Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Go to war
VisaJourney.com > General Family Based Immigration Topics > US Citizenship General Discussion

feejo
I read that because of religion one can tell because his religion believes he can avoid going to war if USA is in war, what are they, is a Catholic apply for that. I mean in the commend it say "Do not kill"?
Staashi
QUOTE(feejo @ May 16 2008, 09:08 AM) *
I read that because of religion one can tell because his religion believes he can avoid going to war if USA is in war, what are they, is a Catholic apply for that. I mean in the commend it say "Do not kill"?


Actually, it is normally Jehovah's Witnesses who are exempt from going to war. Oddly enough, us Catholics have been known for war...just remember the Crusades, etc. If you take up the oath of the US and they declare war, you are obligated to fight...probably won't ever happen, but that is what the oath means.

Good Luck! good.gif
john_and_marlene
QUOTE(Staashi @ May 16 2008, 08:45 AM) *
If you take up the oath of the US and they declare war, you are obligated to fight...probably won't ever happen, but that is what the oath means.


Only if they ever rely on a draft again which hasn't been used for a long time.
NickD
The term is "conscious objector"

http://www.militaryfreeschools.org/conscienceobject.htm

Tells you how to become one, from previous experience, calling yourself a conscious objector does not void you from the draft, but may put you in a non-combative position such as in supply or as a medic. Actually only a small percentage of our military was put on the front lines, most were involved with support. For example if you joined the Navy and aboard an aircraft carrier with 6,000 other mates, only about one hundred of those are pilots that are subjected to risk in today's Navy. The marines are a different story where occupation is very hazardous to your health, even more hazardous than smoking a cigarette if you can believe that.

When I was drafted and my brothers, first thing they did was to divide us up by religion, that was on our dog tags, I just happened to be Roman Catholic at the time so was under a Roman Catholic Chaplin. Not a very long speech, just forget about what you were taught for the last 18 years, and it's okay to kill for your country. My closest buddies were in the military and we still stay in contact, can't say that about high school, college, or work. And if someone is kills or wounds your buddy, believe me, you don't have any problems shooting back.

And if we are attacked by terrorists, don't believe you will have any problems shooting back either if they are trying to kill your wife and kids. Providing they don't take our guns away, then you will have to throw stones. Or maybe just get on your knees and pray.
feejo
QUOTE(NickD @ May 16 2008, 10:53 AM) *
The term is "conscious objector"

http://www.militaryfreeschools.org/conscienceobject.htm

Tells you how to become one, from previous experience, calling yourself a conscious objector does not void you from the draft, but may put you in a non-combative position such as in supply or as a medic. Actually only a small percentage of our military was put on the front lines, most were involved with support. For example if you joined the Navy and aboard an aircraft carrier with 6,000 other mates, only about one hundred of those are pilots that are subjected to risk in today's Navy. The marines are a different story where occupation is very hazardous to your health, even more hazardous than smoking a cigarette if you can believe that.

When I was drafted and my brothers, first thing they did was to divide us up by religion, that was on our dog tags, I just happened to be Roman Catholic at the time so was under a Roman Catholic Chaplin. Not a very long speech, just forget about what you were taught for the last 18 years, and it's okay to kill for your country. My closest buddies were in the military and we still stay in contact, can't say that about high school, college, or work. And if someone is kills or wounds your buddy, believe me, you don't have any problems shooting back.

And if we are attacked by terrorists, don't believe you will have any problems shooting back either if they are trying to kill your wife and kids. Providing they don't take our guns away, then you will have to throw stones. Or maybe just get on your knees and pray.


I will chose the most powerfull one, the last you said. Pen is mother than the sword, so do prayers. Thanks for the link.
NickD
Actually, it's, "The pen is mightier than the sword."

But this can be taken two ways: blush.gif

He who fights with a pen will get ink on his opponent.

