Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: I want my oligarch!
VisaJourney.com > General Discussion Area > Regional Discussion > Russia

mox
MOSCOW — All Elena Larionova wants is a rich husband. It doesn't matter if he is fat, bald, a drunk or all of the above. Love doesn't interest the striking, blond 24-year-old. Stability does.

If she plays her cards right, she says, she might land herself the biggest Russian catch of all: an oligarch.

That's why she is teetering in her stiletto black boots in a Moscow dance studio on a Wednesday night after work, her ankles bound by an elastic band, ensuring that she can only take baby steps.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/sto...ernational/home
slim
It never ceases to amaze me what great lengths some women will go to for this kind of thing.

I hope they realize, looking back, what they missed out on.

Or, maybe they'll get exactly what they want. To each his own. And anyway, hats off to the enterprising Russians who are able to make money off of what girls here are doing for free.
mox
QUOTE(slim @ Mar 19 2008, 11:16 AM) *
It never ceases to amaze me what great lengths some women will go to for this kind of thing.

I hope they realize, looking back, what they missed out on.

Sounds like a lot of them wind up with exactly what they were trying to avoid...destitute and out on the street with kids and no alimony, all because another woman did to her what she did to the previous woman.

QUOTE
And anyway, hats off to the enterprising Russians who are able to make money off of what girls here are doing for free.

LOL yep.
Kazan' Tiger
In a single word... Pathetic. wacko.gif
manwithabeard
People like to say "It is Russia." I prefer, "It was communism." I think we can't understand how lacking in basic things and basic comfort people of the Soviet Union suffered for 80 years.

Now the younger people are mesmerized by hedonism, high style, material goods and money. It's called "New Russia." It's glitzy, gaudy and greedy with some self-destructive tendencies thrown in. And Russian men's appetite for attractive women is a bottomless pit with most average Joe types having 2 or 3 lovers and a wife...so imagine what a Russian billionaire would be like! I'm thinking harem. I'm thinking revolving door dolls.

The cautionary tale for American men is to avoid the "gold diggers" and New Russia women. That's why when I was single I would never go on those big city, mega match-making tours like "A Foreign Affair" that makes the Moscow, St. Petersburg, Kiev circuit.
Kazan' Tiger
Remembering a scene from a pizza parlour last summer... Two truly ugly fat men well into their late 40s or early 50s were sitting there with two gorgeous girls in their 20s. The girls kept giggling, laughing, and having one drink after the other. I made a comment to Alla. She took a look and said, "Yes, I know those men. They are directors of building company. I made business with them several years ago. Foolish girls think these men will leave their wives for them. In some times, these girls will become clever and go from them. But men will always find new lovers. It's Russia!"

QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 19 2008, 03:19 PM) *
People like to say "It is Russia." I prefer, "It was communism." I think we can't understand how lacking in basic things and basic comfort people of the Soviet Union suffered for 80 years.

Now the younger people are mesmerized by hedonism, high style, material goods and money. It's called "New Russia." It's glitzy, gaudy and greedy with some self-destructive tendencies thrown in. And Russian men's appetite for attractive women is a bottomless pit with most average Joe types having 2 or 3 lovers and a wife...so imagine what a Russian billionaire would be like! I'm thinking harem. I'm thinking revolving door dolls.

The cautionary tale for American men is to avoid the "gold diggers" and New Russia women. That's why when I was single I would never go on those big city, mega match-making tours like "A Foreign Affair" that makes the Moscow, St. Petersburg, Kiev circuit.
Satellite
QUOTE(slim @ Mar 19 2008, 11:16 AM) *
It never ceases to amaze me what great lengths some women will go to for this kind of thing.
I agree! Maybe not an oligarch, but another 100,000 Russian women have themselves posted on marriage websites for mostly the same reasons as this lady in the night club and going through many of the same sacrifices in terms of bald, fat, etc.

QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 19 2008, 11:34 AM) *
In a single word... Pathetic. wacko.gif
Agreed again! On both counts.
mox
QUOTE(Satellite @ Mar 19 2008, 04:00 PM) *
I agree! Maybe not an oligarch, but another 100,000 Russian women have themselves posted on marriage websites for mostly the same reasons as this lady in the night club and going through many of the same sacrifices in terms of bald, fat, etc.

I don't necessarily agree with this. There's a kernel of truth in it, but I think the goals for Russian "brides" are a bit different. For starters, money doesn't seem to be of primary importance. If it were, we'd see a pretty different demographic even in this forum than we see now. But I see a demographic that ranges from high-paying white-collar to students.

Stability, however, is a goal both groups seem to share. But there are differences in perspective. For FSU women dating Western men, it seems as if stability is more broadly interpreted than just money. The women in the article seem to think that the one thing means the other, which is why most of them are going to wind up miserable at best, and turning tricks on the streets of Moscow for drug money at worst.
franklie
QUOTE(mox @ Mar 19 2008, 12:55 PM) *
MOSCOW — All Elena Larionova wants is a rich husband. It doesn't matter if he is fat, bald, a drunk or all of the above. Love doesn't interest the striking, blond 24-year-old. Stability does.

If she plays her cards right, she says, she might land herself the biggest Russian catch of all: an oligarch.

That's why she is teetering in her stiletto black boots in a Moscow dance studio on a Wednesday night after work, her ankles bound by an elastic band, ensuring that she can only take baby steps.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/sto...ernational/home



very similar to this story Lessons in Love: The Millionaire Hunters

both articles were written by women; one in Canada, the other in the US.
Kazan' Tiger
Every Russian woman I have ever met, with the exception of two, summed up their desire to marry a Western man for that reason: Stability. The two exceptions told me they will always be in it solely for money.

