Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Visa Denial contested...same day
VisaJourney.com > General Discussion Area > Regional Discussion > Philippines

JeffnBhing
We both went to the interview last Wednesday 18th and as I guessed it, arrogant americans working there. At the first interview I am sure the lady decided to deny the visa within the first minute as she turned the light on for the next person almost immediately after Bing entered the room. I do not have enough income. blink.gif

Sure enough at window 36 another lady called our number and announced that we were denied the visa because Bing would become a public charge... I stepped up to the plate and told her of assets and house etc, she announced the papers were irrelevant without a deed, etc etc etc. I insisted she forward the information to someone in a higher position and she did. mad.gif

Window 33 a man called Bings name and we both went there. I again explained that I have assets in excess of whats needed, he asked if anyone asked to review the documents and I told him None asked. I produced more documents, bank deposits, house statements etc and he added things up and was still in question until he asked a knowledgeable Filipino man that clearly said that I have adequate funds and to reverse the denial in the computer. good.gif

The funny thing about it all is since it was decided at the first interview a denial, the rest of the paperwork was not looked at closely. I suppose it would have been reviewed when the visa denial was contested sometime in the future but since it was contested the same day it was not. The I-134 was not signed, employer letter not reviewed, paperwork not looked into. Only thing reviewed during the day after the first interview was bank statements and house statement and tax bill.... The man looked like he was embarrassed that he was unsure how to proceed with a case such as ours.

Low income and no co-sponsor... no biggie. I knew this would be an issue that Bing alone would not know how to contest and planned to fly for the interview. 3 weeks notice made it hard to get things in order but I did. Too bad none of it was looked at LOL whistling.gif

All that is needed is the stamp indicating PDOS was completed (not open today) and we are good to go back to the US on Thursday... What a hectic few weeks we have both been through. I am glad this is almost completed after all this time.

kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif
hannyperez
QUOTE(JeffnBhing @ Jun 24 2008, 10:23 AM) *
We both went to the interview last Wednesday 18th and as I guessed it, arrogant americans working there. At the first interview I am sure the lady decided to deny the visa within the first minute as she turned the light on for the next person almost immediately after Bing entered the room. I do not have enough income. blink.gif

Sure enough at window 36 another lady called our number and announced that we were denied the visa because Bing would become a public charge... I stepped up to the plate and told her of assets and house etc, she announced the papers were irrelevant without a deed, etc etc etc. I insisted she forward the information to someone in a higher position and she did. mad.gif

Window 33 a man called Bings name and we both went there. I again explained that I have assets in excess of whats needed, he asked if anyone asked to review the documents and I told him None asked. I produced more documents, bank deposits, house statements etc and he added things up and was still in question until he asked a knowledgeable Filipino man that clearly said that I have adequate funds and to reverse the denial in the computer. good.gif

The funny thing about it all is since it was decided at the first interview a denial, the rest of the paperwork was not looked at closely. I suppose it would have been reviewed when the visa denial was contested sometime in the future but since it was contested the same day it was not. The I-134 was not signed, employer letter not reviewed, paperwork not looked into. Only thing reviewed during the day after the first interview was bank statements and house statement and tax bill.... The man looked like he was embarrassed that he was unsure how to proceed with a case such as ours.

Low income and no co-sponsor... no biggie. I knew this would be an issue that Bing alone would not know how to contest and planned to fly for the interview. 3 weeks notice made it hard to get things in order but I did. Too bad none of it was looked at LOL whistling.gif

All that is needed is the stamp indicating PDOS was completed (not open today) and we are good to go back to the US on Thursday... What a hectic few weeks we have both been through. I am glad this is almost completed after all this time.

kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif



wow! this is an amazing experience! but im glad everything is ok now! if it was jsut ur fiancee there i don't think they would even reconsider! good thing u were there! congratulations! and have a safe trip!
john & jean
THAT IS GREAT NEWS, I AM PROUD TO SEE ANYONE THERE WHO WILL STAND UP FOR WHAT'S RIGHT!!
BEST WISHES
john&Jean good.gif
RyaNRiza
It's a wise decision that you accompanied her. Congratulations, you made it!!! good.gif
Haole
Obviously your lady would have been "hung out to dry" if you hadn't been there.
I've always recommended the petitioner attend the interview even tho many say it's not necessary.
You made a GOOD move. LOTS of guys are still kicking themselves in the puwit for not attending!
Looks like you asked to pick up the visa also?
DARUMA07
Congratulations on your Approval! kicking.gif Perserverence always pays off.... You both have a safe flight and Bhing " Welcome to the USA"....
honey_me
wow... smile.gif . Good luck and Hapi trip..
o0pink0o
good thing you were with your lady good.gif Congratulations! kicking.gif kicking.gif
KC♥MP
Congratulations!!! kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif . It's worth the trip to go there and accompany her during the interview good.gif . A safe trip to both of you.
archie07
good.gif
AnneiyAndJacky
You are very lucky and congratulations! I was in the same situation before. My hubby was still a student at that time and our sponsor was his mom. I initially got denied too! On the day of my interview, they told me that my hubby and his family cant afford to bring me the US yet cuz the income that they've presented wasnt enough. So they denied me as likely become a public charge. Even though, I insisted my hubby's familys assets, like the fully paid house. But they didnt consider it too! I went out the embassy on that day crying! i thought i had to go through to another new applications/petition. In my case, my hubby had to find work immedietly so we could present his income. So after 3months i went back to embassy. And we submitted all the docs that we could present, after 3weeks i got my visa without another or second interview. That was the only time i felt so relief. Good Luck on your journey and God Bless!