He who writes with a sword will cut his paper.

zyggy
QUOTE(NickD @ May 16 2008, 07:53 AM) *
The term is "conscious objector"

http://www.militaryfreeschools.org/conscienceobject.htm

Tells you how to become one, from previous experience, calling yourself a conscious objector does not void you from the draft, but may put you in a non-combative position such as in supply or as a medic. Actually only a small percentage of our military was put on the front lines, most were involved with support. For example if you joined the Navy and aboard an aircraft carrier with 6,000 other mates, only about one hundred of those are pilots that are subjected to risk in today's Navy. The marines are a different story where occupation is very hazardous to your health, even more hazardous than smoking a cigarette if you can believe that.

When I was drafted and my brothers, first thing they did was to divide us up by religion, that was on our dog tags, I just happened to be Roman Catholic at the time so was under a Roman Catholic Chaplin. Not a very long speech, just forget about what you were taught for the last 18 years, and it's okay to kill for your country. My closest buddies were in the military and we still stay in contact, can't say that about high school, college, or work. And if someone is kills or wounds your buddy, believe me, you don't have any problems shooting back.

And if we are attacked by terrorists, don't believe you will have any problems shooting back either if they are trying to kill your wife and kids. Providing they don't take our guns away, then you will have to throw stones. Or maybe just get on your knees and pray.


The principle for a fighting a just war against evil comes from the some portions of the Bible (especially the Old Testament) and was particilarly articulated for Catholics in St. Augustine's City of God.

I am on a Draft Board.. if you are truly a conscientious objector against all war and violence and have lived your life in that manner, then you can present your evidence and your case to the board, if successful you will be asked if you would be willing to participate as a non-combatant in the armed services (a medic for example) or if you do not wish to served in the armed service at all, you will be placed in a civil service position. If you are only opposed to a particilar war for political or other reasons, then your request will be denied.
feejo
QUOTE(zyggy @ May 16 2008, 01:20 PM) *
QUOTE(NickD @ May 16 2008, 07:53 AM) *
The term is "conscious objector"

http://www.militaryfreeschools.org/conscienceobject.htm

Tells you how to become one, from previous experience, calling yourself a conscious objector does not void you from the draft, but may put you in a non-combative position such as in supply or as a medic. Actually only a small percentage of our military was put on the front lines, most were involved with support. For example if you joined the Navy and aboard an aircraft carrier with 6,000 other mates, only about one hundred of those are pilots that are subjected to risk in today's Navy. The marines are a different story where occupation is very hazardous to your health, even more hazardous than smoking a cigarette if you can believe that.

When I was drafted and my brothers, first thing they did was to divide us up by religion, that was on our dog tags, I just happened to be Roman Catholic at the time so was under a Roman Catholic Chaplin. Not a very long speech, just forget about what you were taught for the last 18 years, and it's okay to kill for your country. My closest buddies were in the military and we still stay in contact, can't say that about high school, college, or work. And if someone is kills or wounds your buddy, believe me, you don't have any problems shooting back.

And if we are attacked by terrorists, don't believe you will have any problems shooting back either if they are trying to kill your wife and kids. Providing they don't take our guns away, then you will have to throw stones. Or maybe just get on your knees and pray.


The principle for a fighting a just war against evil comes from the some portions of the Bible (especially the Old Testament) and was particilarly articulated for Catholics in St. Augustine's City of God.

I am on a Draft Board.. if you are truly a conscientious objector against all war and violence and have lived your life in that manner, then you can present your evidence and your case to the board, if successful you will be asked if you would be willing to participate as a non-combatant in the armed services (a medic for example) or if you do not wish to served in the armed service at all, you will be placed in a civil service position. If you are only opposed to a particilar war for political or other reasons, then your request will be denied.