When Alla & I first were getting acquainted and I asked her what she wanted out of a relationship, this is what she listed in order:
  • Stable life
  • Tender, loving, faithful, and strong husband with good humour.
  • Loving father for her children that will love them the same as he would his.
When I asked her about money, this is how she put it. "I have never needed to have rich man. I only want enough money to know all normal bills get paid every month. If we have extra, I would like to be able to have rest once a year. I only want to not have to worry every night before I sleep. It is simple what I want, I believe."
QUOTE(mox @ Mar 19 2008, 07:25 PM) *
QUOTE(Satellite @ Mar 19 2008, 04:00 PM) *
I agree! Maybe not an oligarch, but another 100,000 Russian women have themselves posted on marriage websites for mostly the same reasons as this lady in the night club and going through many of the same sacrifices in terms of bald, fat, etc.

I don't necessarily agree with this. There's a kernel of truth in it, but I think the goals for Russian "brides" are a bit different. For starters, money doesn't seem to be of primary importance. If it were, we'd see a pretty different demographic even in this forum than we see now. But I see a demographic that ranges from high-paying white-collar to students.

Stability, however, is a goal both groups seem to share. But there are differences in perspective. For FSU women dating Western men, it seems as if stability is more broadly interpreted than just money. The women in the article seem to think that the one thing means the other, which is why most of them are going to wind up miserable at best, and turning tricks on the streets of Moscow for drug money at worst.
Jason-Sasha
This is extremely pathetic. And any smart man would leave this woman where he finds her.
groovlstk
The Exile did a funny piece on such women awhile back:

In THE STERVA, you play a young female who arrives in Moscow from the provinces, vulnerable, poor, and lonely, but full of sex appeal and ambition.

Love the rendering of the baby crying for sushi rolls smile.gif
mox
QUOTE(groovlstk @ Mar 20 2008, 12:59 PM) *
The Exile did a funny piece on such women awhile back:

In THE STERVA, you play a young female who arrives in Moscow from the provinces, vulnerable, poor, and lonely, but full of sex appeal and ambition.

Love the rendering of the baby crying for sushi rolls smile.gif

LOL!

You cleverly arrange it so that when your sponsor pulls up to your podezd in his migalka-toting Ferrari, you are "caught" having kinky exhibitionist sex with a cute passerby. If you can manage your rich sponsor's anger, you'll be sure to turn around his anger into his begging for forgiveness...and a Nokia mobile phone worth 37,000 rubles! A super-STERVA would turn his anger around and torture him for a Mini Cooper! So, are you STERVA enough?
Satellite
QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 20 2008, 10:30 AM) *
Every Russian woman I have ever met, with the exception of two, summed up their desire to marry a Western man for that reason: Stability.
[*]Stable life
[*]Tender, loving, faithful, and strong husband with good humor.
[*]Loving father for her children that will love them the same as he would his.
What makes your fiancée or anyone else for that matter think these things can't be found in Russia? The government has been very stable under Putin as long as you are not forging your way into politics, involved in proprietary business, or doing something a majority of hard working Russians do not engage in.
I'll admit Russia's men have a lot of beautiful ladies to choose from and can avoid the ladies who have been divorced or have kids, but that doesn't mean there aren't decent husband to be found.

QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 20 2008, 10:30 AM) *
I only want enough money to know all normal bills get paid every month. If we have extra, I would like to be able to have rest once a year. I only want to not have to worry every night before I sleep. It is simple what I want, I believe.
Despite what I said above, having enough money to pay the bills so you can sleep at night does not happen in Russia. Likewise based on statistical and psychological analysis here in this country financial troubles increase divorce and ruin stability.

So I stand firm that you need some money, the kind of money the average American makes in America, that guy who is living the American dream, owns his home, has two cars, and goes on vacation once a year. None of which happen for the majority of Russians no matter how much or how hard they work.
Thus this crazy notion of stability you guys have made up, really just boils down money. And stability is certainly worth sacrificing for.
Kazan' Tiger
Yes, sure, on simplest terms it is money. But to want enough money to exist and live are a far cry from asking for (or even expecting) a new BMW for a birthday gift. Thus the difference between wanting stability versus money.

As for my Alla, no, she could not find all of the things on her list in Russia. Men that she met wanted nothing to do with her two children or pretty much admitted they wanted her only for physical reasons. She had numerous offers.
QUOTE(Satellite @ Mar 20 2008, 09:07 PM) *
QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 20 2008, 10:30 AM) *
Every Russian woman I have ever met, with the exception of two, summed up their desire to marry a Western man for that reason: Stability.
[*]Stable life
[*]Tender, loving, faithful, and strong husband with good humor.
[*]Loving father for her children that will love them the same as he would his.
What makes your fiancée or anyone else for that matter think these things can't be found in Russia? The government has been very stable under Putin as long as you are not forging your way into politics, involved in proprietary business, or doing something a majority of hard working Russians do not engage in.
I'll admit Russia's men have a lot of beautiful ladies to choose from and can avoid the ladies who have been divorced or have kids, but that doesn't mean there aren't decent husband to be found.

QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 20 2008, 10:30 AM) *
I only want enough money to know all normal bills get paid every month. If we have extra, I would like to be able to have rest once a year. I only want to not have to worry every night before I sleep. It is simple what I want, I believe.
Despite what I said above, having enough money to pay the bills so you can sleep at night does not happen in Russia. Likewise based on statistical and psychological analysis here in this country financial troubles increase divorce and ruin stability.