QUOTE(JeffnBhing @ Jun 24 2008, 10:23 AM) *
We both went to the interview last Wednesday 18th and as I guessed it, arrogant americans working there. At the first interview I am sure the lady decided to deny the visa within the first minute as she turned the light on for the next person almost immediately after Bing entered the room. I do not have enough income. blink.gif

Sure enough at window 36 another lady called our number and announced that we were denied the visa because Bing would become a public charge... I stepped up to the plate and told her of assets and house etc, she announced the papers were irrelevant without a deed, etc etc etc. I insisted she forward the information to someone in a higher position and she did. mad.gif

Window 33 a man called Bings name and we both went there. I again explained that I have assets in excess of whats needed, he asked if anyone asked to review the documents and I told him None asked. I produced more documents, bank deposits, house statements etc and he added things up and was still in question until he asked a knowledgeable Filipino man that clearly said that I have adequate funds and to reverse the denial in the computer. good.gif

The funny thing about it all is since it was decided at the first interview a denial, the rest of the paperwork was not looked at closely. I suppose it would have been reviewed when the visa denial was contested sometime in the future but since it was contested the same day it was not. The I-134 was not signed, employer letter not reviewed, paperwork not looked into. Only thing reviewed during the day after the first interview was bank statements and house statement and tax bill.... The man looked like he was embarrassed that he was unsure how to proceed with a case such as ours.

Low income and no co-sponsor... no biggie. I knew this would be an issue that Bing alone would not know how to contest and planned to fly for the interview. 3 weeks notice made it hard to get things in order but I did. Too bad none of it was looked at LOL whistling.gif

All that is needed is the stamp indicating PDOS was completed (not open today) and we are good to go back to the US on Thursday... What a hectic few weeks we have both been through. I am glad this is almost completed after all this time.

kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif

CaNdiD wiTcH
wohoooo!! such an experience!!!
congratulations... have a safe trip.. God bless..
chris-lei
Hi there! that was a nice story. good thing you planned on being with her on the interview. if she was alone, i dont want to think of the possible things your fiancee might have heard. well, congratulations and have a wonderful life! kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif
estadia



wow congratulations im glad u got it thru kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif
I luv my chappara
wow congratulations
have a safe trip
fitzee21
QUOTE(JeffnBhing @ Jun 23 2008, 09:23 PM) *
We both went to the interview last Wednesday 18th and as I guessed it, arrogant americans working there. At the first interview I am sure the lady decided to deny the visa within the first minute as she turned the light on for the next person almost immediately after Bing entered the room. I do not have enough income. blink.gif

Sure enough at window 36 another lady called our number and announced that we were denied the visa because Bing would become a public charge... I stepped up to the plate and told her of assets and house etc, she announced the papers were irrelevant without a deed, etc etc etc. I insisted she forward the information to someone in a higher position and she did. mad.gif

Window 33 a man called Bings name and we both went there. I again explained that I have assets in excess of whats needed, he asked if anyone asked to review the documents and I told him None asked. I produced more documents, bank deposits, house statements etc and he added things up and was still in question until he asked a knowledgeable Filipino man that clearly said that I have adequate funds and to reverse the denial in the computer. good.gif

The funny thing about it all is since it was decided at the first interview a denial, the rest of the paperwork was not looked at closely. I suppose it would have been reviewed when the visa denial was contested sometime in the future but since it was contested the same day it was not. The I-134 was not signed, employer letter not reviewed, paperwork not looked into. Only thing reviewed during the day after the first interview was bank statements and house statement and tax bill.... The man looked like he was embarrassed that he was unsure how to proceed with a case such as ours.

Low income and no co-sponsor... no biggie. I knew this would be an issue that Bing alone would not know how to contest and planned to fly for the interview. 3 weeks notice made it hard to get things in order but I did. Too bad none of it was looked at LOL whistling.gif

All that is needed is the stamp indicating PDOS was completed (not open today) and we are good to go back to the US on Thursday... What a hectic few weeks we have both been through. I am glad this is almost completed after all this time.

kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif

That is so awesome! Way to show them!
Oh, and congrats! good.gif
bevs
congrats even u had a hard time for that, then good thing u made it through. u both have a safe trip and GOD bless u both.
David-Mae Forever
That's one unforgettable experience for you and Bhing. Glad to know that you're able to contest the denial and granted the visa. May your life together be blessed with more graces. Have a safe flight to US!

--Mae
patiently waiting
CONGRATULATIONS TO BOTH OF YOU
edp333
Congrats!! I am glad to hear you stood up for what is right and got it the confussion straightened out.