Spiritual fight is more inportant, and amos are prayers. Like Fatima: peace will not come until people turn to my immaculated hearth. Peace can only come from a desire into the prayer, a good exemple is Martin L.K. he did alot with his faith, even have a fiest for him.
NickD
Joshua wasn't exactly nice killing every man, woman, and child in Jericho. The only problem I have with wars, is that we send our kids to fight other kids when we should be sending our leaders to do battle and somehow, government contractors seem to get awfully rich. And going to Harvard should not be cause to avoid the draft, now who did that? Certainly not Bush junior or Bill. Even Reagan got out of it by making war movies and so did John Wayne, my hat is off to Jimmy Stewart and Clark Cable.

So, exactly what does one do on a draft board since we don't seem to have a draft. Have that registration thing though that says we know you are there, but you better confirm it or we will send you to jail.

If there is a draft, should draft us old experienced guys rather than our kids, easiest to go there then to sit at home and be worried sick about that. Can't tell you how sick and worried I was when my younger brothers were drafted, that was far worse then going myself. Ha, and I wonder if I was as dumb and naive when I was 18 as my 18 year old kids are. But my memory tells me I knew a lot more then then I do now. And also a hell of a way to grow up.

And promising young girls a couple of bucks for college that can't even open a pickle jar by joining the guard, then sending them down to Texas for sevens weeks of MP school, sticking an M-16 that is too heavy for them to carry and shipping them off to Iraq! That is way too much for me, and I know of three tiny little girls that already happened to. And I do not feel giving up a golf game is justifiable compensation for that. Neither is screwing GI's out of college benefits, that is not new, also happened to me after my honorable discharge, but for some strange reason got a letter from the VA about three years ago that I am eligible for full benefits. Should go back to college and learn basket weaving since my high paying engineering job was moved to China. Or maybe I should learn how to grow rice.

Lot's of wonderful people in this world, hard working, moral, and good people, but can't say the same for our leaders. Why is that?

By the way, God helps those that help themselves was not in the bible. Benjamin Franklin said that and it was people like him that gave a new nation it's freedom, even George Washington suffered all the hardships with his troops and it was because of men like him the constitution made the president the commander in chief of the armed services. Wonder what our forefathers would say if they were around today?

Would you really buy a used car from Hillary? We finally got to the point where we could compete with the Japanese and Bill and Hillary got some huge campaign funds from the Chinese that was never investigated, makes a guy wonder whom they are really working for, and yes, people will say anything to become president.

Study your civics test and learn what a really great country this has intended to be. Take an interest in politics and help make it that way.

feejo
If we are a permanent resident, we do not need to do the oath, so they can't send you to war until you are citizen? If I marry on a K1 I can wait 10 years to decide to get residency or am I obligated after 3 years?
flames9
As a permanent resident and under the age of 26, you still have to sign up for the Selective Service
http://www.sss.gov/FSwho.htm
NickD
QUOTE(flames9 @ May 23 2008, 08:29 AM) *
As a permanent resident and under the age of 26, you still have to sign up for the Selective Service
http://www.sss.gov/FSwho.htm


Ha, only if you are a male even though recently the ERA has joined the military with some women even serving in combat roles. Women make even better fighter pilots than men as their bodies can withstand much higher G's without passing out. I wouldn't worry about the selective service, does seem kind of dumb in that even as a permanent resident you have to register, but if the draft ever comes back, all of us will be fighting. Bush is not being very wise by cutting GI benefits and sending National guard people to Iraq that are suppose to be here protecting us, so enlistments are way down, but if he does bring back the draft, that would be the end of him. The riots against the draft in the 60's almost made a worse war here than in Viet Nam. But it was easy to avoid the draft back then, just go to Harvard like Bush and Clinton did or knock up a girl before you were 18 and marry her.

My younger brother enlisted at 18, took college courses at night, free, the conned the army into sending him to medical school for three years with pay and all tuition paid, became an MD and spent his remaining years all over the world patching rather than inflicting wounds safe behind enemy lines. Retired at the ripe old age of 43 with colonials pay and today can do anything he wants to. Also got married and had three daughters that had a world education. He tried one of those HMO clinics and was expected to see 24 patients a day, told them this is BS and quit after three days. Just works maybe 5 or 6 days a month on call where he loves to patch up severe accident victims and is doing quite well, thanks to the army.