So I stand firm that you need some money, the kind of money the average American makes in America, that guy who is living the American dream, owns his home, has two cars, and goes on vacation once a year. None of which happen for the majority of Russians no matter how much or how hard they work.
Thus this crazy notion of stability you guys have made up, really just boils down money. And stability is certainly worth sacrificing for.
mox
QUOTE(Satellite @ Mar 20 2008, 06:07 PM) *
So I stand firm that you need some money, the kind of money the average American makes in America, that guy who is living the American dream, owns his home, has two cars, and goes on vacation once a year. None of which happen for the majority of Russians no matter how much or how hard they work.
Thus this crazy notion of stability you guys have made up, really just boils down money. And stability is certainly worth sacrificing for.

Well...duh. Once you get past the bottom layer of Maslow's hierarchy of needs, everything else is about money unless you happen to live in the wilderness, hunt your own food, and build your own dwelling. This isn't just for Russian women, it's for everyone. Of course it all boils down to money.

I guess I don't understand the point you're making, unless it's "money makes the world go 'round."
slim
QUOTE(mox @ Mar 19 2008, 02:28 PM) *
Sounds like a lot of them wind up with exactly what they were trying to avoid...destitute and out on the street with kids and no alimony, all because another woman did to her what she did to the previous woman.


Just like the movie Showgirls. "Someone younger, who wants it more, will always be there to push you down the stairs."

Basically it boils down to the girl reaching that point in her life where she realizes it's not the money that's going to make her happy. But, to most Russian girls, even a student in the U.S. is rich compared to a guy in Russia with a decent job. Sure, the 100,000 internet profiled ladies may be looking for some stability, but even they know having an American student working two part time jobs is going to provide more stability than the average Russian guy working full time.

And to say that Russia has become "stable" is completely inaccurate. Sure, it has now. But, every Russian woman can remember a time in her life where she was unsure of how she was going to care for herself and children in the future. That hasn't happened here for a long time. It was less than 20 years ago in Russia and is just now starting to get more stable. That's not exactly a guarantee for the longterm stability that is "nice" when choosing a mate and place to set up shop for rearing a family.

Bottom line is stability is created by money. To say a woman wants stability but not necessarily money can be accurate, but how does she get that stability without having some money? By having a higher stability base. One like what we have here in the U.S. where even a student has a place to live, a car, food to eat, etc. etc. etc. And not only that, but they have the potential to, very easily, secure an environment that is conducive to raising a family very easily and without much effort or sacrifice. That simply does not exist in Russia due to the history and the unguaranteed future. The future of the U.S. is unquestionable.

Higher per-capita net worth. Plain and simple.

And as I always must argue.... 7th grade biology class. Women look for the most stable environment to create/complete a family, men look for their best looking option that agrees with them to do that.
eekee
I think in some ways it can be construed as a feminist issue as well... Sure, my guy makes a good salary for russia and would do even better in the states, but i never thought of finding someone to marry as a question of financial stability. I don't ever want to have to rely on a man financially.
Buck and Natalia
Kind of a sad thread. Sure Russian women want financial stability and the chaos of Russia in the 1990's, for those that remember those times, probably heightened this need........... much like it did for a generation of Depression era American women. As for the "gold-digging", this has always been present in all cultures has long as man has been on the face of this planet. In fact, in Victorian times, most English women married exactly for position and wealth. There was no secret about it. This was understood and expected by both sexes.

All I can say is that as the years tick by, financial stability becomes a very hollow substitute if love and passion is not present in the marriage.

Buck
manwithabeard
Stability is a quality of life that actually can not be bought. I hear the arguments that money buys stability but many many couples divorce with pockets full of money. Look at Paul McCartney's situation. Money can, paradoxically perhaps, destabilize a relationship when it becomes too important or too central to daily life. I still believe that a degree of challenge and struggle builds character and grounds people. Our own Russian women seem to confirm this fact. Money and the easy life will, more likely than not, push people apart and distract them from being close of heart, body and spirit.

Russian women want stable men and stable relationships. Such men seem difficult to find in Russia...from the ugly remnants of past Soviet ways; from cheap vodka and cognac; from a lack of leadership and growth opportunities; from a spiritually bankrupted male population, from the baggage their father's left them. You can add to the list if you'd like.

The kindly, true blue women of Russia (the majority I think) are not looking for gold or oligarchs or the easy life...they want real men--hearty, decisive, strong of character, sexual, generous with affection and praise, sober, emotionally available...and sometimes being a good old-fashioned dad. My wife has joked that she will be happy with me as long as we don't have to live in a "cardboard box" in America. But I know it's much more than that she's looking for from me...I see it when she looks at me or talks to me about our future life together. I see she has claimed me as her special man and that honors me, and challenges me to step up and be masculine in a good way for her.

Russian women, unlike most of the rest of modern women, are still following the traditional ways that our grandmothers followed. I accept that way of being...where the man is the head of the house...even if it pisses off my American sisters. I don't have to have it that way but I think many traditional Russian woman want it that way...and they want to relax and be cozy and comfortable with their man...a dependable man who won't desert them with young children...who won't beat them in a drunken state...who won't slip off to the local sauna for a quickie with his current under 30 lover. If they can find such a man, he will be awarded the key to the castle. He will be a king of sorts. And he will know what it feels like to be honored and revered as a man and a husband.

