hi,ok this is my problem.my husband and i have been married for12 years.i am a usc and when we got married he got his citizenship from me and we lived happily ever after......until....my sister married his brother...not for america but because they fell in love...anyway after that,hell broke loose and they didnt get along.she had brought him to the us after they got married and they lived together here for about 1 year and 8 months,then they got a divorce.since then he has gotten a temporary green card and now it has expired and he made an appointment in the immigration and they told him his case has been denied because there is no proof that it was a bonafide marraige because he wouldnt get her pregnant.so the immigration lawyer told him that he could appeal,but he needed witnesses that it was a bonafide marraige.both my husband and i are going to be his witnesses that it was indeed a real marraige.please tell me....what do you think is going to happen?im so stressed out thinking about this.its tearing our families apart.thanks.

Was the I-751 ever filed?


It is pretty weird that INS would deny him *only* because there were no children. What are we missing out on?


Don't they have any other evidence at all, other than two people ready to testify?

He received the conditional GC after they were divorced? So did he arrive on a K3? Were they still married when and if they were interviewed for Adjustment of Status?

Something doesn't add up. Not impregnating one's spouse is not a valid ground for denial. If they were only living together for 1 yr 8 months, and he arrived on a K3, then they were married how long before he applied for adjustment of status? And if his card has since expired, yes, I agree with Wild's question, did he apply to remove conditions on his GC before the deadline? If divorced, the alien can apply right away under any one or all of the waiver requirements.

1) Your husband's brother has an immigration attorney -- he should listen to his attorney.

2) If your husband's brother is interested in other opinions, he should consult with another immigration attorney.

3) You have not provided any actual useful information here, not sure how we laypersons can offer even an uneducated guess. If you want some uneducated guesses, try giving us a complete timeline of everything that was filed, approved, and/or denied, along with details on any decisions handed down, who it was handed down by, when, etc.

Just out of curiosity, what do you mean by "he wouldn't get her pregnant"? He refused to have sex with her and the marriage was never "consummated"?