It has been posted on this forum before that the USEM does not look at assets; like they should do.
shes
QUOTE(hannyperez @ Jun 23 2008, 09:31 PM) *
QUOTE(JeffnBhing @ Jun 24 2008, 10:23 AM) *
We both went to the interview last Wednesday 18th and as I guessed it, arrogant americans working there. At the first interview I am sure the lady decided to deny the visa within the first minute as she turned the light on for the next person almost immediately after Bing entered the room. I do not have enough income. blink.gif

Sure enough at window 36 another lady called our number and announced that we were denied the visa because Bing would become a public charge... I stepped up to the plate and told her of assets and house etc, she announced the papers were irrelevant without a deed, etc etc etc. I insisted she forward the information to someone in a higher position and she did. mad.gif

Window 33 a man called Bings name and we both went there. I again explained that I have assets in excess of whats needed, he asked if anyone asked to review the documents and I told him None asked. I produced more documents, bank deposits, house statements etc and he added things up and was still in question until he asked a knowledgeable Filipino man that clearly said that I have adequate funds and to reverse the denial in the computer. good.gif

The funny thing about it all is since it was decided at the first interview a denial, the rest of the paperwork was not looked at closely. I suppose it would have been reviewed when the visa denial was contested sometime in the future but since it was contested the same day it was not. The I-134 was not signed, employer letter not reviewed, paperwork not looked into. Only thing reviewed during the day after the first interview was bank statements and house statement and tax bill.... The man looked like he was embarrassed that he was unsure how to proceed with a case such as ours.

Low income and no co-sponsor... no biggie. I knew this would be an issue that Bing alone would not know how to contest and planned to fly for the interview. 3 weeks notice made it hard to get things in order but I did. Too bad none of it was looked at LOL whistling.gif

All that is needed is the stamp indicating PDOS was completed (not open today) and we are good to go back to the US on Thursday... What a hectic few weeks we have both been through. I am glad this is almost completed after all this time.

kicking.gif kicking.gif kicking.gif



wow! this is an amazing experience! but im glad everything is ok now! if it was jsut ur fiancee there i don't think they would even reconsider! good thing u were there! congratulations! and have a safe trip!

wow! wat an experience..but how do they know that the beneficiary will be a public charge??? what wud be the criteria then..hhmm....i might make a new thread for that
Ray and Geraldyn
WOW...good thing you decided to be there with her yes.gif
Good luck to both of you with your life together good.gif
jom
In the end "KAYO AND NAGWAGI" ( you won ) smile.gif

Congratulations!!
ronjie
congrat's, i will surely learn from your experience... thank you and have a safe trip!!!!!!
JeffnBhing
In all the emotional sleepless madness we forgot to take the Immigration documents out of the suitcase and realized it as it slipped beyond the black rubber straps of the conveyor not to be seen until arrival. Bhing worried the whole brutal trip about it and I reassured her that she should be worried tongue.gif

Upon arrival I explained to an officer that she needed her papers before she could go to immigration and he told us to explain it to the man at entry, he said go to US citizen check in and they should help us. We did, they told Bhing had to wait tin the back as I went to find the luggage with the documents. While waiting I hear this sweet voice next to me saying theres the suitcase with the papers...they let her out to help look for it with me... how she got out I wondered. Anyways she got paperwork and disappeared into the abyss again as I searched for the rest of the luggage.

About 10 minutes later again I hear her voice saying that she thinks she sees the rest of the luggage, I asked how she got out, she told me she is done... what? She said they entered stuff into the computer and welcomed her to America... wow.

Luggage in hand we proceed to the declaration point and inspection of luggage, handed the slips to a lady who told us to proceed. There was a area that said customs inspection and outbound flights.... I saw a sign that said enter Detroit and we opted to go through them doors...went through and was in general population, surely this is wrong, no? Went to the 2nd level and out to my car, loaded up and home we are.

I knew we didn't have anything to worry about even though the paperwork was not handy but this was way too easy. WAY too easy, I don't know what and where I messed up but it slid through so easily and without incident I still have a hard time believing how this day has transpired.

Watching her reactions after we arrived at home (home now not just my house) Bhing couldn't sleep more than 30 minutes while I took full advantage and got 6 hours sleep. I can not imagine all the things that must be going through her head right now. I couldn't imagine what it is like to be her at this time. All I can promise her is that I will be here and help her with anything and everything that I can.

Tomorrow for me will bring the regular manatony of the stock markets and printing after that closes in an effort to perpetuate my income-less future, Bhing has already made the daily things I depend on being handy disappear into a pre organization effort. She says my house is so dirty...LMAO If she only saw it 4 weeks ago before me and my son spent weeks cleaning and organizing.

I think in her mind is a thousand things going on but as I write this and think, I realize that my mind is thinking thousands of things also. In the pre-departure restaurant meal with her family and the ensuing interrogation I had just realized why I have waited and gone through this Visa Journey for Bhing, I have treated many women well but have not ever had the chance to treat a good woman well. This will be the beginning of a new life for both of us, and I have promised to do as I will never change who I am, be me and trust and honor again a woman who has had me wait and stand the test of time. I believe in destiny and I am living it now.
AllRightsReserved
Just happen to read such a learning interview experience.

Congratulations!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.