Now, we know Russian women are not passive or weak or child-like and won't be taken lightly...but they will stand shoulder-to-shoulder with us when we are at our best, and strong. They will be the queen of the house and strong in that unique Russian way...strong but feminine. Unlike our American sisters, they are not at all confused about who does what in marriage. And our Russian women don't need to be "self-actualized" and liberated. They need a partnership with a dependable stable man...and that's refreshingly simple.

My brothers, let's not misuse this opportunity. Let's put away our money and material wealth and the male-female relationships we have passively accepted over the last 30 years...and we tried to function in when we had American wives and girlfriends. That's behind us and now we need to step up and be the kind of men our Russian ladies want and need. We need to walk the talk...and create a new possibility with these unique women we've found in Mother Russia.

These Russian-American marriages are a grand experiment here in the USA, and I personally feel the gravity and significance of what we're trying to do...something beyond just another relationship...it feels bigger than that to me.
eekee
You can idealize Russian women all you want, but the reality is quite different. From what i've seen, it is these relations between men and women which CREATES men who are forever children. The men are never expected to do anything and their mothers always treat them like they're five years old, thus they have trouble taking responsibility for themselves. Hopefully this will change, but it's been this way for a long time. It was this way in my own family.
And to whoever said an American student makes more money than a Russian guy with a career... That's not really correct. Maybe in the provinces, but in Moscow and Petersburg that's not true at all.

QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 01:00 AM) *
Stability is a quality of life that actually can not be bought. I hear the arguments that money buys stability but many many couples divorce with pockets full of money. Look at Paul McCartney's situation. Money can, paradoxically perhaps, destabilize a relationship when it becomes too important or too central to daily life. I still believe that a degree of challenge and struggle builds character and grounds people. Our own Russian women seem to confirm this fact. Money and the easy life will, more likely than not, push people apart and distract them from being close of heart, body and spirit.

Russian women want stable men and stable relationships. Such men seem difficult to find in Russia...from the ugly remnants of past Soviet ways; from cheap vodka and cognac; from a lack of leadership and growth opportunities; from a spiritually bankrupted male population, from the baggage their father's left them. You can add to the list if you'd like.

The kindly, true blue women of Russia (the majority I think) are not looking for gold or oligarchs or the easy life...they want real men--hearty, decisive, strong of character, sexual, generous with affection and praise, sober, emotionally available...and sometimes being a good old-fashioned dad. My wife has joked that she will be happy with me as long as we don't have to live in a "cardboard box" in America. But I know it's much more than that she's looking for from me...I see it when she looks at me or talks to me about our future life together. I see she has claimed me as her special man and that honors me, and challenges me to step up and be masculine in a good way for her.

Russian women, unlike most of the rest of modern women, are still following the traditional ways that our grandmothers followed. I accept that way of being...where the man is the head of the house...even if it pisses off my American sisters. I don't have to have it that way but I think many traditional Russian woman want it that way...and they want to relax and be cozy and comfortable with their man...a dependable man who won't desert them with young children...who won't beat them in a drunken state...who won't slip off to the local sauna for a quickie with his current under 30 lover. If they can find such a man, he will be awarded the key to the castle. He will be a king of sorts. And he will know what it feels like to be honored and revered as a man and a husband.

Now, we know Russian women are not passive or weak or child-like and won't be taken lightly...but they will stand shoulder-to-shoulder with us when we are at our best, and strong. They will be the queen of the house and strong in that unique Russian way...strong but feminine. Unlike our American sisters, they are not at all confused about who does what in marriage. And our Russian women don't need to be "self-actualized" and liberated. They need a partnership with a dependable stable man...and that's refreshingly simple.

My brothers, let's not misuse this opportunity. Let's put away our money and material wealth and the male-female relationships we have passively accepted over the last 30 years...and we tried to function in when we had American wives and girlfriends. That's behind us and now we need to step up and be the kind of men our Russian ladies want and need. We need to walk the talk...and create a new possibility with these unique women we've found in Mother Russia.

These Russian-American marriages are a grand experiment here in the USA, and I personally feel the gravity and significance of what we're trying to do...something beyond just another relationship...it feels bigger than that to me.

manwithabeard
QUOTE(eekee @ Mar 22 2008, 04:02 AM) *
You can idealize Russian women all you want, but the reality is quite different. From what i've seen, it is these relations between men and women which CREATES men who are forever children. The men are never expected to do anything and their mothers always treat them like they're five years old, thus they have trouble taking responsibility for themselves. Hopefully this will change, but it's been this way for a long time. It was this way in my own family.
And to whoever said an American student makes more money than a Russian guy with a career... That's not really correct. Maybe in the provinces, but in Moscow and Petersburg that's not true at all.

QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 01:00 AM) *
Stability is a quality of life that actually can not be bought. I hear the arguments that money buys stability but many many couples divorce with pockets full of money. Look at Paul McCartney's situation. Money can, paradoxically perhaps, destabilize a relationship when it becomes too important or too central to daily life. I still believe that a degree of challenge and struggle builds character and grounds people. Our own Russian women seem to confirm this fact. Money and the easy life will, more likely than not, push people apart and distract them from being close of heart, body and spirit.

Russian women want stable men and stable relationships. Such men seem difficult to find in Russia...from the ugly remnants of past Soviet ways; from cheap vodka and cognac; from a lack of leadershipgr and growth opportunities; from a spiritually bankrupted male population, from the baggage their father's left them. You can add to the list if you'd like.

