollah members? i'd vote for the latter. and hence my remarks about the pending change....... wink.gif


There is nothing in this article that pertains to wanting to "change the Lebanese legal system."

You have listed a lot of snippets about Hezbollah protesting or making demands that the Siniora administration resign or be replaced, but that's not the same thing as changing the laws of the country.

So again... this article does not support your conclusion.


QUOTE(peezey @ Dec 1 2006, 02:56 PM) *

Ok, then I am confused about what you consider defines a Muslim country. Please explain what makes one such.


I see there's a new topic to discuss this question. Let me read it and catch up before I respond over there.
mybackpages
QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 1 2006, 12:04 PM) *
that long list of lebanon legal system above might be revised soon, was my point. sorry it was over your head.




uh-ohIPB Image

amal
QUOTE(mybackpages @ Dec 1 2006, 03:37 PM) *

QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 1 2006, 12:04 PM) *
that long list of lebanon legal system above might be revised soon, was my point. sorry it was over your head.




uh-ohIPB Image

i agree
charles!
QUOTE(wife_of_mahmoud @ Dec 1 2006, 03:29 PM) *

QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 1 2006, 02:25 PM) *

QUOTE(wife_of_mahmoud @ Dec 1 2006, 12:19 PM) *


*You* are the one that cited the article as a reference point for your theory of an imminent change in the Lebanese legal system.

My question is: how are you drawing that conclusion based on the article you posted ?

Sorry it was over your head. jest.gif

oh let's see. perhaps you missed these parts........

-Hezbollah, Lebanon's most powerful Shi'ite Muslim group, and its pro-Syrian allies had called on Lebanese from across the country to take part in the protest (i'm sure they are doing that just because they are nice guys and have no plans for lebanon)

-Large numbers of security forces, backed by armored troop carriers, were deployed. Scores of soldiers, using barbed wire and metal barriers, cordoned off the complex housing the government's offices in downtown Beirut. (this sounds to me like civil war might occur - again)

and why is this going on?
-Hezbollah has been at loggerheads with Siniora's government over what it says was its failure to back the group during the July-August war with Israel.

so let's see........Hezbollah, Lebanon's most powerful Shi'ite Muslim group - Hezbollah, which is backed by Syria and Iran - what exactly do you think they will stand to gain from this deal? just replacing the govenment, or replacing the government with hezbollah members? i'd vote for the latter. and hence my remarks about the pending change....... wink.gif


There is nothing in this article that pertains to wanting to "change the Lebanese legal system."

You have listed a lot of snippets about Hezbollah protesting or making demands that the Siniora administration resign or be replaced, but that's not the same thing as changing the laws of the country.

So again... this article does not support your conclusion.


ok, since you you're so brilliant.......just what, pray tell, do you think is hezbollah's agenda then in starting such unrest? do you think they (hezbollah) won't benefit from the downfall of lebanon's current government in such a way that they won't have more power there? do you really expect them (hezbollah) not to institute some changes to what the current mode of their legal system? i honestly foresee some changes in the wind.........
morocco4ever
eb0dfafc.gif

Friday entertainment for the discriminating taste.....
melly
Soooo... it's currently 50 degrees here. It was a nippy 34 when I woke up this morning but it looks to be heating up by Tuesday morning to 37!! Watch out for that tropical weather huh? tongue.gif
Maggie724
QUOTE(Morocco4ever @ Dec 1 2006, 06:22 PM) *

eb0dfafc.gif

Friday entertainment for the discriminating taste.....


It was bound to happen after two days of talking about nothing but the weather tongue.gif Thankfully it is almost the end of the day, and someone can start a new thread!!
cbd2cai
QUOTE(maggieNomar @ Dec 1 2006, 09:46 PM) *

QUOTE(Morocco4ever @ Dec 1 2006, 06:22 PM) *

eb0dfafc.gif

Friday entertainment for the discriminating taste.....


It was bound to happen after two days of talking about nothing but the weather tongue.gif Thankfully it is almost the end of the day, and someone can start a new thread!!


LOL, this is the Thursday thread that ppl aren't letting go of!! The Friday thread has been sorely neglected today! tongue.gif
wife_of_mahmoud
QUOTE(cbd2cai @ Dec 2 2006, 01:22 AM) *

LOL, this is the Thursday thread that ppl aren't letting go of!! The Friday thread has been sorely neglected today! tongue.gif


Hahha why is it always the Thursday threads that go like this.....
wife_of_mahmoud
QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 1 2006, 09:28 PM) *

ok, since you you're so brilliant.......just what, pray tell, do you think is hezbollah's agenda then in starting such unrest? do you think they (hezbollah) won't benefit from the downfall of lebanon's current government in such a way that they won't have more power there? do you really expect them (hezbollah) not to institute some changes to what the current mode of their legal system? i honestly foresee some changes in the wind.........