Just saying, all aspects of the military are not bad.
kmineo
feejo-

You don't have to ever get a US citizenship, you could continue on the green card for ages. So no you don't have to get it after 3 years after you are married.
Feliz
applicants can't just declare he's Jehovah's witness or buddist and change oath, USCIS require tonns of proof that applicant attends regularly from church etc etc.

plus even if there is such a draft, women, older men and people with useful professions and skills most likely will be used for noncombattant things from cooking\nursing to translations and highly professional tasks, like surgeries, engineering, biochem, programming etc,

the only guys in real danger of being drafted and sent to battle are young healthy males up untill 32 with no other army-applicable qualifications.
Gulskjegg
The correct interpretation of the Commandment is "Thou shalt not lie in wait for innocent blood", or in other words, dont murder someone. Killing in defense is perfectly acceptable in the eyes of God. For more on this see Timothy 5:8 "If anyone does not take care of his own relatives, especially his immediate family, he has denied the faith and is worse then an unbeliever." Put simply, we are not second class citizens. If someone breaks into your home to do harm to your family, you are fully authorized to correct that person as to the error of his ways. This correction can range anywhere from words, a baseball bat, or a 12-gauge shotgun.

As far as a draft, please see the Universal National Service Act of 2007. This "draft" will include females and males aged 18 to 42...no deferments. This bill has been cruising through congress since 2003 and is waiting for the next "attack" on America. The Selective Service System has also been fully activated, staffed, and funded and is ready to spring into action at a moments notice. If you are a citizen, register as an objector ASAP. If you are not a citizen, be prepared to return to the nation you came from. And everyone, regardless of status, should be prepared to renounce your American citizenship when America begins to recall all subjects abroad for military service.
NickD
If you are not a citizen, be prepared to return to the nation you came from.

Provided that nation is not Austria, Mexico, Denmark, Germany, Greece, Israel, Malaysia, the Republic of China (Taiwan), Russia, Singapore, South Korea, Norway, Sweden, and Switzerland, that all have a national service act.

The Universal National Service Act of 2003 had only two congressman in favor, 402 against and such a bill requires 2/3rd's for passing before going to the senate. I failed just a tad short in passing in the house of representatives, don't you agree.

The Universal National Service Act of 2007 only has two sponsors and never even got off the ground, 80% of Americans are against the war in Iraq and any congressman that votes for a bill at this time will be committing political suicide.

But as a male between the ages of 18 and 25 whether a permanent resident or a US citizen, you still have to register with selective service, and there is a stiff penalty if you don't! It was up to a $10,000 fine or one year in jail for a US citizen have no idea for a permanent resident.

My neighbor, a woman in the Army National Guard is a captain soon to be promoted to a major, got her PA training from the guard and is doing quite well at our clinic. But she may be going to Iraq, will be well protected working inside of a well guarded base, but 18 months will be a long time to be separated from her seven year old daughter.

Her husband is also a captain in the national guard, said if his wife gets promoted he will have to salute her. Ha, just responded, my military days are over, but my wife is a general, and I am just a private.

Somebody teed off just a hand full of terrorists and would like to know who, sure wasn't me, but to go into Iraq was a imperialistic act that is contrary to the traditions of this country by making up false statements. The arrogance between the FBI and the CIA could have prevented this disaster so now we have the DHS that also took over immigration making a mess out of that. Our leaders certainly have made a big mess in this country and that new congress that promised to do something about it backed off once in office.

Even old man Bush had the wisdom not to go into Baghdad during Desert Storm, but couldn't talk any sense into his spoil brat kid, he knew Iraq would be impossible to control. No war has been declared by congress since WW II, and those that we did fight in were likewise disasters for this country. Hopefully we will have a better future and Americans will take a greater interest in our government and less in Britney. Maybe the new immigrants will.


This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.