The kindly, true blue women of Russia (the majority I think) are not looking for gold or oligarchs or the easy life...they want real men--hearty, decisive, strong of character, sexual, generous with affection and praise, sober, emotionally available...and sometimes being a good old-fashioned dad. My wife has joked that she will be happy with me as long as we don't have to live in a "cardboard box" in America. But I know it's much more than that she's looking for from me...I see it when she looks at me or talks to me about our future life together. I see she has claimed me as her special man and that honors me, and challenges me to step up and be masculine in a good way for her.

Russian women, unlike most of the rest of modern women, are still following the traditional ways that our grandmothers followed. I accept that way of being...where the man is the head of the house...even if it pisses off my American sisters. I don't have to have it that way but I think many traditional Russian woman want it that way...and they want to relax and be cozy and comfortable with their man...a dependable man who won't desert them with young children...who won't beat them in a drunken state...who won't slip off to the local sauna for a quickie with his current under 30 lover. If they can find such a man, he will be awarded the key to the castle. He will be a king of sorts. And he will know what it feels like to be honored and revered as a man and a husband.

Now, we know Russian women are not passive or weak or child-like and won't be taken lightly...but they will stand shoulder-to-shoulder with us when we are at our best, and strong. They will be the queen of the house and strong in that unique Russian way...strong but feminine. Unlike our American sisters, they are not at all confused about who does what in marriage. And our Russian women don't need to be "self-actualized" and liberated. They need a partnership with a dependable stable man...and that's refreshingly simple.

My brothers, let's not misuse this opportunity. Let's put away our money and material wealth and the male-female relationships we have passively accepted over the last 30 years...and we tried to function in when we had American wives and girlfriends. That's behind us and now we need to step up and be the kind of men our Russian ladies want and need. We need to walk the talk...and create a new possibility with these unique women we've found in Mother Russia.

These Russian-American marriages are a grand experiment here in the USA, and I personally feel the gravity and significance of what we're trying to do...something beyond just another relationship...it feels bigger than that to me.


Neither one of us are sociologists but i would argue that blaming women for the problem with Russian men is an over-simplification of a complex issue. I would say the absence of a father in the home has been shown to be devastating to the sons who grow up in such a family in the USA. And frequently men in prisons are shown to come from fatherless homes. I suspect it's equally bad in Russia and probably far worse given that divorce is at 80% in Russia. And that does not count in the large number of common law style marriages when there is no legal marriage.

I don't idealize Russian women per se but in comparison to other non Russian women I have known. I'll leave it at that.

I personally think (and hope) that many Russian women can stand next to a strong man, and the relationship finds balance and evenness...and maybe even long-term happiness. The relationship's roles are clear and incongruity, and there is no competition for power and authority.

In your case, my understanding is you're not Russian but Belarusian...and i don't know if you can fairly compare the two cultures.
mox
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 09:41 AM) *
Neither one of us are sociologists but i would argue that blaming women for the problem with Russian men is an over-simplification of a complex issue.

I'll even take that one step further and say that entire volumes could be written on the problems with Russian men. Broken homes, alcoholism, drugs, a fragmented economy coupled with the pressures of being *the* provider, the ongoing repercussions of Afghanistan and Chechnya, etc, etc, etc. When you stop to think about how much Russian men have got working against them, it's a pretty amazing that the divorce rate is *only* 80%. (I'd love to know the demographic breakdown of that statistic. Would be interesting to see how it's distributed.) I don't envy the pressures placed on the Russian man, and the fact that the majority of Russian men can keep it together in the kind of environment they have to operate in is actually a testament to their collective character.
eekee
QUOTE(seanconneryii)
per se [/i]but in comparison to other non Russian women I have known. I'll leave it at that.

I personally think (and hope) that many Russian women can stand next to a strong man, and the relationship finds balance and evenness...and maybe even long-term happiness. The relationship's roles are clear and incongruity, and there is no competition for power and authority.

In your case, my understanding is you're not Russian but Belarusian...and i don't know if you can fairly compare the two cultures.


Belarusian family culture is identical to Russian family culture, although my mother swears that Russians are worse housekeepers and that Belarusians are much cleaner.
I've spent a lot of time in Russia itself as well, and have lived with Russian families and Russian friends. Of course women aren't totally to blame for men's actions, but constantly infantilizing them doesn't help either. Watch Ironia sudby--the scene where the guy comes back to Moscow and says to his mom that no woman is for him because no woman is as good as her and she just goes, "Oh, moi cynok!!"--total encapsulation of russian mother/son relationship.

My grandmother never forced my uncle to move out, let him do whatever he want and never blamed him for anything whereas she made my mom do all the housework and always punished her. After my grandparents died my uncle was totally incapacitated and he couldn't hold a job and lost the house (which he had never moved out of). Yeah, it's Belarusian family but it's really the same in that aspect. Trust me. I recognized so much about the way i was raised that had always made me think my mom was crazy and really different from all my friends' parents when i got to russia and lived with russians. You'd be hard-pressed to find 2 cultures more similar than Russian and Belarusian. The difference is that Russians will often see themselves as superior and Belarusians with strong national pride (those in the diaspora society my mother grew up in) are very bitter towards them. But just saying that i have Belarusian roots gets Russians really excited and they start talking about how my face is so slavic and then buy me drinks. I can speak to my mom in Russian and she'll answer me in Belarusian with pretty much complete mutual understanding--belarusian to me sounds like russian with a lot of soft sounds. We have the same religion and same food only belarusians love potatos more. Lukashenka wants to be president of a unified Belarus and Russian Federation. My grammar teacher said she's been everywhere in Belarus and practically never heard Belarusian--it's pretty much an endangered language at this point.