Well I never claimed to be so brilliant huh.gif but if you think so, then thanks... I guess....

What does Hezbollah want ? They have been pretty up front about it -- I mean, they hold rallies, they have a TV station, a newspaper, and a website -- this info is all easily available to you on the internet.

But basically -- they want the current government of Lebanon to step down and be replaced by a national unity government. They have a website if you want to read it in their own words (translated into English) -- it's at http://www.hizbollah.org/

You haven't come out and said it, but your concern seems to be that Hezbollah would want to turn Lebanon into an Islamic state or establish Shari'a law, by force. Hassan Nasrallah has stated:

QUOTE
We believe the requirement for an Islamic state is to have an overwhelming popular desire, and we're not talking about fifty percent plus one, but a large majority. And this is not available in Lebanon and probably never will be.

http://www.counterpunch.org/kfoury10022006.html

By the way this entire article about Nasrallah from Counterpunch is very insightful -- it might answer a lot of people's questions.
charles!
QUOTE(wife_of_mahmoud @ Dec 3 2006, 10:15 PM) *

QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 1 2006, 09:28 PM) *

ok, since you you're so brilliant.......just what, pray tell, do you think is hezbollah's agenda then in starting such unrest? do you think they (hezbollah) won't benefit from the downfall of lebanon's current government in such a way that they won't have more power there? do you really expect them (hezbollah) not to institute some changes to what the current mode of their legal system? i honestly foresee some changes in the wind.........


Well I never claimed to be so brilliant huh.gif but if you think so, then thanks... I guess....

What does Hezbollah want ? They have been pretty up front about it -- I mean, they hold rallies, they have a TV station, a newspaper, and a website -- this info is all easily available to you on the internet.

But basically -- they want the current government of Lebanon to step down and be replaced by a national unity government. They have a website if you want to read it in their own words (translated into English) -- it's at http://www.hizbollah.org/

You haven't come out and said it, but your concern seems to be that Hezbollah would want to turn Lebanon into an Islamic state or establish Shari'a law, by force. Hassan Nasrallah has stated:

QUOTE
We believe the requirement for an Islamic state is to have an overwhelming popular desire, and we're not talking about fifty percent plus one, but a large majority. And this is not available in Lebanon and probably never will be.

http://www.counterpunch.org/kfoury10022006.html

By the way this entire article about Nasrallah from Counterpunch is very insightful -- it might answer a lot of people's questions.

and do you believe hizbollah when they say that? i don't. no0pb.gif
sarah and hicham
Charles, you've put up a good fight. Trust me, you can't win.
~*Dorothy*~
QUOTE(sarah and hicham @ Dec 4 2006, 02:31 PM) *

Charles, you've put up a good fight. Trust me, you can't win.


Sarah...must say that i love that picture of the two of you...such an adorable couple...

D.
sarah and hicham
QUOTE(Lost in NY @ Dec 4 2006, 11:39 AM) *

QUOTE(sarah and hicham @ Dec 4 2006, 02:31 PM) *

Charles, you've put up a good fight. Trust me, you can't win.


Sarah...must say that i love that picture of the two of you...such an adorable couple...

D.



Thank you, that's very sweet of you! rose.gif
charles!
QUOTE(sarah and hicham @ Dec 4 2006, 01:31 PM) *

Charles, you've put up a good fight. Trust me, you can't win.

i just can't see how an organization that is supported by iran and syria is going to be "helpful" to the local population.........it's only logical that hezbollah would have an agenda different from what is best for the country.
sarah and hicham
QUOTE(charlesandnessa @ Dec 4 2006, 11:41 AM) *

QUOTE(sarah and hicham @ Dec 4 2006, 01:31 PM) *

Charles, you've put up a good fight. Trust me, you can't win.

i just can't see how an organization that is supported by iran and syria is going to be "helpful" to the local population.........it's only logical that hezbollah would have an agenda different from what is best for the country.


I know but it's not worth the argument with certain people, trust me.
noura
can this thread also be put to rest now? thank u all very much! wink.gif
peezey
QUOTE(noura @ Dec 4 2006, 05:25 PM) *

can this thread also be put to rest now? thank u all very much! wink.gif



Ok, I started a new topic thread so this important discussion isn't lost in Thursday's thread.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.