Also bear in mind that while you all have Russian ladies, i deal with a russian MAN every day (and sometimes his mom) and thus my perspective on this issue. smile.gif

Plus i don't think relationships need power balances or struggles--just, you know, equality. Sharing housework and childrearing equally, both bringing money to the home. That's my ideal.
mox
Just wanted to add...I didn't post this story to say "see what gold-diggers Russian women are?" It would be like someone posting a Britney Spears story and saying "see what bad mothers American women are?" If anything, it's an indictment of one of the negative side-effects capitalism has had on Muscovite/SP culture.
manwithabeard
QUOTE(eekee @ Mar 22 2008, 02:30 PM) *
QUOTE(seanconneryii)
per se [/i]but in comparison to other non Russian women I have known. I'll leave it at that.

I personally think (and hope) that many Russian women can stand next to a strong man, and the relationship finds balance and evenness...and maybe even long-term happiness. The relationship's roles are clear and incongruity, and there is no competition for power and authority.

In your case, my understanding is you're not Russian but Belarusian...and i don't know if you can fairly compare the two cultures.


Belarusian family culture is identical to Russian family culture, although my mother swears that Russians are worse housekeepers and that Belarusians are much cleaner.
I've spent a lot of time in Russia itself as well, and have lived with Russian families and Russian friends. Of course women aren't totally to blame for men's actions, but constantly infantilizing them doesn't help either. Watch Ironia sudby--the scene where the guy comes back to Moscow and says to his mom that no woman is for him because no woman is as good as her and she just goes, "Oh, moi cynok!!"--total encapsulation of russian mother/son relationship.

My grandmother never forced my uncle to move out, let him do whatever he want and never blamed him for anything whereas she made my mom do all the housework and always punished her. After my grandparents died my uncle was totally incapacitated and he couldn't hold a job and lost the house (which he had never moved out of). Yeah, it's Belarusian family but it's really the same in that aspect. Trust me. I recognized so much about the way i was raised that had always made me think my mom was crazy and really different from all my friends' parents when i got to russia and lived with russians. You'd be hard-pressed to find 2 cultures more similar than Russian and Belarusian. The difference is that Russians will often see themselves as superior and Belarusians with strong national pride (those in the diaspora society my mother grew up in) are very bitter towards them. But just saying that i have Belarusian roots gets Russians really excited and they start talking about how my face is so slavic and then buy me drinks. I can speak to my mom in Russian and she'll answer me in Belarusian with pretty much complete mutual understanding--belarusian to me sounds like russian with a lot of soft sounds. We have the same religion and same food only belarusians love potatos more. Lukashenka wants to be president of a unified Belarus and Russian Federation. My grammar teacher said she's been everywhere in Belarus and practically never heard Belarusian--it's pretty much an endangered language at this point.

Also bear in mind that while you all have Russian ladies, i deal with a russian MAN every day (and sometimes his mom) and thus my perspective on this issue. smile.gif

Plus i don't think relationships need power balances or struggles--just, you know, equality. Sharing housework and childrearing equally, both bringing money to the home. That's my ideal.

I don't know much about Belarus except I heard it's unfriendly to Americans and not easy to travel to. I never considered women from that country because of that negative street talk.

Your observations may be accurate within your frame of reference of living in an area of Russia...perhaps a bigger city. I don't know if your anecdotal stories reflect the entire country and the ways of the people living deeper inside Russia. But I don't completely disagree with you about Russian mothers.

I surmise it has a lot to do with guilt and shame around the absent father situation...so they want to over compensate with too much attention at home and the babying stuff. I don't see single American moms as any different. Too much nurturing and softer female energy without the counter-balancing of harder, tough love male energy will not produce ideal results in child rearing. Russian moms usually work long hard jobs so often grandmothers have to pick up the slack. The over arching culture may be a patriarchy but the day to day culture is a matriarchy. Must be confusing to young people over there.

You should remember the softer life is over once a boy turns 18 and goes into the Army. From what i hear it's a tough year with a lot harsh treatment. I think in a way that is a boy's right of passage in Russia...where he can no longer hide behind his mom's apron and must deal with the male side of his homeland.

Bobalouie
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 03:29 PM) *
QUOTE(eekee @ Mar 22 2008, 02:30 PM) *
QUOTE(seanconneryii)
per se [/i]but in comparison to other non Russian women I have known. I'll leave it at that.

I personally think (and hope) that many Russian women can stand next to a strong man, and the relationship finds balance and evenness...and maybe even long-term happiness. The relationship's roles are clear and incongruity, and there is no competition for power and authority.

In your case, my understanding is you're not Russian but Belarusian...and i don't know if you can fairly compare the two cultures.


Belarusian family culture is identical to Russian family culture, although my mother swears that Russians are worse housekeepers and that Belarusians are much cleaner.
I've spent a lot of time in Russia itself as well, and have lived with Russian families and Russian friends. Of course women aren't totally to blame for men's actions, but constantly infantilizing them doesn't help either. Watch Ironia sudby--the scene where the guy comes back to Moscow and says to his mom that no woman is for him because no woman is as good as her and she just goes, "Oh, moi cynok!!"--total encapsulation of russian mother/son relationship.

My grandmother never forced my uncle to move out, let him do whatever he want and never blamed him for anything whereas she made my mom do all the housework and always punished her. After my grandparents died my uncle was totally incapacitated and he couldn't hold a job and lost the house (which he had never moved out of). Yeah, it's Belarusian family but it's really the same in that aspect. Trust me. I recognized so much about the way i was raised that had always made me think my mom was crazy and really different from all my friends' parents when i got to russia and lived with russians. You'd be hard-pressed to find 2 cultures more similar than Russian and Belarusian. The difference is that Russians will often see themselves as superior and Belarusians with strong national pride (those in the diaspora society my mother grew up in) are very bitter towards them. But just saying that i have Belarusian roots gets Russians really excited and they start talking about how my face is so slavic and then buy me drinks. I can speak to my mom in Russian and she'll answer me in Belarusian with pretty much complete mutual understanding--belarusian to me sounds like russian with a lot of soft sounds. We have the same religion and same food only belarusians love potatos more. Lukashenka wants to be president of a unified Belarus and Russian Federation. My grammar teacher said she's been everywhere in Belarus and practically never heard Belarusian--it's pretty much an endangered language at this point.

Also bear in mind that while you all have Russian ladies, i deal with a russian MAN every day (and sometimes his mom) and thus my perspective on this issue. smile.gif

Plus i don't think relationships need power balances or struggles--just, you know, equality. Sharing housework and childrearing equally, both bringing money to the home. That's my ideal.

I don't know much about Belarus except I heard it's unfriendly to Americans and not easy to travel to. I never considered women from that country because of that negative street talk.

Your observations may be accurate within your frame of reference of living in an area of Russia...perhaps a bigger city. I don't know if your anecdotal stories reflect the entire country and the ways of the people living deeper inside Russia. But I don't completely disagree with you about Russian mothers.

I surmise it has a lot to do with guilt and shame around the absent father situation...so they want to over compensate with too much attention at home and the babying stuff. I don't see single American moms as any different. Too much nurturing and softer female energy without the counter-balancing of harder, tough love male energy will not produce ideal results in child rearing. Russian moms usually work long hard jobs so often grandmothers have to pick up the slack. The over arching culture may be a patriarchy but the day to day culture is a matriarchy. Must be confusing to young people over there.

You should remember the softer life is over once a boy turns 18 and goes into the Army. From what i hear it's a tough year with a lot harsh treatment. I think in a way that is a boy's right of passage in Russia...where he can no longer hide behind his mom's apron and must deal with the male side of his homeland.


Dont know if I agree with this last paragraph. While it is well known that the treatment is harsh to say the least, not every man goes to the army. If you are affluent and dont want to go, you pay a doctor to list you as unfit. Or, you go to university and that excludes you from service. Even the boys who do go into the service do not escape their mothers even then. If your family does not send you food and clothing and bedding and most other necessary things, you dont have them during your time in the Russian military. Parents often follow their children around and provide for them, even when they are in the military.
mox
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 01:29 PM) *
You should remember the softer life is over once a boy turns 18 and goes into the Army. From what i hear it's a tough year with a lot harsh treatment. I think in a way that is a boy's right of passage in Russia...where he can no longer hide behind his mom's apron and must deal with the male side of his homeland.

I don't believe a year of much of anything is going to undo 18 years of whatever conditioning a boy gets from his family/mother, but I do agree that military service would have some kind of impact.
Kazan' Tiger
Alla told me it can be brutal, especially for the fresh. She said beatings occur and other very harsh hazing rituals take place. Nothing subsides until you are high enough to become a beater rather than a beatee.
QUOTE(mox @ Mar 22 2008, 10:12 PM) *
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 01:29 PM) *
You should remember the softer life is over once a boy turns 18 and goes into the Army. From what i hear it's a tough year with a lot harsh treatment. I think in a way that is a boy's right of passage in Russia...where he can no longer hide behind his mom's apron and must deal with the male side of his homeland.

I don't believe a year of much of anything is going to undo 18 years of whatever conditioning a boy gets from his family/mother, but I do agree that military service would have some kind of impact.

manwithabeard
QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 22 2008, 11:13 PM) *
Alla told me it can be brutal, especially for the fresh. She said beatings occur and other very harsh hazing rituals take place. Nothing subsides until you are high enough to become a beater rather than a beatee.
QUOTE(mox @ Mar 22 2008, 10:12 PM) *
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 01:29 PM) *
You should remember the softer life is over once a boy turns 18 and goes into the Army. From what i hear it's a tough year with a lot harsh treatment. I think in a way that is a boy's right of passage in Russia...where he can no longer hide behind his mom's apron and must deal with the male side of his homeland.

I don't believe a year of much of anything is going to undo 18 years of whatever conditioning a boy gets from his family/mother, but I do agree that military service would have some kind of impact.


My wife told me it used to be two years in the Army but there were so many suicides Putin cut it to one year. It may only be one year...but it's a long year I imagine.
Kazan' Tiger
Alla mentioned the suicides too! Makes me glad, I never had to go though it! unsure.gif
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 11:38 PM) *
QUOTE(Kazan @ Mar 22 2008, 11:13 PM) *
Alla told me it can be brutal, especially for the fresh. She said beatings occur and other very harsh hazing rituals take place. Nothing subsides until you are high enough to become a beater rather than a beatee.
QUOTE(mox @ Mar 22 2008, 10:12 PM) *
QUOTE(seanconneryii @ Mar 22 2008, 01:29 PM) *
You should remember the softer life is over once a boy turns 18 and goes into the Army. From what i hear it's a tough year with a lot harsh treatment. I think in a way that is a boy's right of passage in Russia...where he can no longer hide behind his mom's apron and must deal with the male side of his homeland.

I don't believe a year of much of anything is going to undo 18 years of whatever conditioning a boy gets from his family/mother, but I do agree that military service would have some kind of impact.


My wife told me it used to be two years in the Army but there were so many suicides Putin cut it to one year. It may only be one year...but it's a long year I imagine.

peejay
QUOTE(eekee @ Mar 22 2008, 01:30 PM) *
Belarusian family culture is identical to Russian family culture, although my mother swears that Russians are worse housekeepers and that Belarusians are much cleaner.
I've spent a lot of time in Russia itself as well, and have lived with Russian families and Russian friends. Of course women aren't totally to blame for men's actions, but constantly infantilizing them doesn't help either. Watch Ironia sudby--the scene where the guy comes back to Moscow and says to his mom that no woman is for him because no woman is as good as her and she just goes, "Oh, moi cynok!!"--total encapsulation of russian mother/son relationship.

My grandmother never forced my uncle to move out, let him do whatever he want and never blamed him for anything whereas she made my mom do all the housework and always punished her. After my grandparents died my uncle was totally incapacitated and he couldn't hold a job and lost the house (which he had never moved out of). Yeah, it's Belarusian family but it's really the same in that aspect. Trust me. I recognized so much about the way i was raised that had always made me think my mom was crazy and really different from all my friends' parents when i got to russia and lived with russians. You'd be hard-pressed to find 2 cultures more similar than Russian and Belarusian. The difference is that Russians will often see themselves as superior and Belarusians with strong national pride (those in the diaspora society my mother grew up in) are very bitter towards them. But just saying that i have Belarusian roots gets Russians really excited and they start talking about how my face is so slavic and then buy me drinks. I can speak to my mom in Russian and she'll answer me in Belarusian with pretty much complete mutual understanding--belarusian to me sounds like russian with a lot of soft sounds. We have the same religion and same food only belarusians love potatos more. Lukashenka wants to be president of a unified Belarus and Russian Federation. My grammar teacher said she's been everywhere in Belarus and practically never heard Belarusian--it's pretty much an endangered language at this point.

Also bear in mind that while you all have Russian ladies, i deal with a russian MAN every day (and sometimes his mom) and thus my perspective on this issue. smile.gif

Plus i don't think relationships need power balances or struggles--just, you know, equality. Sharing housework and childrearing equally, both bringing money to the home. That's my ideal.

Both of my mom's parents immigrated to the USA from Byelorussia (now Belarus). From my limited observations, modern Russian and Belarusian cultures are almost indistinguishable. What differences I find are more regional than cultural. Russian and Belarusian surnames are different as are Ukrainian surnames even though all 3 are Slavic peoples. As far as the languages go, my mom's relatives that I met on my many visits to Belarus speak Russian. Of course they use some Belarusian words sprinkled in with it, but for the most part the Belarusian language is dead in Belarus despite attempts by the modern day Belarusian government to revive it. My grandparents were ethnic Byelorussian peasants from the countryside that immigrated to the USA as subjects of the Imperial Russian Czar Nicholas before the Bolshevik Revolution and I'm not even sure how much pure Belarusian language they spoke even back then. I think the pure Belarusian language has been dying out for a long time since being dominated by Russia stretching back into the times of the Czars.

My wife is originally from Russian Siberia, but moved to what was then the Byelorussian Soviet Socialist Republic in 1984 when her ex-husband was posted there while in the Soviet military. She took Belarusian citizenship after the USSR broke apart and was living there when I met her. This is very common throughout the former USSR. Some of my Belarusian cousins have lived and worked in Russia many years before the USSR broke up and took Russian citizenship after the USSR broke up. My wife could probably reclaim her birthright Russian citizenship if she wanted to, but wants to keep her Belarusian citizenship even though she wasn't born there.

One of the most obvious differences I noticed is that my Russian wife speaks English and Russian with a distinctively different accent than my Belarusian relatives do. There is definitely a regional difference in the accents. Several of my Belarusian relatives also speak English and it is quite noticable the difference in their accents compared to my wife's. I also detect a distinctive difference in accent when they both speak Russian to each other.

Kudos to you Eekee for learning to speak Russian. Even though I have been exposed to the Russian language since birth and am married to a Russian woman for 4 years, I am not fluent enough to hold a conversation even though I know quite a lot of words and short phrases. My American born mom and aunts often spoke Russian with my grandparents, but my mom and her sisters almost always spoke English among themselves. The Russian/Belarusian language died out in our family after both of my grandparents died within months of each other in 1967. My mom and aunts were all married to guys that spoke only English and there was really no incentive to perpetuate the Russian language in our family. Houston, TX never really had an ethnic enclave of Slavic peoples large enough to perpetuate the language and culture here. So most of the American children and grandchildren of the Slavic immigrants of that era are assimilated into America with little connection to the old country. The Cold War and the stigma of being from that region of the world in that era also contributed to American assimilation and rejection of the old country.

I took my first trip to Belarus in 1993 with my mom and several of her cousins that were born in America or immigrated from Belarus at a young age in order to meet our Belarusian relatives for the first time. It was the first time anyone had ventured to travel there. None of our family members had ever traveled there since immigrating decades ago nor had their children/grandchildren. It was an experience. My mom had always wanted to see where her parents were born and to meet her relatives there. Since then I had several opportunities to travel throughout Belarus and Russia to meet several of my relatives. In 2002 I took a train trip with my cousins from Minsk to Moscow to St. Petersburg and back to Minsk. It was impressive.



This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.